Daniel Bryan basically.I'll explain what I think a good wrestler to be.
Someone who has an impressive move set. Very rarely botches. Can tell a story in the ring. A guy who can take bumps. Can make both himself and the other guy look good. A guy who can get the crowd going and interested in the match. Has good endurance and fitness. Can sell moves so the other guy looks good. Not essential but isn't afraid to get on top ropes and has a good finisher.
Those are some of the attributes I would want from a good wrestler.