Wrestling Forum banner

21 - 40 of 42 Posts

·
Currently lying down wearing a blue suit
Joined
·
10,663 Posts
My top 2 women, Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair, rightfully being on top :banderas

I'm also happy with the placements of Emma, Maryse, Carmella, and Alexa Bliss :eek:

Edit: I would've voted for Lita too if I knew that she was eligible :lol
 

·
Won't shut up about Peyton Royce
Joined
·
17,643 Posts
How on earth Nia and Tamina are over Cathy Kelley? I mean :wtf:wtf

And I didn't know Carmella have that many fans tbh
 

·
Currently lying down wearing a blue suit
Joined
·
10,663 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,982 Posts
Nope. Took long enough as it was lol.
Just bashed them into excel, here's how they compare:

New formula / Previous Formula
1. Becky 304 / Becky 281
2. Charlotte 247 / Charlotte 226
3. Alexa 211.5 / Alexa 187.5
4. Sasha 162 / Sasha 154
5. Emma 145 / Emma 135
6. Asuka 142 / Maryse 130.5
7. Maryse 134.5 / Asuka 124
8. Nikki Cross 129 / Carmella 115
9. Carmella 122 / Nikki Cross 114
10. Peyton Royce 87 / Peyton Royce 87
11. Kairi Sane 86.5 / Kairi Sane 81.5
12. Bayley 77.5 / Bayley 75.5
13. Lana 66 / Mickie James 64.5
14. Mickie James 64.5 / Lana 58
15. Renee Young 57.5 / Renee Young 54.5
16. Nikki Bella 48 / Nikki Bella 49
17. Ember Moon 43 / Mandy Rose 44
18. Mandy Rose 42 / Ember Moon 41.5
19. Naomi 40 / Naomi 41
20. Nia Jax 35 / Nia Jax 35
21. Dakota Kai 30 / Ruby Riot 27.5
22. Ruby Riot 28.5 / Billie 27.5
23. Lita, Natalya 28 / Natalya 27
24. N/A / Liv Morgan 24.5
25. Billie Kay 27 / Lita 22
26. Liv Morgan 24 / Dakota Kai 21
27. Maria 16.5 / Maria 16.5
28. Jojo 15 / Jojo 15
29. Charly Caruso, Tamina 13.5 / Tamina 13.5
30. N/A / Charly Caruso 12.5
31. Cathy Kelley 13 / Cathy Kelley 12
32. Sarah Logan 11.5 / Sarah Logan 10.5
33. Bianca BelAir 10 / Bianca BelAir 10
34. Dana Brooke 8 / Dana Brooke 8
35. Abbey Laith 6.5 / Abbey Laith 6.5
36. Sonya Deville 3 / Sonya Deville 3
37. Aliyah 2.5 / Aliyah 2.5
38. Alicia Fox, Alundra Blayze, Stephanie McMahon 2 / Stephanie McMahon, Alicia Fox 2

40. N/A / Vanessa Bourne 1.5
41. Vanessa Bourne 1.5 / Alundra Blayze, Dasha Fuentes, Sage Beckett, Taynara Conti 1
42. Dasha Fuentes, Rhea Ripley, Sage Beckett, Taynara Conti 1 / N/A



46. N/A / Rhea Ripley 0.5
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,682 Posts
Emma doing absolutely fuck all but bitch on twitter for sympathy points, yet moves up. Makes sense
How did the female Eugene rank higher than Lana? :sodone :stop
Lana started wrestling, she's bad at wrestling. She also looks less hot in her wrestling gear than her slutty corporate outfit.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
17,493 Posts
Discussion Starter #28
Just bashed them into excel, here's how they compare:

New formula / Previous Formula
1. Becky 304 / Becky 281
2. Charlotte 247 / Charlotte 226
3. Alexa 211.5 / Alexa 187.5
4. Sasha 162 / Sasha 154
5. Emma 145 / Emma 135
6. Asuka 142 / Maryse 130.5
7. Maryse 134.5 / Asuka 124
8. Nikki Cross 129 / Carmella 115
9. Carmella 122 / Nikki Cross 114
10. Peyton Royce 87 / Peyton Royce 87
11. Kairi Sane 86.5 / Kairi Sane 81.5
12. Bayley 77.5 / Bayley 75.5
13. Lana 66 / Mickie James 64.5
14. Mickie James 64.5 / Lana 58
15. Renee Young 57.5 / Renee Young 54.5
16. Nikki Bella 48 / Nikki Bella 49
17. Ember Moon 43 / Mandy Rose 44
18. Mandy Rose 42 / Ember Moon 41.5
19. Naomi 40 / Naomi 41
20. Nia Jax 35 / Nia Jax 35
21. Dakota Kai 30 / Ruby Riot 27.5
22. Ruby Riot 28.5 / Billie 27.5
23. Lita, Natalya 28 / Natalya 27
24. N/A / Liv Morgan 24.5
25. Billie Kay 27 / Lita 22
26. Liv Morgan 24 / Dakota Kai 21
27. Maria 16.5 / Maria 16.5
28. Jojo 15 / Jojo 15
29. Charly Caruso, Tamina 13.5 / Tamina 13.5
30. N/A / Charly Caruso 12.5
31. Cathy Kelley 13 / Cathy Kelley 12
32. Sarah Logan 11.5 / Sarah Logan 10.5
33. Bianca BelAir 10 / Bianca BelAir 10
34. Dana Brooke 8 / Dana Brooke 8
35. Abbey Laith 6.5 / Abbey Laith 6.5
36. Sonya Deville 3 / Sonya Deville 3
37. Aliyah 2.5 / Aliyah 2.5
38. Alicia Fox, Alundra Blayze, Stephanie McMahon 2 / Stephanie McMahon, Alicia Fox 2

