Wrestling Forum banner

21 - 34 of 34 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
624 Posts
Okay I will play....Im not going to bother putting a specific year, let's just assume we are throwing out their "prime" level of performance.

Order of entrance,,,, Much edited

Mine is less personal, more of a American Wrestling Super Bowl of Greatness the freakin 30 GOATS going at it.

1. HBK
2. Bret Hart
3. Ric Flair
4. Buddy Rogers
5. Jack Brisco
6. Bruno Sammartino
7. Undertaker
8. Andre
9. Nick Bockwinkel
10. Road Warrior Hawk
11. Terry Gordy
12. The Rock
13. Harley Race
14. Jerry Lawler
15. Dusty Rhodes
16. The Original Sheik
17. Gorgeous George
18. Terry Funk
19. Verne Gagne
20. Randy Savage
21. Bruiser Brody
22. Sgt Slaughter
23. Hulk Hogan
24. Goldberg
25. Stone Cold Steve Austin
26. Sting
27. Road Warrior Animal
28. Jim Londos
29. Brock Lesner
30. Roddy Piper
I almost always respect your opinion, when it comes to the older times you know ya stuff. However I can't dig no Arn, Foley, The Snake, Race or Windham.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,673 Posts
Not really thinking about all 30 but I'd be thrilled to see Andre win it while setting a record for opponets eliminated; Big Show and Brock for sure... maybe Kane, Reigns and Hogan... and 24 other guys.
 

·
Actively avoiding Testicular Torsion
Joined
·
4,025 Posts
Wade Barrett returns, teams with Sheamus to get to the final two and eventually win the Rumble to go on to main event Wrestlemania and Bullhammer Roman's head off.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
460 Posts
This is a fun idea I’m going to put numbers next to mine but that’s not entrance order it’s just so I remember where I’m at in my list I don’t have the time to sit out and order them
1. Austin 97
2. Goldberg 98
3. Hogan 87
4. Flair 87
5. Andre 77
6. Warrior 90
7. HBK 96
8. Undertaker 98
9. Kane 98
10. Rock 00
11. Mankind 96
12. Cena 2010
13. Bret 94
14. Piper 84
15. Batista 07
16. Orton 09
17. Angle 03
18. Lesnar 02
19. Big Show 04
20. Edge 06
21. Savage 88
22. Braun 17
23. Jericho 01
24. Henry 12
25. Bruiser Brody 84
26. Sting 91
27. Dusty 84
28. Harley Race 77
29. Mr Perfect 91
30. Diesel 94
I can decide who I’d pick to win but probably Austin Flair or Goldberg this would be an insane matchup though I’d love to see Braun and prime Andre face off or a Warrior Goldberg showdown I think Hall of Pain Mark Henry would be the one that surprises people in this I’d say that Andre or Goldberg end up with the most eliminations if they came in early and there are like 10 guys in that list who could last over an hour
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,824 Posts
Okay, I'll play at this. Here are the participants, and the order in which they come out in:

