Wrestling Forum banner

Who should we rate next?


  • Total voters
    16
  • This poll will close: .
1 - 20 of 43 Posts

·
Currently lying down wearing a blue suit
Joined
·
10,994 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Believe it or not, we've gone one week since doing these threads! We're still on schedule though. It is finally time to rate another current superstar. I'd like to thank the many of you for participating in my previous threads. Remember that all of your votes DO matter, but please just try to be objective. Let's also try to get as many responses here as possible now :eek:

Bret Hart ended up being ranked at 1st place in the classic section so far. Unfortunately for Bret, the ratings for his mic skills hurt him dramatically. However, the Hitman did receive an excellent score for his in-ring ability. It turns out that Bret now has the best look/presence in the classic section so far. He also has the best score based off his in-ring ability out of anyone in the classic section.

Nia Jax ended up being ranked at 23rd place in the section for the women. Unfortunately for Nia, she did not seem to have any strengths since her scores for each department were all mediocre.

Here are the updated standings:

Classic:

Bret Hart: 8.8 (Look/Presence 9.2, In-Ring Ability 9.8, Charisma 8.6, Mic Skills 7.5)
Shawn Michaels: 8.7 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 9.4, Charisma 9.0, Mic Skills 8.0)

Current:

Samoa Joe: 8.9 (Look/Presence 8.9, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 9.5)
Daniel Bryan: 8.9 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 9.7, Charisma 9.2, Mic Skills 8.6)
John Cena: 8.7 (Look/Presence 9.2, In-Ring Ability 7.2, Charisma 9.4, Mic Skills 9.1)
Randy Orton: 8.2 (Look/Presence 9.3, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 7.2)
The Miz: 8.0 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 6.9, Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 9.3)
AJ Styles: 7.9 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 9.3, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 6.6)
Jeff Hardy: 7.8 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 9.4, Mic Skills 5.7)
Dean Ambrose: 7.8 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 6.8. Charisma 8.2, Mic Skills 8.4)
Seth Rollins: 7.7 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 8.3, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 6.9)
Kevin Owens: 7.5 (Look/Presence 6.0. In-Ring Ability 7.7, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 8.4)
Sheamus: 7.5 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 6.9, Mic Skills 7.0)
SR: 7.4 (7.7, 8.1, 7.3, 6.6)
Dolph Ziggler: 7.4 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 7.0, Mic Skills 6.9)
Braun Strowman: 7.4 (Look/Presence 9.4, In-Ring Ability 5.9. Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 6.1)
Cesaro: 7.3 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 9.3, Charisma 6.4, Mic Skills 5.0)
Brock Lesnar: 7.2 (Look/Presence 9.5, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 4.1)
Rusev: 7.2 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 6.6)
Rey Mysterio: 7.1 (Look/Presence 7.0, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 5.6)
Sami Zayn: 7.0 (Look/Presence 4.9, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 7.1, Mic Skills 7.6)
Andrade Cien Almas: 7.0 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 8.8, Charisma 7.2, Mic Skills 3.9)
BL: 6.9 (9.2, 7.0, 7.5, 3.8)
Jason Jordan: 6.9 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 6.1, Mic Skills 5.4)
SZ: 6.8 (4.8, 8.2, 6.9, 7.4)
Finn Balor: 6.7 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 6.4, Mic Skills 5.2)
Shinsuke Nakamura: 6.4 (Look/Presence 7.1, In-Ring Ability 7.3, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 3.7)
Baron Corbin: 6.3 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 6.4, Charisma 6.1, Mic Skills 6.4)
SN: 6.2 (6.9, 7.0, 7.4, 3.6)
Bobby Lashley: 6.1 (Look/Presence 9.5, In-Ring Ability 6.7, Charisma 4.3, Mic Skills 3.9)

Women:

