Wrestling Forum banner

Who should we rate next?


  • Total voters
    8
  • This poll will close: .
1 - 13 of 13 Posts

·
Currently lying down wearing a blue suit
Joined
·
10,597 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Yep, you know the drill. This is a women's week, which means that it is now time to rate another classic female superstar. I'd like to thank those of you who participated in my previous threads. Remember that all of your votes DO matter, but please just try to be objective. Let's also try to get as many responses here as possible now :eek:

As you already know, Undertaker ended up being ranked at 5th place in the classic section so far. Unfortunately for Undertaker, the ratings for his mic skills hurt him dramatically. However, the Phenom did receive an incredible score for his look/presence. I will repeat that Undertaker now has the highest score and a perfect rating for his look/presence out of anyone rated in the classic section so far. He also now has the 3rd highest score for having the most charisma compared to the rest of the talents rated in the classic section already.

As you already know, Humberto Carrillo ended up being ranked at 7th place in the cruiserweight section so far. Unfortunately for Carrillo, the ratings for his mic skills hurt him drastically. However, he did receive a very good score for his in-ring ability. I will repeat that Carrillo is now tied with Akira Tozawa at 4th place for having the best in-ring ability compared to the rest of the cruiserweight talents rated so far.

Here are the updated standings:

Classic:

Steve Austin: 9.6 (Look/Presence 9.7, In-Ring Ability 9.0, Charisma 9.9, Mic Skills 9.7)
Chris Jericho: 9.1 (Look/Presence 8.1, In-Ring Ability 8.8, Charisma 9.7, Mic Skills 9.8)
Kurt Angle: 9.1 (Look/Presence 8.9, In-Ring Ability 9.4, Charisma 9.0, Mic Skills 8.9)
Bret Hart: 8.8 (Look/Presence 9.3, In-Ring Ability 9.9, Charisma 8.6, Mic Skills 7.5)
Undertaker: 8.8 (Look/Presence 10.0, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 9.6, Mic Skills 7.4)
Eddie Guerrero: 8.7 (Look/Presence 8.1, In-Ring Ability 9.4, Charisma 9.2, Mic Skills 8.2)
Shawn Michaels: 8.7 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 9.4, Charisma 9.0, Mic Skills 8.0)
Edge: 8.4 (Look/Presence 8.4, In-Ring Ability 7.8, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 8.7)
E: 8.2 (8.2, 7.6, 8.4, 8.5)
Batista: 8.2 (Look/Presence 9.7, In-Ring Ability 6.8, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 7.5)
Rob Van Dam: 7.9 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 8.9, Mic Skills 6.1)
Christian: 7.9 (Look/Presence 6.7, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 8.4, Mic Skills 8.1)
Goldberg: 7.3 (Look/Presence 9.7, In-Ring Ability 5.0, Charisma 9.0, Mic Skills 5.6)

Current:

