Kelly Kelly, with no hesitation. i would already HAVE pushed Kelly Kelly.
i don't give a shit about the divas division. and the casual fans dont give much of a shit either if they're hot. they've already proven they think Kelly Kelly is pretty hot, considering she gets the largest pop around, arguably 2nd maybe to Beth Phoenix (but probably not), so who the fuck cares. give the girl the belt.
Eve. She has won me over when she owned The Miz. She's also the most skilled out of these three divas. Besides, if you're diva it doesn't really matter how over you are to the crowds because the creatives will still give you the belt anyway. Case in point: Alicia Fox...and Michelle McCool before her Laycool run.
Personally I'd rather push Beth Phoenix, Nattie Neidhart, Melina, Gail Kim, and Maryse;
But if I have to push one of the three I'd push Kelly Kelly, the audience seems to like her, she's attractive, and in the ring she has a few flashy moves plus she has a more natural look which I think would help her stand out a little more.
Eve has been demoted now for a while, and, she deserves to be in the mix again. Natalya is getting her rightful time in the spotlight, but, like many have said before, If I had to choose, I'd definitely go for Eve.