[RockNova]

2000 -
2001 -
2002 -
2003 -
2004 -
2005 -
2006 -
2007 -
2008 -
2009 -
2010 -
2011 -
2012 -
2013 -
2014 -
2015 -
2016 -
2017 -
2018 -
2019 -
2020 -

 

[MarkyWhipwreck]

2000 - The Rock
2001 - Steve Austin
2002 - Triple H
2003 - Brock Lesnar
2004 - Chris Benoit
2005 - Kurt Angle
2006 - Edge
2007 - John Cena
2008 - Chris Jericho
2009 - Randy Orton
2010 - Chris Jericho
2011 - CM Punk
2012 - CM Punk
2013 - Daniel Bryan
2014 - Brock Lesnar
2015 - Seth Rollins
2016 - Dean Ambrose
2017 - AJ Styles
2018 - AJ Styles
2019 - Adam Cole
2020 - Randy Orton

 

[The Quintessential Mark]

2000 -The Rock
2001 -Chris Jericho
2002 -Brock Lesnar
2003 -Brock Lesnar
2004 -Randy Orton
2005 -Batista/John Cena(Eddie Guerrero I'd wedge in out of honor)
2006 -Edge
2007 -Undertaker/Shawn Michaels
2008 -Chris Jericho/Jeff Hardy
2009 -CM Punk
2010 -Randy Orton
2011 -CM Punk
2012 -CM Punk
2013 -Daniel Bryan
2014 -Seth Rollins
2015 -Kevin Owens
2016 -AJ Styles
2017 -Shinsuke Nakamura
2018 -Daniel Bryan
2019 -Becky Lynch
2020 -Randy Orton

 

[DammitChrist]

I'll try the best that I can

2000: The Rock
2001: Steve Austin
2002: Triple H
2003: Brock Lesnar
2004: Chris Benoit
2005: John Cena
2006: Edge
2007: John Cena
2008: Chris Jericho
2009: Randy Orton
2010: Randy Orton
2011: CM Punk
2012: CM Punk
2013: Daniel Bryan
2014: Brock Lesnar
2015: Seth Rollins
2016: AJ Styles
2017: AJ Styles
2018: Seth Rollins
2019: Adam Cole
2020: Randy Orton

 

[emerald-fire]

Really good thread idea. I'll do 3 for each year in descending order.

2000
The Rock
Triple H
Chris Jericho

2001
Chris Jericho
Stone Cold Steve Austin
Kurt Angle

2002
Triple H
The Rock
Shawn Michaels

2003
Brock Lesnar
Kurt Angle
Shawn Michaels

2004
Randy Orton
Chris Benoit
Triple H

2005
Batista
Kurt Angle
The Undertaker

2006
Edge
John Cena
Batista

2007
John Cena
Randy Orton
The Undertaker

2008
Chris Jericho
Shawn Michaels
Randy Orton

2009
Randy Orton
Jeff Hardy
Chris Jericho

2010
Randy Orton
John Cena
Edge

2011
CM Punk
Randy Orton
John Cena

2012
CM Punk
John Cena
Sheamus

2013
Daniel Bryan
Randy Orton
CM Punk

2014
Brock Lesnar
John Cena
Daniel Bryan

2015
Seth Rollins
Roman Reigns
John Cena

2016
AJ Styles
Chris Jericho
Dean Ambrose

2017
The Miz
Braun Strowman
Roman Reigns

2018
The Miz
Seth Rollins
AJ Styles

2019
Seth Rollins
Daniel Bryan
Kofi Kingston

2020
Randy Orton
Drew McIntyre
Roman Reigns

 

[drougfree]

2000 -HHH
2001 -Austin
2002 -Jericho
2003 -Lesnar
2004 -JBL
2005 -Batista
2006 -Edge
2007 -Orton
2008 -Jericho
2009 -CmPunk
2010 -Cena
2011 -CmPunk
2012 -CmPunk
2013 -Bryan
2014 -Rollins
2015 -Rollins
2016 -Styles
2017 -No idea
2018 -Rousey
2019 -Lynch
2020-Orton

 

[The Wood]

2000 - The Rock
2001 - Steve Austin
2002 - The Rock
2003 - Kurt Angle
2004 - Chris Benoit
2005 - Kurt Angle
2006 - Edge
2007 - Shawn Michaels
2008 - Chris Jericho
2009 - Jeff Hardy
2010 - Shawn Michaels
2011 - CM Punk
2012 - Daniel Bryan
2013 - Daniel Bryan
2014 - Daniel Bryan
2015 - Brock Lesnar
2016 - AJ Styles
2017 - AJ Styles
2018 - Daniel Bryan
2019 - Brock Lesnar
2020 - Roman Reigns

