So I decided to go to the show. Here's the report I sent Meltzer:
Attendance - Couldn't have been more than 350-400. A lot of front row seats were available to the point where some in General Admission would just move into 1st and 2nd row seats without being escorted back by security. General Admission seating was full (although only half the bleachers were out), but ringside seats drew poorly. $30 for 3rd row, $40 for 2nd and $60 for front row seats isn't exactly a fair price for a market that hasn't been run in years.
There was also a problem with one group of 5's tickets. Not sure if there weren't enough seats put out or ROH double booked those seats because those 5 were moved to empty front row seats camera side.
ROH's pre-show autograph session of Michael Elgin, Adam Cole, Maria Kanellis and Jay Lethal didn't draw very well. I only saw a handful of people go up to their table and ask for an autograph/picture.
First match was "Unbreakable" Michael Elgin versus "The Prodigy" Mike Bennett with Maria. Match was surprisingly good. Elgin was pretty over but Bennett didn't get as much heat as he would across the bridge in the Hammerstein. At one point Elgin was preparing for a suicide dive onto Bennett, but Truth instead kicked him around to Elgin's dismay. A little Maria interference towards the end, but Elgin won with the Buckle Bomb-Spinning Powerbomb combination. Really good opener.
Next was The Bravado Brothers taking on the debuting team of CHIKARA's 3.0. I don't think the majority of fans knew who these guys were and a lot of their stuff didn't catch on. Good back and forth tag match and eventually the crowd got behind 3.0. Very loud "Justin Bieber" chants directed to Harlem Bravado. Bravados picked up the victory with their finisher in another solid match. Afterward, Bravados offered a handshake to 3.0 but delivered a kick to the gut to both Shane Matthews and Scott Parker.
In another Ring of Honor debut, Bobby Fish took on "God's Gift" QT Marshall. R.D. Evans (QT's new manager) was nowhere to be found. Didn't catch all of this match, but from what I heard around me, it was nothing special anyway. Crowd really liked Fish and he did look impressive from what I saw. Fish hit a spinning kick to the head and got the 3. I'm assuming since Bobby won the match that he'll be brought back.
Next up was the 3 Way Elimination Tag Team Championship match with Wrestling's Greatest Tag Team, Rhett Titus & BJ Whitmer, and defending champions Steve Corino and Jimmy Jacobs. WGTT got a ton of heat and Haas flicked off his fair share of fans as usual. A lot of spitting back and forth between teams was involved and it just got dumb after awhile. Corino and Jay Lethal's father front row were aruging for the majority of the match for some reason. WGTT were the first to be eliminated, but Haas sent a chairshot to the back of Titus when the ref wasn't looking and Corino delivered a Backdrop Driver to retain the championships. Something just didn't click in this match. Not a good night for Rhett as he was noticeably sloppy at times. Good first half.
Intermission. Fans were instructed to go into the lobby and get a card for their free iPPV access code. Really poor job by ROH as they just sprawled the cards all over the table so peoplb just took as many as they wanted. I'm sure there will be some cards going up on eBay since every card has a different code.
There was also an incident with the screamo/heavy metal band that played Elgin's and Eddie Edwards' theme live. They were doing an intermission "halftime show" when after a few songs, a group of people started to boo. The lead singer then went on a tanget to a guy wearing a Kanye West shirt that rap isn't real music and how their songs were made with real instruments and was just being really unprofessional. Needless to say, they stopped playing until Eddie Edwards' match.
Kyle O'Reilly versus Roderick Strong. This crowd LOVED Roddy and cheered him heavily. I'd go as far as the last time he got that kind've reaction was when he won the ROH World Title from Tyler Black at Glory By Honor IX (Black's last match in the company.) Crowd didn't even react to O'Reilly. At one point, this new ROH referee botched a spot as O'Reilly rolled up Strong and the ref counted 3 even though Roddy kicked out. Loud "You F'd Up" chants and heavy boo'ing followed of course. Roddy won with a big Backbreaker and the crowd popped big time. Another good match.
Next up was Davey Richards against Mike Mondo. Davey got a big reaction to my surprise and there were even a few Mondo fans. Usual Davey match with his usual spots. At one point they were going back and forth with submissions which I thought was silly considering how well Davey is technically. Davey eventually won with a Cloverleaf. He got on the mic and ripped into Sinclair but put over having honor and how great the wrestling ROH provides is. He turned his attention to Mondo and said that he now has respect for him and how he's been negatively treated. Davey said this is a fresh start for Mondo and welcomed him to Ring of Honor. Promo did work since the crowd cheered big time for Mondo on his way out of the ring. I aso noticed when Davey went up to the 2nd rope to do the American Wolf hand sign, he jumped off awkwardly and came up limping and limped up the ramp. Don't know if this is anything to worry about.
Briscoes versus Eddie Edwards and TV Champion Adam Cole. This match RULED. Mark Briscoe was probably the most over one with his wackiness and his karate chops. This match wasn't too long so the crowd didn't get bored with it at any time. Thought the crowd would react more, but I guess since all 4 guys are really popular, they didn't know who to cheer for. "This is Awesome" chants broke out towards the end. Briscoes won with a Doomsday Device on Adam Cole. Makes sense since The Briscoes are getting a title shot at the next iPPV. Due to what happened in the main event, this is my Match of the Night.
Main Event time. Defending ROH Champion Kevin Steen against hometown boy Jay Lethal. For as many Steen shirts I saw throughout the night, Jay Lethal had the crowd 85-15 in favor of him. This match was incredible and got a ton of time. Crowd was alive for the whole match which is expected. Lethal hit the Lethal Injection on Steen, but Steen kicked out and then would later hit the Lethal Injection, but Steen rolled out of the ring. This is where it all went wrong. After Steen rolls out of the ring, he goes into one of the corner barricades where Jay Lethal's parents are sitting. He starts talking a bit of trash and then Lethal's mom throws her soda in his face. Steen spits on her and that's when Lethal went chaotic. Jay starts pounding on Steen as Cornette (who was at ringside for this match), Corino & Jacobs, ring crew, and others start to break things up. Of course there were pull-away, someone escapes and attacks the other moments. Steen goes up the ramp and starts tearing down the curtain and then exits with the rest of Scum. Lethal throws one of the ring crew guys and referees, chairs; he just goes ballistic. He yells at Cornette (couldn't make out what he was saying) and then escorts his parents out of the building. He comes back to ringside and nothing's happening. EXTREMELY loud "Bulls***" chants as Lethal proceeds up the ramp. No one knows what's going on until Bobby Cruise goes on the microphone and announces that the match is ruled a No Contest, apologizes for the language exchanged by Steen and Lethal, and reminds the fans that tickets are on sale for Final Battle in New York City.
That's when the crowd starts rebelling. More "Bulls***" chants and a ton of bottles and trash start getting thrown into the ring. People start chanting "REFUND! REFUND!" as Cornette and company exit. I saw a few people trying to throw chairs into the ringside area as well. I overheard fans saying "F this company", "I'm done" as well as other expletive filled rants. NO ONE was happy with this ending and honestly, I was too. How does Ring of Honor think that having a No Contest result with the hometown boy in the World Title match will be good business? Everyone left with a negative attitude and ROH's "build" to a possible Steen/Lethal rematch at Final Battle has completely backfired.
Overall, although I enjoyed the show, I and everyone in attendance were left with a VERY bad taste in our mouths. I really just don't understand the logic of doing that finish in Jay Lethal's backyard. I honestly can't imagine ROH running this market for awhile after the finish (or lack thereof) of the main event.