Wrestling Forum banner

1 - 11 of 11 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
110 Posts
Discussion Starter #1 (Edited)
What is your ratings at Reign of Okada for the IWGP Heavyweigth Champion? Is for you the Reigns most greats for the all times? Should it end earlier?

My rating:

Vs Naito-Dominion 6.19 in Osaka ****1/4

Vs Marufuji-KOPW 2016 ****1/2+

Vs Kenny Omega-WK 10 ****3/4

Vs Minrou Suzuki-New Beginning in Osaka 2017 ****1/4

Vs Shibata-Sakura Genesis 2017 *****

Vs Bad Luck Fale- Wrestling Dontaku 2016 ***3/4+

Vs Kenny Omega-Dominion 6.11 in Osaka ****

Vs Cody-G1 Special Day 1 ***1/2+

Vs EVIL-KOPW 2017 ***

Vs Tetsuya Naito-WK 11 ****3/4

Vs SANADA-New Beginning in Osaka 2018 ****1/4+

Vs Zack Sabre Jr-Sakura Genesis 2018 ****3/4
 
Joined
·
60,001 Posts
I don't recall my individual ratings. I thought his matches with Kenny and Shibata were the best while Cody and Fale's were the lowest, but those were still good. He really has been on another level for quite some time now.
 

·
#1 Somamaniac
Joined
·
13,620 Posts
Are we counting the first Naito match?

Naito: 4

Marufuji: 5

Omega: 5

Old-Manoru Shitzuki: 2-3 (can't remember specifically of the top of my head)

Shibata: 5

Fale: 4

Omega: 5 (but I might change that to a 4.75 depending on my mood)

Cody: 4.25

EVIL: 4

Naito: 4.75

SANADA: 4.75

Sabre: 5

Honestly, I think it should've ended at Wrestle Kingdom.
 

·
The NEW
Joined
·
13,420 Posts
Marufuji: *1/4
Omega: ***3/4
Suzuki: **
Shibata: *****
Fale: ****1/4
Omega II: **1/2
Cody: ****1/4
EVIL: *1/2
Naito: ***3/4
SANADA: ***1/4
ZSJ: ****1/4
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
5,390 Posts
Marufuji - ****1/4
Omega - *****
Suzuki - ****1/4
Shibata - *****
Fale - ***1/2
Omega II - ****1/2
Cody - ****
EVIL - ***3/4
Naito - ****3/4
Sanada - ****3/4
Sabre - ****1/2
 

·
The NEW
Joined
·
13,420 Posts
WHY ***3/4 at Okada/Omega, Okada/Naito, and why *1/4 Vs Marufuji?
For Okada/Omega, the first half keeps it from being a 4*+ banger. Super soulless, dry, boring. Sucked the life out of me. When they went nuts though, it got fantastic. Not sure how it would hold up on a re-watch, but that's how I thought last year watching it.

Okada/Naito was really damn good. Not sure what exactly keeps it from being a 4*+ one, but that's just how I felt. I think overall it's better than the first Omega match.

Maru match I hated. Haven't watched it back at all & ever since then, I've started liking Marufuji more, so who knows what would happen on a re-watch. Their G1 match is tremendous that's for sure.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,164 Posts
Okada vs. Naito Dominion 2016 ****1/4
Okada vs. Marufuji ****1/2
Okada vs. Omega I *****
Okada vs. Suzuki *****
Okada vs. Shibita *****
Okada vs. Fale ****
Okada vs. Omega II *****
Okada vs. Rhodes ****
Okada vs. Evil ****
Okada vs. Naito WK ****3/4
Okada vs. Sanada ****1/4
Okada vs. Sabre ****1/4
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,636 Posts
I don’t really have star ratings, but in order of what I liked best to least:

Okada vs Shibata

Okada vs Omega (wK11)

Okada vs Marufuji

Okada vs Omega( Dominion)

Okada vs Naito (WK12)

Okada vs Sabre

Okada vs Suzuki

Okada vs Sanada

Okada vs Evil

Okada vs Bad Luck Fale

Okada vs Cody
 

·
Le Champion
Joined
·
18,718 Posts
I don't really know if there's a point in me doing this because OP I feel like you're just gonna disregard my opinion towards Okada, but oh well here we go. :p Not counting his title win over Naito.

vs. Marufuji - Didn't see
vs. Omega I - **** 3/4
vs. Suzuki - * (Such a horrible performance from Okada and match in general)
vs. Shibata - *****
vs. Fale - *** 1/2
vs. Omega II - ** (Legit hated the last 25-30 minutes of this)
vs. Cody - ** 1/2? (I tend to forget this even happened)
vs. EVIL - Didn't see
vs. Naito - ****
vs. SANADA - ***
vs. Sabre Jr. - ****

So no I don't think it's been one of the greatest reigns ever or anything like that. It's been a very up and down one and Okada's individual performances have been nothing special and constantly overshadowed by his opponents. I really think it should've ended with Naito at WK but it seems it will go on at the very least until Dominion.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
I don't really know if there's a point in me doing this because OP I feel like you're just gonna disregard my opinion towards Okada, but oh well here we go. :p Not counting his title win over Naito.

vs. Marufuji - Didn't see
vs. Omega I - **** 3/4
vs. Suzuki - * (Such a horrible performance from Okada and match in general)
vs. Shibata - *****
vs. Fale - *** 1/2
vs. Omega II - ** (Legit hated the last 25-30 minutes of this)
vs. Cody - ** 1/2? (I tend to forget this even happened)
vs. EVIL - Didn't see
vs. Naito - ****
vs. SANADA - ***
vs. Sabre Jr. - ****

So no I don't think it's been one of the greatest reigns ever or anything like that. It's been a very up and down one and Okada's individual performances have been nothing special and constantly overshadowed by his opponents. I really think it should've ended with Naito at WK but it seems it will go on at the very least until Dominion.
No...no
 
1 - 11 of 11 Posts
Top