1. Dynamite Kid (1983)
2. Brian Pillman (1996)
3. "The Total Package" Lex Luger (1989)
4. "Handsome" Harley Race (1982)
5. Kurt Angle (2000)
6. Bruno Sammartino (1964)
7. "Nature Boy" Ric Flair (1988)
8. John Cena (2007)
9. "Mr Wonderful" Paul Orndorff (1986)
10. Rowdy Roddy Piper (1985)
11. The Great Muta (1989)
12. The Ultimate Warrior (1990)
13. HHH (2002)
14. "Superstar" Billy Graham (1978)
15. Sting (1997)
16. The Undertaker (1999)
17. "The Heartbreak Kid" Shawn Michaels (1997)
18. Randy "Macho Man" Savage (1988)
19. Bret "Hitman" Hart (1997)
20. Hulk Hogan (1989)
21. The Big Show (1999)
22. Bob Backlund (1979)
23. "The Enforcer" Arn Anderson (1988)
24. Hiroshi Tanhashi (2014)
25. Andre the Giant (1983)
26. Gorilla Monsoon (1972)
27. Roman Reigns (2017)
28. "Stone Cold" Steve Austin (1998)
29. Sid Justice (1991)
30. Rikidozan (1960)
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
677 Posts
Discussion Starter #31
This is a fun idea I’m going to put numbers next to mine but that’s not entrance order it’s just so I remember where I’m at in my list I don’t have the time to sit out and order them
1. Austin 97
2. Goldberg 98
3. Hogan 87
4. Flair 87
5. Andre 77
6. Warrior 90
7. HBK 96
8. Undertaker 98
9. Kane 98
10. Rock 00
11. Mankind 96
12. Cena 2010
13. Bret 94
14. Piper 84
15. Batista 07
16. Orton 09
17. Angle 03
18. Lesnar 02
19. Big Show 04
20. Edge 06
21. Savage 88
22. Braun 17
23. Jericho 01
24. Henry 12
25. Bruiser Brody 84
26. Sting 91
27. Dusty 84
28. Harley Race 77
29. Mr Perfect 91
30. Diesel 94
I can decide who I’d pick to win but probably Austin Flair or Goldberg this would be an insane matchup though I’d love to see Braun and prime Andre face off or a Warrior Goldberg showdown I think Hall of Pain Mark Henry would be the one that surprises people in this I’d say that Andre or Goldberg end up with the most eliminations if they came in early and there are like 10 guys in that list who could last over an hour
Interesting you picked Bret from 94. 93/94 were his best years no doubt. I noticed the others that picked Bret from a certain year got him at 97. 97 was solid but at that time I just remember brawls more than the mat classics that gave us all tears in our eyes. We only saw the old Bret in WCW whenever he wrestled Benoit.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
460 Posts
This is a fun idea I’m going to put numbers next to mine but that’s not entrance order it’s just so I remember where I’m at in my list I don’t have the time to sit out and order them
1. Austin 97
2. Goldberg 98
3. Hogan 87
4. Flair 87
5. Andre 77
6. Warrior 90
7. HBK 96
8. Undertaker 98
9. Kane 98
10. Rock 00
11. Mankind 96
12. Cena 2010
13. Bret 94
14. Piper 84
15. Batista 07
16. Orton 09
17. Angle 03
18. Lesnar 02
19. Big Show 04
20. Edge 06
21. Savage 88
22. Braun 17
23. Jericho 01
24. Henry 12
25. Bruiser Brody 84
26. Sting 91
27. Dusty 84
28. Harley Race 77
29. Mr Perfect 91
30. Diesel 94
I can decide who I’d pick to win but probably Austin Flair or Goldberg this would be an insane matchup though I’d love to see Braun and prime Andre face off or a Warrior Goldberg showdown I think Hall of Pain Mark Henry would be the one that surprises people in this I’d say that Andre or Goldberg end up with the most eliminations if they came in early and there are like 10 guys in that list who could last over an hour
Interesting you picked Bret from 94. 93/94 were his best years no doubt. I noticed the others that picked Bret from a certain year got him at 97. 97 was solid but at that time I just remember brawls more than the mat classics that gave us all tears in our eyes. We only saw the old Bret in WCW whenever he wrestled Benoit.
I agree 97 Bret was definitely more interesting from a character standpoint than 94 Bret but wasn’t fully in his prime while 94 Bret was if we’re treating this like a real fight 94 Bret would be quicker, more durable, etc.
 

·
Premium Member
Donna Del Mondo ⭐
Joined
·
3,024 Posts
1. Jake Roberts
2. Shawn Michaels
3. Iron Sheik
4. Bret Hart
5. Ken Shamrock
6. Big Boss Man
7. Randy Orton
8. Kurt Angle
9. Earthquake
10. Ric Flair
11. Gorgeous George
12. AJ Styles
13. Edge
14. Seth Rollins
15. Bob Backland
16. Randy Savage
17. Bruiser Brody
18. New Jack
19. Cactus Jack
20. Kevin Owens
21. Sami Zayn
22. Yokozuna
23. Ricky Steamboat
24. Harley Race
25. Rey Mysterio
26. Andre the Giant
27. Jim Neidhart
28. Arn Anderson
29. JBL
30. Brian Pillman


Winner


Andre the Giant
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,195 Posts
Buster Cannon said:
Interesting you picked Bret from 94. 93/94 were his best years no doubt. I noticed the others that picked Bret from a certain year got him at 97. 97 was solid but at that time I just remember brawls more than the mat classics that gave us all tears in our eyes. We only saw the old Bret in WCW whenever he wrestled Benoit.
And it kind of fit w/ the character change.

The Sheik said:
1. Jake Roberts
2. Shawn Michaels
3. Iron Sheik
4. Bret Hart
5. Ken Shamrock
6. Big Boss Man
7. Randy Orton
8. Kurt Angle
9. Earthquake
10. Ric Flair
11. Gorgeous George
12. AJ Styles
13. Edge
14. Seth Rollins
15. Bob Backland
16. Randy Savage
17. Bruiser Brody
18. New Jack
19. Cactus Jack
20. Kevin Owens
21. Sami Zayn
22. Yokozuna
23. Ricky Steamboat
24. Harley Race
25. Rey Mysterio
26. Andre the Giant
27. Jim Neidhart
28. Arn Anderson
29. JBL
30. Brian Pillman


Winner


Andre the Giant
Fitting winner and nice lineup!
 
21 - 34 of 34 Posts
Top