[The Pied Piper]

Simple question, but I think this should spark some interesting discussion.

 

[#1Peep4ever]

to me it was a five star match
dont care about what dave thinks about this match

 

[Rocky_Mark0000]

4 stars i think

 

[Headliner]

Everyone has their own criteria. Some people give out 5 stars easier/more than others.

 

[Green Light]

It's just his opinion, how can it be wrong or right

 

[samizayn]

There's no right and wrong in opinion-land. And a significant part of dealing out star ratings is due to opinion/personal experience.

 

[Clique]

It's his opinion so he can do whatever he wants. It's the greatest match I've ever seen.

 

[123bigdave]

Ehh. It's his opinion. Every has one on everything. Damn butthurt droolers ye are.

 

[Rusty Shackleford]

It's just his opinion. I don't know why people act like everything he says is fact.

 

[LINK]

My opinion is that it was a five star match, but Dave Meltzer can rate it whatever he wants.

 

[20083]

Personally, it was easily a five star match for me. Meltzer's not 'wrong' in rating it otherwise though, matter of opinion.

 

[BrosOfDestruction]

No right or wrong in an opinion. Meltzer can rate it whatever he wants.

It's easily a flawless, 5 star match to me but I have never been overly critical or analyzed matches in a whole lot of depth.

 

[#dealwithit]

It's not a ***** match. It's ****15/16 :side:

 

[Medo]

It's his opinion so he can do whatever he wants. It's the greatest match I've ever seen.

I second that

 

[James Curran]

I'm going with 4 1/2 stars. I know what my favourite match is of all time and that's a 5/5 and this match just didn't meet the standers of my fave match.

 

[Couch]

Was he right to have an opinion is basically what you're asking.

 

[666_The_Game_666]

Its his opinion he didn't see it as a 5 star match so he didn't give it 5 stars. I think the Taker dive spot was the one part of the match that takes it down from a 5 star match to a 4 and three quarter star match

 

[Brock]

to me it was a five star match
dont care about what dave thinks about this match

(Y)

 

[kokepepsi]

So when a doctor tells you that in his opinion you should lose weight you don't do it CUZ IT"S JUST SOME DUDES OPINION RIGHT?

Meltzer is the all knowing wrestling smark. If he said it wasn't 5 stars it's becasue it wasn't.

GETMADBITCHES

 

[#BadNewsSanta]

Who cares?