Becky Lynch: 8.3 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 7.8, Charisma 8.8, Mic Skills 8.2)
BL: 8.2 (8.2, 7.7, 8.7, 8.0)
Mickie James: 8.1 (Look/Presence 8.4, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 7.9)
Alexa Bliss: 7.9 (Look/Presence 8.4, In-Ring Ability 6.0, Charisma 8.5, Mic Skills 8.6)
Asuka: 7.9 (Look/Presence 8.5, In-Ring Ability 8.9, Charisma 8.8, Mic Skills 5.3)
Toni Storm: 7.8 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 6.3)
Rhea Ripley: 7.7 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 7.8, Charisma 7.7, Mic Skills 6.5)
Ruby Riott: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.0, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 7.7)
Charlotte Flair: 7.3 (Look/Presence 8.1, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 6.0)
Sasha Banks: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 6.2)
Kairi Sane: 7.2 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 4.4)
RR: 7.1 (6.7, 7.8, 6.5, 7.5)
Lacey Evans: 7.1 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 5.9, Charisma 7.1, Mic Skills 7.0)
Io Shirai: 7.0 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 7.2, Mic Skills 4.0)
KS: 7.0 (7.7, 8.5, 7.5, 4.2)
Ronda Rousey: 6.7 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 7.2, Charisma 6.9, Mic Skills 4.3)
Ember Moon: 6.5 (Look/Presence 7.6, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 5.4, Mic Skills 4.3)
Carmella: 6.5 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 4.7, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 7.3)
Nikki Cross: 6.5 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 7.0, Mic Skills 6.1)
EM: 6.4 (7.3, 8.6, 5.3, 4.2)
Sonya Deville: 6.3 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 5.5, Mic Skills 5.3)
Mandy Rose: 6.2 (Look/Presence 8.6, In-Ring Ability 5.3, Charisma 5.7, Mic Skills 5.2)
SD: 6.2 (7.3, 6.9, 5.4, 5.2)
MR: 6.1 (8.4, 5.2, 5.6, 5.1)
Peyton Royce: 6.1 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 5.1, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 5.6)
Bayley: 6.1 (Look/Presence 6.3, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 3.8)
B: 5.9 (6.1, 7.5, 6.5, 3.6)
Billie Kay: 5.6 (Look/Presence 6.4, In-Ring Ability 4.0, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 6.0)
BK: 5.4 (6.2, 3.9, 5.7, 5.8)
Natalya: 5.4 (Look/Presence 5.8, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 3.7, Mic Skills 4.6)
N: 5.2 (5.5, 7.2, 3.5, 4.4)
Nia Jax: 3.5 (Look/Presence 5.3, In-Ring Ability 2.9, Charisma 3.2, Mic Skills 2.6)
NJ: 3.3 (5.0, 2.7, 2.9, 2.4)
Tamina: 2.8 (Look/Presence 5.3, In-Ring Ability 3.1, Charisma 1.3, Mic Skills 1.3)
T: 2.4 (4.6, 2.7, 1.1, 1.1)

Today we will rate Roman Reigns since he won the previous poll. This is your turn to vote. Make sure to keep up!

Please set each quality in this order (Look/Presence, In-Ring Ability, Charisma, Mic Skills), so it'll be easier to count your votes :)

NOTE: If you feel like you missed out on a previous rating thread of a superstar, then it is NOT too late!! I am still willing to count any of your votes for any old rating threads from this year. You folks have until the END OF THIS DECEMBER to do this; so just be sure to let me know which old rating thread you want me to include your vote in, and just be sure that it's from a thread in 2019. If you even feel like bumping up any of my older rating threads, then go right on ahead! My rankings are based off the MOST UPDATED standings. The MORE votes that are included to ALL of this, the MORE accurate the results will be :D

Edit: Don't forget that the poll is MULTIPLE CHOICE.

Previous Threads:

https://www.wrestlingforum.com/classic-wrestling/2397760-rate-classic-superstar-bret-hart-edition.html

https://www.wrestlingforum.com/raw/2397762-rate-current-superstar-nia-jax-edition.html
 
  • Like
Reactions: JRL

·
Currently lying down wearing a blue suit
Joined
·
10,994 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
Roman Reigns:

Look/Presence: 10/10

In-Ring Ability: 7.5/10

Charisma: 6.5/10

Mic Skills: 6.5/10
 

·
THE EXTREME HORSEMEN
Joined
·
5,979 Posts
Look/Presence - 10/10
In-ring ability - 9.5/10
Charisma - 8.5/10
Mic skills - 8/10
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,406 Posts
Look/Presence: 9

He's got a pretty good look. He looks intimidating and he fits the role of a powerhouse. The whole tactical gear is kind of played out at this point, but it's a minor criticism.

