The Smashing Machine is a kind of film that is not going to be a box office Juggernaut. So i wasn't expecting to make a lot of money. If it's feels like a failure is more about the budget of the film.
I saw the film yesterday, it thought it was pretty solid.
As for Rock performance, it was definitely one of his best acting roles.
As for a Oscar Nomination, I personally think he'll be a long shot contender. You only got 5 nominees.
I do think he at least has a much better shot at a Golden Globe Nomination
The movie industry itself isn't reliant on box office any more. Like I said previously, The Irishman took in $8m against a production budget if $150m+ and was nominated for 10 Academy Awards.
TBF to The Irishman, it was only briefly in theaters to qualify for Oscar contention. It was a Netflix steaming film unlike The Smashing Machine.