Which 1 is better?
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
Joined
·
1,489 Posts
1st one no doubt, second one is just ugly. In the first one you should get some better BG, maybe some brushes will help. You also should make the main 'Taker cut bigger. For blending you should use maybe something like overlay. The text has bad placement, it should be at the bottom. The red outer glow looks real bad with the purple BG. You should put only a cut of taker in the back, or the whole pic and blend it with the bg. Maybe you should like only put his face there and make it fade away.
1st one - never use that kind of border on a graphic unless you wanna stay a n00b forever. Bad blending, bg and text.
2nd - Bad blending, bad text and bad bg
the sig - bad bg, bad text, bad cut, and I hate those text bars they look good when used right on a grunge but here it just looks bad so I'd say remove it.
2nd - Bad blending, bad text and bad bg
the sig - bad bg, bad text, bad cut, and I hate those text bars they look good when used right on a grunge but here it just looks bad so I'd say remove it.
Joined
·
7,477 Posts
Is it me, or does it look like taker's saying to himself, "Please...someone tell this jerkoff never to use me in a banner again!"
Now if I could be serious for a moment....
The first one is deffinately the lesser of two evils. The border's probably a pre-made I'm guessin (don't think I've seen it used before so I can't say for sure) but it doesn't take away from the product so I won't deduct points for it.
You could've tossed a few more cuts in to spice it up and made the lower text a little bigger (and easier on the eye's) so I'll give it a 6/10.
The second one.... Well, if you don't have anything nice to say....give it a 2/10 and be done with it.
Joined
·
290 Posts
the color selection is ugly, if you dont colorize the taker cut to the same color it would look better... try adding contrast to his normal color and make the cut bigger also I think a simple stroke effect would look better on the text instead of the glow. Keep working and try out what I said
Joined
·
15,321 Posts
First one is the best. The second one is alright but the text is hard to read. The third one is just horrible. The outline on Taker in the third one needs to be fixed cause it ruins the pic.
Joined
·
7,915 Posts
The first one is the best, but they all are bad. Bad text, bad blending on all of them. Horrible color choices also. 5/10 for the second on and sig one. 6/10 for the first one. Keep tryin though.
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