40. N/A / Vanessa Bourne 1.5
41. Vanessa Bourne 1.5 / Alundra Blayze, Dasha Fuentes, Sage Beckett, Taynara Conti 1
42. Dasha Fuentes, Rhea Ripley, Sage Beckett, Taynara Conti 1 / N/A



46. N/A / Rhea Ripley 0.5
So which you prefer?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
17,493 Posts
Discussion Starter #31 (Edited)
When was the voting? I think I missed it. I would've just solidified Becky's 1st place anyway

Cool to see Nikki Cross climbing the ranks more and more.
It was over the last couple days. The last woman standing played a hand in Storm rejoining the Top 10. If NXT drop the ball with her, she'll no doubt go outside it again.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,982 Posts
So which you prefer?
Heh, well... My favorites have certainly fared better under the new system, so in that respect I prefer the new method... But in terms of keeping the race closer and arguably fairer, I still think the older one is probably more balanced, and I feel like if anythng, these surveys could do with allowing the battles as competative as possible rather than less so.

(Along that tangent, I'd be curious to see how a convex point alocation version might work, ie;

1. 10 points
2. 9.5 Points
3. 9 Points
4. 8.5 Points
5. 8 points
6. 7.5 Points
7. 7 points
8. 6.5 Points
9. 5 Points
10. 1 Point

Although that might just be getting altogether too complex, although I might have a look at how the latest results might look under that system later.)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
17,493 Posts
Discussion Starter #33
Heh, well... My favorites have certainly fared better under the new system, so in that respect I prefer the new method... But in terms of keeping the race closer and arguably fairer, I still think the older one is probably more balanced, and I feel like if anythng, these surveys could do with allowing the battles as competative as possible rather than less so.

(Along that tangent, I'd be curious to see how a convex point alocation version might work, ie;

1. 10 points
2. 9.5 Points
3. 9 Points
4. 8.5 Points
5. 7.5 points
6. 5.5 Points
7. 3.5 points
8. 2 Points
9. 1 Points
10. 0.5 Point

Although that might just be getting altogether to complex, although I might have a look at how the latest results might look under that system later.)
But it's not about keeping the race closer. Reason for the new system is for those who don't have 10 favourites, still get the same as those that do. Not everybody is gonna struggle to narrow down to 10, because some don't care enough for the division.

I'll probably keep this system over the old. Depends if I get any feedback from regular voters. We'll see in October.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,982 Posts
But it's not about keeping the race closer. Reason for the new system is for those who don't have 10 favourites, still get the same as those that do. Not everybody is gonna struggle to narrow down to 10, because some don't care enough for the division.

I'll probably keep this system over the old. Depends if I get any feedback from regular voters. We'll see in October.
That's cool, new style favors my picks anyway!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
17,493 Posts
Discussion Starter #35
Anyways my thoughts on the Top 10:

Becky - her fanbase has held strong whilst others are collapsing. Her being first again doesn't surprise me. Probably will for the rest of the year too.

Charlotte - I honestly thought she'd stay third forever. Won't likely climb any higher.

Alexa - Her fans are very much like Paige's were. This time next year they'll have abandoned ship.

Sasha - meh.

Emma- She's hot and talented but they do fuck all with her. I always scratch my head at her permanent role in the top 10.

Asuka - I got bored of her months ago. And until she's gone the rest of NXT are just, there. She'll swing up and down a spot or 2 every time.

Maryse - definition of somebody who does nothing. But least she looks good standing there I guess. Another top 10 mainstay that won't be going anytime soon.

Nikki Cross- definitely helped by the last woman standing match. It'll be what she does next if she stays in the 10 or not.

Carmella - just like last woman standing, I feel MITB & Ellsworth have helped her here.

Peyton Royce- a shining star of NXT but she'll struggle to keep her position which could easily go to Kairi next time. Or if Lana, Mickie, Bayley climb back up.

It'll be interesting where the Mae Young classic females will fare too. Could end up with a huge glut of no pointers.
 
21 - 40 of 42 Posts
Top