Wow, what an utterly dire list, you know WWE has problems with creating fresh new talents when that is the cream of their 2011 crop. Hopefully 2012 produces far better results, I'm guessing Sandow and Ambrose will completely eclipse everyone on that list.
I'm going to have to pick Brodus Clay based solely on the quality of his losing NXT promo, probably the only guy that screamed massive potential. Who could have predicted that Vince would turn him into a ridicuous mid card comedy act back then?
Sin Cara and Kharma pretty much blow all of the other names away. Although Brodus Clay has had so many "debuts" you could literally put forth a case for him having debuted in 2010, 2011 or 2012. Sort of.