 

[kennykiller12]

2000 - Triple H
2001 - Steve Austin
2002 - Triple H
2003 - Kurt Angle
2004 - Chris Benoit
2005 - Batista
2006 - Edge
2007 - John Cena
2008 - Chris Jericho
2009 - Jeff Hardy
2010 - Didn't Watch Enough to Know
2011 - Didn't Watch Enough to Know
2012 - Didn't Watch Enough to Know
2013 - Didn't Watch Enough to Know
2014 - Brock Lesnar
2015 - Brock Lesnar
2016 - AJ Styles
2017 - Brock Lesnar
2018 - Didn't Watch Enough to Know
2019 - Brock Lesnar
2020 - Roman Reigns

 

[AlexfromAus]

I’ll have a crack. The mid 2010s for me were the hardest.

2000 - The Rock
2001 - Stone Cold
2002 - Triple H
2003 - Brock Lesnar
2004 - Chris Benoit
2005 - Batista
2006 - Edge
2007 - John Cena
2008 - Chris Jericho
2009 - Randy Orton
2010 - John Cena
2011 - CM Punk
2012 - CM Punk
2013 - Daniel Bryan
2014 - Daniel Bryan
2015 - Seth Rollins
2016 - Chris Jericho
2017 - Randy Orton
2018 - Seth Rollins
2019 - Kofi Kingston
2020 - Roman Reigns

 

[Rookie of the Year]

2000 - Triple H
2001 - Chris Jericho
2002 - Kurt Angle
2003 - Brock Lesnar
2004 - Chris Benoit
2005 - Shawn Michaels
2006 - Edge
2007 - John Cena
2008 - Chris Jericho
2009 - Chris Jericho
2010 - Edge
2011 - CM Punk
2012 - CM Punk
2013 - Daniel Bryan
2014 - Brock Lesnar
2015 - Seth Rollins
2016 - AJ Styles
2017 - Brock Lesnar
2018 - Seth Rollins
2019 - Brock Lesnar
2020- Randy Orton

 

[CookieMonsterPunk_SES]

2000 - The Rock
2001 - Stone Cold
2002 - HHH (Really just cuz of the big return tbh)
2003 - Lesnar
2004 - Eddie/Benoit
2005 - Batista
2006 - Edge
2007 - Cena
2008 - Jeff Hardy/Jericho
2009 - Orton
2010 - Cena
2011 - CM Punk
2012 - CM Punk
2013 - Daniel Bryan
2014 - Lesnar
2015 - Rollins
2016 - AJ Styles
2017 - AJ Styles
2018 - Rollins
2019 - Adam Cole
2020 - Orton/McIntyre


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Cooper09]

2000 - The Rock
2001 - Kurt Angel
2002 - HHH
2003 - Lesnar
2004 - Eddie Guerreo
2005 - Batista
2006 - Edge
2007 - Cena
2008 - HBK
2009 - Undertaker
2010 - Cena
2011 - Cena
2012 - CM Punk
2013 - CM Punk
2014 - Lesnar
2015 - Reigns
2016 - Styles
2017 - Reigns
2018 - Lesnar
2019 - Michael Cole
2020 - Drew McIntyre

 

[NondescriptWWEfan]

2000 - HHH
2001 - Steve Austin
2002 - Lesnar
2003 - Angle
2004 - Eddie
2005 - Jericho
2006 - Cena
2007 - Orton
2008 - Jericho
2009 - Jericho
2010 - Punk
2011 - Orton
2012 - Punk
2013 - Daniel Bryan
2014 - Daniel Bryan
2015 - Reigns
2016 - Styles
2017 - Blissy 💕
2018 - Styles
2019 - Becky Lynch
2020 - Randy Orton

 

[Olnoname]

2000 - The Rock
2001 - Steve Austin
2002 - Rob Van Dam
2003 - Brock Lesnar
2004 - Chris Benoit
2005 - Batista
2006 - Edge
2007 - John Cena
2008 - Chris Jericho
2009 - Jeff Hardy
2010 - Undertaker
2011 - CM Punk
2012 - CM Punk
2013 - Brock Lesnar
2014 - Daniel Bryan
2015 - Brock Lesnar
2016 - AJ Styles
2017 - Braun Strowman
2018 - Seth Rollins
2019 - AJ Styles
2020 - Drew Mcyintire

