Did someone say real fight?

The answer is Bobby Lashley.

 

Yes. That is a great answer. He would beat both of those guys.

 

Who cares? Pro wrestling is fake fighting, who would win a real fight is irrelevant.

 

I've heard Rock has done a little MMA training in his spare time. I'd say The Rock would just crush him based off of size alone. Former Football player who knows how to use his strength to his advantage.

Punk is too frail, unathletic and weak to put up a proper defense for someone The Rock's size. Punk even got the breaks beat off of him Teddy Heart.

 

Rock kills him.

 

Please vote

 

I think Rock, but it wouldn't be a fair fight. Rock is roided to the gills.

 

Yeah but with Punk's crazy style and 2 professional UFC bouts, he would likely be -1500 or so. Give or take

 

Again. Everyone knows who's the toughest shooter of them all.

 

Well, Punk tried fighting for real and got smoked so the answer is THE GREAT ONE.

 

He fought trained fighters, Gall his first opponent is a black belt in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu.

Rocks a guy in his mid 50s with no combat training so by any logic Punk who trained for few years and did go the distance in one fight would easily beat a guy who never trained.

 

What is with all these stupid threads about Punk? Show us on the doll where he touched you, for fucks sake. Is this an Elite burner account?

 

It's funny that you chose these two guys instead of some proven fighters like Bobby Lashley, Ken Shamrock, Dan Severn, Tank Abbott and Brock Lesnar. Steve Blackman is also considered a legit tough guy. He just didn't compete in MMA competition.

 

Rocks bigger than him and stronger than him.

Trust me in a scrap outside Weatherspoons Dwayne would batter Punk.
MMA ring with rules... probaly size advantage Dwayne wins again.

 

I said Punk because Rock is dogshit.

 

Considering Rock’s size and the fact he has a little MMA training now under his belt, Rock flattens him.

 

Training in MMA doesn't make you a good fighter - I hope that makes it clear to everyone.

Punk is not a good fighter. I imagine The Rock isn't great considering his size and age either.

 

Someone has a little bee in their bonnet about Punk

 

Probably Punk. Training matters. Look at the Paul's. As unskilled as they are they're still going to be body 99% of people at boxing because they spent years training with actual boxers.

Punk couldn't beat a grandma who seriously trained in MMA like he did but Rock doesn't have that so there's probably some move he can get him to get a win.

 

Depends if you allow nut shots, kidney punches and other dirty shit. As far as im aware, dwayne would still go down if you hit him in the nuts

 

The Rock of course.

 

Nah, it's neither Rock or Punk

It's this guy

 

All you need to see is CM Sellout's MMA career........

 

I don't see logic in these arguments. Punk fought guys who were actual fighters. Rocks not a fighter or a black belt etc.

It's akin to putting Rock starting in the NFL now and laughing he isn't as the same level of the bench guys there. Reality is Rock would clown Punk in a game of football because he spent years playing the game.

 

Hmm a terrible trained fighter vs an untrained fighter who is much bigger than him. I'd have Phil as the favorite just because he's been in fights before

Rock is a nice guy and he's not trying to resolve his conflicts with physicality, which is the type of matchup Punk thrives in

 

Punk still owned Jungle Boy in a fight so what does it say about the Lollipop Guild in All Petite Wrestling

 

Huge fan of Punk but no just no, I don't think he is taking the Rock in a real fight

 

No clue.

What weapons are they bringing to the fight? That's the only way to know for sure.

 

Punk has a road cone and Rock has a hairdryer but it doesn't work well because the cord is frayed. Who wins?

 

I'd give it to The Rock, I think the advantage in size probably outweighs Punk's training. I don't think it's an obvious answer, though. How can anyone know how a guy who trained in MMA for several years, but absolutely sucked against professional fighters, would do against a much bigger guy who's never trained much at all? Is there some freakshow league where people like that fight?