Wrestling Forum banner

2341 - 2360 of 2370 Posts

·
CHAMPION
Joined
·
1,170 Posts
Not saying I’d have read him correctly but his play around me would’ve put him toward the bottom of PoE and the cop result would’ve meant I deffo wouldn’t lynch him with 2 scum left lololol
 

·
Chr1st0’s Top Deputy
Joined
·
4,178 Posts
Lynching a copped town player is dumb unless only the GF remains tbf.

Atleast i’ve always played it that way, the chances of the cop copping the GF are way less likely then the other spots being scum.
 

·
In the bleak midwinter ....
Joined
·
1,927 Posts
No HM nomination for me? <img src="http://www.wrestlingforum.com/images/smilies/smile.gif" border="0" alt="" title="Smilie" class="inlineimg" /> My reads were so dead on that scum had to fake info on me.

Thanks for the game. Congratulations to the winners!
:heston
 

·
In the bleak midwinter ....
Joined
·
1,927 Posts
I haven’t read the scum qt, but I’m pretty sure Poyser just took it as an opportunity, I don’t think he was shook by CP at all tbh

I don’t really care either way, I just felt the hm begging from someone who had no discernible impact on the game was quite funny
 

·
CHAMPION
Joined
·
1,170 Posts
Ye basically was caught off guard by people wanting me to use both my shots, decided to fake info as confirming both of them would be suicide. Was gonna do it to magic for the majority of the planning and then went actually, we’ll do it for CP instead because he’s less lynchable than magic after my flip and cp thought Mikey shot tweet which was getting quite annoying

I mean, CP was suspecting me because he though I fake didn’t read the OP to fake confirm someone to get town points, dumb as fuck and wouldn’t even have held up once I claimed lie detector which explains what I was doing lol
 

·
The Sundance Kid
Joined
·
18,281 Posts
I mean he's right.


Except he thought tweet was a fake pgo.
I thought Tweet was scum on play and pointed out Tweet/Poyser's interactions as feeling like scum/scum, just as I read PHEN0M/Poyser's interaction as scum/scum after the former's flip. I also entertained the possibility of a scum PGO, unlike others. :) Just a fact check for you. I know Poyser and Odo aren't interested in facts but what else can you expect from the younger generation. ;)

I haven’t read the scum qt, but I’m pretty sure Poyser just took it as an opportunity, I don’t think he was shook by CP at all tbh

I don’t really care either way, I just felt the hm begging from someone who had no discernible impact on the game was quite funny
Your continued preoccupation with me is concerning. Hope all is well with you!
 

·
The Sundance Kid
Joined
·
18,281 Posts
I like Odo and dislike Poyser so far. :)

Not personally of course. Just on gut feeling. Personally, I like both of them! :)
My first post correctly leaned town on Odo and scum on Poyser. :)

This is unconvincing in my opinion. I feel like Poyser wanted to be perceived as trying to lay a trap because that's something town would do.

Feels like show-and-tell to me. :)

He does it as both alignments! :lol

I think he was hoping you and we would see it that way. :)

Why not stay on Odo?
This was all dead on re: Poyser. Not debatable.

But you caught Odo doing something he was against doing before as town, whereas Chimp was doing something he does every game as both alignments. Why is it more likely Chimp is scum than Odo?
Again.

I'll bet!

Yes I agree!

Seems like he showed up since then and started giving reads. I'm not sure why he's still people's lynch choice.

SLIMY

Nah your questions were lame, you wanted me to psycho-analyze you and I'd rather not. :)

Jeez Big Man you have been going for some low tier wagons so far. Not a fan, sad to say!

I liked that Chimp was going after Poyser for a while there, gave me a slight town read on him.
My minor suspicion of Big Man didn't persist when Magic repped in and started posting. Never considered Chimp as scum. Continued to suspect Poyser.

Hmm not really down to lynch Chimp or Smark. Big Man and Poyser both feel slimy to me so far but I don't think we can effectively pressure them in the remaining time.

Well I guess I'll see you guys in like 23 hours. :lol Jeez I miss working remote.
Smark was the only scum player I leaned town on this game, so credit to him once again. :)

PHEN0M is being too agreeable let's lynch him
Of course it was a little jokey but I did not like his posts at that point. :lol

scum/scum interaction imo

A lot of defending of Junk, don't see him doing that for a teammate who might not show up and be lynched, just making yourself look bad for no gain.

Ye I feel like Chimp and Smark are both town. Good on me for not voting either.

Odo and Raikonnen both likely town as well.
Called out PHEN0M/Poyser interaction as scum/scum correctly.

Town read Junk and Odo correctly.