 

[A-55 Man]

2000 - The Rock
2001 - Stone Cold Steve Austin
2002 - Triple H
2003 - Triple H
2004 - Triple H
2005 - John Cena
2006 - Edge
2007 - John Cena
2008 - Edge
2009 - Randy Orton
2010 - John Cena
2011 - CM Punk
2012 - CM Punk
2013 - CM Punk
2014 - Brock Lesnar
2015 - Brock Lesnar
2016 - Roman Reigns
2017 - Brock Lesnar
2018 - Brock Lesnar
2019 - Brock Lesnar
2020 - Randy Orton

 

[TheGuiminator]

2000 - The Rock
2001 - Steve Austin
2002 - The Rock
2003 - Brock Lesnar
2004 - Chris Benoit
2005 - Batista
2006 - Edge
2007 - John Cena
2008 - Chris Jericho
2009 - Randy Orton
2010 - John Cena
2011 - CM Punk
2012 - CM Punk
2013 - Daniel Bryan
2014 - Brock Lesnar
2015 - Roman Reigns
2016 - AJ Styles
2017 - Roman Reigns
2018 - Seth Rollins
2019 - Becky Lynch
2020 - Drew Mcyintire

 

[DammitChrist]

I'll try doing one for the women:

2000: Chyna
2001: Trish Stratus
2002: Victoria
2003: Molly Holly
2004: Trish Stratus
2005: Trish Stratus
2006: Mickie James
2007: Melina
2008: Beth Phoenix
2009: Michelle McCool
2010: Michelle McCool
2011: Beth Phoenix
2012: AJ Lee
2013: AJ Lee
2014: Paige
2015: Sasha Banks
2016: Charlotte Flair
2017: Alexa Bliss
2018: Ronda Rousey
2019: Becky Lynch
2020: Asuka

Edit:

I was close to nominating Eve Torres for 2012 for her good character work as a heel, but AJ Lee was the hottest female star at the time and she broke out big time that year

 

[The Phantom]

Mayu.

 

[DammitChrist]

I’ll use @emerald-fire ’s tactic of listing 3 wrestlers per year (as if those positions were gold, silver, and bronze) since it seems more fun this way due to the various MVPs for each of those years

2000: The Rock, Triple H, Kurt Angle
2001: Steve Austin, Kurt Angle, Chris Jericho
2002: Triple H, Brock Lesnar, Kurt Angle
2003: Brock Lesnar, Kurt Angle, Shawn Michaels
2004: Chris Benoit, Kurt Angle, JBL
2005: John Cena, Batista, Eddie Guerrero
2006: Edge, John Cena, Shawn Michaels
2007: John Cena, Batista, Edge
2008: Chris Jericho, Shawn Michaels, Triple H
2009: Randy Orton, CM Punk, Jeff Hardy
2010: Randy Orton, Edge, Kane
2011: CM Punk, Randy Orton, Christian
2012: CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, Sheamus
2013: Daniel Bryan, CM Punk, Randy Orton
2014: Brock Lesnar, Daniel Bryan, Seth Rollins
2015: Seth Rollins, Kevin Owens, Roman Reigns
2016: AJ Styles, Chris Jericho, The Miz
2017: AJ Styles, Brock Lesnar, Braun Strowman
2018: Seth Rollins, AJ Styles, Tommaso Ciampa
2019: Adam Cole, Seth Rollins, Kofi Kingston
2020: Randy Orton, Drew McIntyre, Seth Rollins

Notes:

The late 2000s were HARD as hell since the main-event scene during that period was STACKED with the likes of Randy Orton, Edge, John Cena, Triple H, Shawn Michaels, Chris Jericho, and Undertaker all being in the main-event scene around the same time; so it was really hard to choose who were the top 3 MVPs during those years with them on top

 

[Rick Sanchez]

2000 - The Rock
2001 - Stone Cold Steve Austin
2002 - Brock Lesnar
2003 - Brock Lesnar
2004 - Chris Benoit
2005 - Batista
2006 - Edge
2007 - John Cena
2008 - Chris Jericho
2009 - CM Punk
2010 - Edge
2011 - CM Punk
2012 - CM Punk
2013 - Daniel Bryan
2014 - Brock Lesnar
2015 - Seth Rollins
2016 - AJ Styles
2017 - AJ Styles
2018 - Seth Rollins
2019 - Becky Lynch
2020 - Sasha Banks