In-ring ability - 8.5

Roman has learned and grown over the years. He's had some really good matches. The superman punch is kind of dumb (or maybe it's the way Cole sells it) but he's a solid hand at this point in his career.

Charisma - 8

He's always had a look and a presence to him dating back to when he was the silent man of The Shield. Unfortunately, he has had some real stinker promos and I've found many of his attempts as comedy as lame and sometimes his tough guy act can be eye roll worthy. But overall he's not too bad.

Mic skills - 7.5

Short and sweet was the key with Roman but they didn't stick with it. When I was typing in a grade all I could remember was "sufferin' succotash, son". Although I will say when he announced his leukemia was back he spoke from the heart and came across as very genuine and likeable. It was a completely different side of him. I wish they found a way to incorporate that into his promos a little more.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
689 Posts
Look/Presence: 10/10
In-Ring Ability: 7/10
Charisma: 8/10
Mic Skills: 7/10 - Well he is a 7 when he doesn't have some 70 year old moron in his ear telling him to say "Sufferin Succotash" and "Tater Tots"
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,498 Posts
look/presence: 9 He does have a good look like there is a reason Vince likes him as much as he does and this is it right here

in-ring ability: 7.5 He isn't on the level of some of the more workrate oriented guys but he is easily good enough to hold his own with them and as long as the styles mesh properly he's actually capable of having a good match with the less impressive talents (though sometimes he does have his stinkers dude has no chemistry with Brock for instance or really Drew for that matter the latter being quite surprising)

Charisma: 8 Say what you want about him but he does have something to him he's not the charisma vacuum that a lot of people call him he can hold attention pretty well if not in a shitty situation and can come across actually really well if given any shred of decent booking (which he almost never is)

Mic skills: 7 Still his weakest area though he has improved a lot in this area in particular when promos are kept short and sweet though he's really still not suited to the longform traditional WWE starting promo.

Overall if WWE didn't drop the ball try to pick it back up but instead accidentally kicked it down a cliff then threw a rock that knocked it down into the abyss and then blocked off the entrance just to make sure it can't be picked up again Roman would actually be a great main eventer if not quite top guy talent wise rather than the incredibly hated and ridiculously overpushed before he was ready talent he became.
 

·
F*** This indy flippy shit
Joined
·
2,244 Posts
Look/Presence - 8/10. This is his claim to fame. Although I think his physique is overrated. I’m not overly impressed with his muscle mass/definition. The women love him though.

In-ring ability - 5/10. Extremely boring move-set. The Superman Punch is C level MMA at best.

Charisma - 2/10. At least Cena was charismatic, Reigns is a dud. Probably his biggest flaw.

Mic skills - 4/10. His delivery is your standard wwe memorized promo. His lines though are some of the worst ever. Just absolutely corny as fuck.

I didn’t mind Reigns as the silent assassin/enforcer role during the early Shield days, but as the new Cena. GTFO, Cena sucked too but at least he had charisma and could talk.
 

·
Smokin' Da Good Stuff
Joined
·
2,751 Posts
Looks / presence 9/10

In Ring Ability 7/10

Charisma 5/10

Mic Skills 5/10


He's Vince's favorite after Brock , I'm happy he got over the big c. I'm actually looking forward to him and Undertaker kicking Drew and Shane all over , drew has really dropped recently talks a good game.

Peace.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DammitChrist

·
My mom thinks I'm cool.
Joined
·
2,108 Posts
Look/Presence: 9
In-Ring Ability: 7.5
Charisma: 7
Mic Skills: 7
 
  • Like
Reactions: DammitChrist

·
I will make something truly astonishing!
Joined
·
4,218 Posts
Look/Presence: 6 - the Shield gear should'a been berried a long, long time ago. Give him a fresh look and wash off the stink a bit. That detracts from what otherwise is a good 'WWE' look.

In-Ring Ability: 4 - painting by numbers. Sell, pretend he's choking for no apparent reason, wankfist - spear - meh. OK at what he does, but it's not exciting.

Charisma: 2 - managed to fail despite having his balls gently cupped by Vince's loving hands for 6 or 7 years. sad really.

Mic Skills: 2 - delivers everything without passion. Simply shouting BITCH at people does not a good promo make. Been absolutely owned by anyone above average unless they've not been allowed to speak.
 
1 - 20 of 43 Posts
Top