That junk read is bizarre he doesn't even explain why she's a town lean, just why she's not a scum lean. But he gives her a town read!
Called out Tweet's bizarre read on Junk.

All of jeff's mentions of PHEN0M

Not sure how this makes him nailed on scum or anything as Poyser was implying.
Shot down Poyser's attempt to tie jeff to PHEN0M. Jeff was lacking in gratitude to say the least! :lol

How does this make him more likely to be the SK?

They could've rolestopped a teammate they were worried about having be copped.

Eh feels slimy to me. I assume whoever they shot at didn't die and so they're assuming they hit the SK. If they did block Chimp then they'd probably feel fairly certain about it. But Chimp would've also been an obvious watcher target too.

Seems more likely they shot at who they think is the SK than they actually rolecopped the SK. PHEN0M would lie to create the kind of speculation above where certain players are suspected of being the SK based on non-play related reasons.

These reads seem unbelievably bad to me. :lol

I don't know that you're actually basing these statements on history. :lol This is sus.

:monkey

He seems obvtown on play though.

I think Poyser told Tweet to bus him and gave bad scum reads on purpose. :side:

This petty shot at MrEvans for no reason. :lol

I thought he was hinting lightning rod or a role that makes all kills fail before n1, and then nobody died n1 so I figured he was legit. But now he's speculating about what happened to the kills so either he's WIFOM'ing or I was wrong. :)
More suspicion of Tweet and Poyser, shot down Magic's attempts to cast Odo as the SK with bad reasoning.

vote Poyser

This is the claim I want as I think knowing his alignment will help figure things out re: Magic and Odo, which is the most important thing right now to me. :)

I'm hoping he's mafia as that'll make things easy!
Pushed Poyser to a claim.

Yeah I'm dead certain at least one of Poyser, Odo, or Magic is mafia. :) Couldn't be more obvious. Going to go with the guy I've been reading as scum from the jump first. Also Magic agrees with me so that makes it easier. I thought Odo agreed with me early on but he's only ever pushed others if I am recalling correctly so my confidence has been a little shaken there but we'll see!
PGOs aren't BP and we have a Bodyguard. Pretty sure Tweet is nailed on scum. :)
Already had Tweet as scum at this point but the stuff with Mikey did give me a role-based theory I could try to convince people on. They should've followed but you can't say that that's why/when I had Tweet as scum. Already had him there!

He didn't realize you were a PGO. This is evidenced by him asking the vig to shoot you. You've been found out. :lol

:rolleyes:

There are no good points. :lol That was a dreadful MQ.

Which reads weren't coherent?

But I'm saying he's confirmed scum and everyone else is acting like he isn't! :lol

Well I'm not going to lynch the claimed lie detector right now so I'll just claim and vote Tweet. :)

Craig Pero, a classmate of Barry, I have no special abilities but still want to help, making me a vanilla townie.

unvote
vote Tweet


Mikey 100% didn't realize Tweet was a PGO and shot him. This is not debatable. Tweet is still alive. He's not a BP PGO when we have a bodyguard. Tweet is scum.
Real quick, not lynching Tweet would be awful. Evans was the mafia kill. Lethal died shooting TKOK. We don't have a vig and a desperado in an 18-person game with mafia, SK, and a PGO of undetermined alignment. Mikey 100% shot Tweet and there's no explanation for Tweet's survival other than that he's BP scum. Not lynching him would be WOAT. :)
Was completely committed to lynching Tweet. If people had followed we probably would've won. :)

Just some more fact checking since certain people seem to enjoy gaslighting where I am concerned. I'm sure this won't dissuade them but that's not really the point. ;)
 

·
Friends Come And Go,Banners Hang Forever
Joined
·
25,686 Posts
i mean cp did play well.


i dont know why people complain about that sort of stuff. i dont think poyser really warrants mvp over his teammates when he was the most suspicious out of his 4 teammates but im sure he also thinks he played well and wont like that im saying he's not. this is how it is lol.
 

·
In the bleak midwinter ....
Joined
·
1,927 Posts
And yes, you made some reads but did they impact the game? Were you able to persuade people to your cause?

Congratulations on not being completely terrible I guess, we’ll be talking about this one for a long time :eyeroll
 

·
The Sundance Kid
Joined
·
18,281 Posts
Huh? :lol I said I had good reads, which is objectively correct. What are you even going on about? Why is the idea of someone possibily acknowledging that I played a good game so triggering for you? You come off like a bitter old spinster miserably swirling around a glass of wine. This is no way to live my friend! :lol Relax!
 
2341 - 2360 of 2370 Posts
Top