Wrestling Forum banner
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 31 Posts

Choke2Death

· Registered
Joined
·
23,172 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
I've been wondering about this topic for a while and I wanna know what everyone else here thinks. The topic title makes it clear.

Basically, police decide to one day reopen the case and they find some sort of evidence that suggests Chris Benoit is innocent and he & his family were, in fact, murdered by an intruder. Now that's not what the question is.

The question is, how would Vince react and would he continue keeping his distance from Benoit's name or would he acknowledge the work police have been doing, lift the Benoit ban and let him be an open topic in commentary, video packages and so on?

As it is, the ban is in full force and the latest 'Vintage Collection' features a match of Finlay from 1998 where he screams Benoit's name during a rest hold. On this 'Vintage' release, the sound is muted when Finaly mentions Benoit and they have even gone as far as censoring his lips to avoid lip-reading.

And most importantly, if anybody is going to enter this topic just to say "he's not innocent, he did it", then just leave before posting because this is strictly imagination and a "what if" thread, similar to ones such as "What if Owen Hart didn't do the stunt", "what if Eddie Guerrero was still alive" and etc.

Since Benoit-related threads rarely go down well, I'll repeat this once again: This is NOT about Benoit's legacy, Hall of Fame induction, him being recognized as a wrestler, being a murderer or what happened that weekend. It's simply a question regarding what would happen IF police reopened the case and suggested that Benoit is not guilty of the murders. Specifically, Vince's reaction and how he would treat Chris Benoit's career and name in historic and promotional manner.

-------------------------

To add my opinion, I think Vince would not make it a big deal or announce anything about it anywhere but he would naturally let Benoit's name be mentioned like normal again. For instance, during the Royal Rumble month, they'll mention his #1 entry victory along with Shawn Michaels blatantly rather than subliminally, show him in video packages when necessary and display his pictures like normal on their site and at points where it only makes sense such as the Royal Rumble 2004 page and Wrestlemania XX. A Hall of Fame induction would probably happen a few years from the day he's ruled out as suspect behind the tragedy.
 
Sorry to disappoint but its a pretty pointless question. How would the world react if it found out that Hitler didn't order the genocide and he was merely a puppet? Who knows. Too crazy to speculate. It was an open and shut case. We could speculate if there was mystery surrounding the deaths, but there isnt.
 
ridiculous thread dude. theres a documentary on youtube, i suggest u watch it. benoits brain was massively fucked up, he just hid it well. benoits dad is all over the program. the dude was seen walking around his yard with flowers around his neck before he flipped out.
 
Save
If he were found innocent?

Hall Of Fame 2013, Benoit 3 Disc Box Set and his profile would be put back in on WWE.com.

Seriously though, I would imagine WWE would still continue to ignore Benoit. Maybe his name wouldn't be taboo in WWE, but I don;t think they would mention him, in order to stay away from that topic.
 
Discussion starter · #5 ·
Sorry to disappoint but its a pretty pointless question. How would the world react if it found out that Hitler didn't order the genocide and he was merely a puppet? Who knows. Too crazy to speculate. It was an open and shut case. We could speculate if there was mystery surrounding the deaths, but there isnt.
Most questions in forums would be pointless if we simply went off reality and facts. But that's not what forums are for, so why not just discuss it using imagination?

There's lots of threads all around here that ask questions such as "What if ___ never went to X-promotion", "What if ___ didn't get injured" and "How would you book [insert event]". These questions are pointless if you look at them the same way you do here but that's the point of forums. You discuss things that never/wont happen(ed).

ridiculous thread dude. theres a documentary on youtube, i suggest u watch it. benoits brain was massively fucked up, he just hid it well. benoits dad is all over the program. the dude was seen walking around his yard with flowers around his neck before he flipped out.
I'm not questioning the investigation or the conclusion. I'm just saying IF he was innocent. Use your imagination.
 
Chill guys, OP knows the evidence is pretty much all in and Benoit did it. That's why this is a hypothetical question.

I think WWE would slowly begin incorporating Benoit matches and segments into its DVDs and flashbacks, but Vince would never publicly redeem him if that were to happen.
 
I think the real question to ask is why are so many wrestling fans headcases who continue to idolise a murderer?
 
Save
I think the real question to ask is why are so many wrestling fans headcases who continue to idolise a murderer?
I find it abhorrent as well, but people idolize and become infatuated with serial killers all the time. At least Benoit had talent and seemed like a good guy before his brain turned to mush.
 
I think the real question to ask is why are so many wrestling fans headcases who continue to idolise a murderer?
Because everyone is entitled to their opinion regarding whether as a fan they should remember one tragic weekend - Or to respect his outstanding talent as a performer and what he gave to the industry.

Chris Benoit is my favourite Professional Wrestler of all time. I choose not to remember the negatives of his life but the positives, as one should with others they look up to, love or idolise.

OP:

It's difficult to tell with something as sensitive as this. I expect WWE would not change anything at all. Remember there are still Nancy's and Chris' families who grieve to this day. If they'd like Benoit's name to be mentioned after his death is down to them I would expect. Much like Owen Hart's ex-wife not wishing for Owen to be referred to or even inducted into the HOF.
 
Discussion starter · #12 ·
No one is keeping it open... the question is purely hypothetical, intended to spark a discussion.
Exactly. Seems like a lot of people have reading comprehension problems. "WHY ARE YOU GLORIFYING A MURDERER?" when I didn't even give an OPINION on Chris Benoit as a person, wrestler or otherwise.

Seriously, stop derailing this topic if you're just going to post something irrelevant to the discussion. I never said a thing about Benoit as a person or even wrestler, positive or negative. This is a hypothetical question to create some discussion. If your contribution is simply "stop talking about benoit" or "why do you like this murderer?", then get out of here and post in a topic that suits your needs.
 
Sorry to disappoint but its a pretty pointless question. How would the world react if it found out that Hitler didn't order the genocide and he was merely a puppet? Who knows. Too crazy to speculate. It was an open and shut case. We could speculate if there was mystery surrounding the deaths, but there isnt.
That Hitler comparison is really bad. To answer the OP, the WWE won't allow the case to be reopened.
 
Save
You would slowly start seeing mentions of Benoit in DVDs, on their website and so on. I don't think Vince McMahon and the WWE would fully come out and mention the case again. It'd more an likely be one of those situations where we are all are treated like idiots and management would act is if never happened.
 
I think they would still really keep it on the down low. After all if the case was somehow re-opened and new evidence supported an innocent Benoit, who knows if you can trust that fully? There might be more evidence later confirming there was a mistake in the previous investigation and he really is guilty blah blah blah.

I think they would be smart and let the sleeping dog lie.
 
Save
Chris Benoit is my favourite Professional Wrestler of all time. I choose not to remember the negatives of his life but the positives, as one should with others they look up to, love or idolise.
fpalm

Chris Benoit was my favourite pro wrestler of all time, but I find it impossible to 'choose not to remember the negatives of his life' when those negatives are murdering his wife and child. Maybe people can do that to an extent with people like Steve Austin (the 'negative' of his life being that he's a wife beater, at least Debra is still alive to tell the tale) but Benoit? No.
 
Discussion starter · #19 ·
That Hitler comparison is really bad. To answer the OP, the WWE won't allow the case to be reopened.
Why would they? I know Vince is stubborn but not to that extent. If Benoit would be proven innocent, he would finally be able to comfortably acknowledge history properly and ease the work needed to do in order to make sure Benoit is not "promoted" in any way during their DVD releases or any recaps of matches & segments where Benoit is displayed positively in any way. (commentary praising him or positive fan signs)

Plus, it would help the recovery of that black eye pro wrestling has got since that day. Pretty sure Vince would rather get rid of this than waste his time doing all he can to refuse to admitting that he was wrong.

fpalm

Chris Benoit was my favourite pro wrestler of all time, but I find it impossible to 'choose not to remember the negatives of his life' when those negatives are murdering his wife and child. Maybe people can do that to an extent with people like Steve Austin (the 'negative' of his life being that he's a wife beater, at least Debra is still alive to tell the tale) but Benoit? No.
As long as nobody actually condones Benoit's actions, I don't see any problem with remembering his career and the good he brought for 20 years before that dreadful weekend. And as far as I know, not a single "Benoit apologist" so far has come forward and defended his actions.
 
Assuming this is all hypothetical and doesn't regards how he is found found innocent if ever:

I believe we would get a legal statement from WWE and a segment on TV shortly recapping the whole case and his new found innocence. From there he would slowly be brought back into mentionings and I can eventually see:
-Life of Benoit 3 disc set with Doc about his innocence
-Hall of Fame induction
 
Save
1 - 20 of 31 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.