Samoa Joe: 8.9 (Look/Presence 8.9, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 9.5)
Daniel Bryan: 8.9 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 9.7, Charisma 9.2, Mic Skills 8.6)
John Cena: 8.7 (Look/Presence 9.2, In-Ring Ability 7.2, Charisma 9.4, Mic Skills 9.1)
Randy Orton: 8.2 (Look/Presence 9.3, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 7.2)
EC3: 8.1 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 8.0, Mic Skills 8.5)
Bray Wyatt: 8.1 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 8.8)
The Miz: 8.0 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 6.9, Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 9.3)
Dean Ambrose: 7.9 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 6.9. Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 8.5)
AJ Styles: 7.9 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 9.3, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 6.6)
BW: 7.8 (7.9, 6.4, 8.4, 8.6)
Jeff Hardy: 7.8 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 9.4, Mic Skills 5.7)
Seth Rollins: 7.7 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 8.3, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 6.9)
R-Truth: 7.7 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 7.9)
Aleister Black: 7.5 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 8.3, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 6.6)
Kevin Owens: 7.5 (Look/Presence 6.0, In-Ring Ability 7.7, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 8.4)
Sheamus: 7.5 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 6.9, Mic Skills 7.0)
SR: 7.4 (7.7, 8.1, 7.3, 6.6)
Dolph Ziggler: 7.4 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 7.0, Mic Skills 6.9)
Braun Strowman: 7.4 (Look/Presence 9.4, In-Ring Ability 5.9. Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 6.1)
Matt Riddle: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 5.8)
Bobby Roode: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 7.1, Charisma 7.2, Mic Skills 7.0)
Cesaro: 7.3 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 9.3, Charisma 6.4, Mic Skills 5.0)
Brock Lesnar: 7.2 (Look/Presence 9.5, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 4.1)
Rusev: 7.2 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 6.6)
Elias: 7.2 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 5.4, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 7.9)
Rey Mysterio: 7.1 (Look/Presence 7.0, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 5.6)
Sami Zayn: 7.0 (Look/Presence 4.9, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 7.1, Mic Skills 7.6)
Andrade Cien Almas: 7.0 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 8.8, Charisma 7.2, Mic Skills 3.9)
BL: 6.9 (9.2, 7.0, 7.5, 3.8)
Jason Jordan: 6.9 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 6.1, Mic Skills 5.4)
SZ: 6.8 (4.8, 8.2, 6.9, 7.4)
Drew McIntyre: 6.8 (Look/Presence 9.1, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 4.8, Mic Skills 5.7)
Finn Balor: 6.7 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 6.4, Mic Skills 5.2)
Mustafa Ali: 6.7 (Look/Presence 6.0, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 6.1, Mic Skills 6.4)
Roman Reigns: 6.7 (Look/Presence 8.7, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 5.4)
Chad Gable: 6.5 (Look/Presence 6.0, In-Ring Ability 8.3, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 5.7)
Shinsuke Nakamura: 6.4 (Look/Presence 7.1, In-Ring Ability 7.3, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 3.7)
Baron Corbin: 6.3 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 6.4, Charisma 6.1, Mic Skills 6.4)
CG: (5.7, 8.2, 5.7, 5.4)
SN: 6.2 (6.9, 7.0, 7.4, 3.6)
Bobby Lashley: 6.1 (Look/Presence 9.5, In-Ring Ability 6.7, Charisma 4.3, Mic Skills 3.9)
Jinder Mahal: 5.7 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 4.7, Charisma 5.1, Mic Skills 5.1)
AOP: 5.5 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 6.4, Charisma 4.1, Mic Skills 3.3)
JM: 5.4 (7.3, 4.5, 4.8, 4.9)
Ricochet: 4.7 (Look/Presence 4.9, In-Ring Ability 6.4, Charisma 4.4, Mic Skills 2.9)
R: 4.6 (4.8, 6.3, 4.3, 2.8)

Women:

Becky Lynch: 8.3 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 7.8, Charisma 8.8, Mic Skills 8.2)
Trish Stratus: 8.3 (Look/Presence 9.5, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 7.5)
BL: 8.2 (8.2, 7.7, 8.7, 8.0)
Mickie James: 8.1 (Look/Presence 8.5, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 8.0, Mic Skills 7.9)
TS: 7.9 (9.2, 7.1, 8.3, 7.1)
Asuka: 7.9 (Look/Presence 8.5, In-Ring Ability 8.9, Charisma 8.8, Mic Skills 5.3)
Alexa Bliss: 7.9 (Look/Presence 8.4, In-Ring Ability 6.0, Charisma 8.5, Mic Skills 8.6)
AJ Lee: 7.8 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 8.6, Mic Skills 8.1)
Toni Storm: 7.8 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 6.3)
Rhea Ripley: 7.8 (Look/Presence 8.9, In-Ring Ability 7.7, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 6.7)
Melina: 7.6 (Look/Presence 8.4, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 7.4, Mic Skills 7.4)
AJL: 7.5 (7.1, 6.8, 8.3, 7.7)
Io Shirai: 7.4 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 8.9, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 4.7)
Gail Kim: 7.4 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 6.7, Mic Skills 6.6)
Ruby Riott: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.0, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 7.7)
Charlotte Flair: 7.3 (Look/Presence 8.1, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 6.0)
Beth Phoenix: 7.3 (Look/Presence 9.1, In-Ring Ability 7.7, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 5.7)
Sasha Banks: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 6.2)
Molly Holly: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.1, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 6.9)
Kairi Sane: 7.2 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 4.4)
RR: 7.1 (6.7, 7.8, 6.5, 7.5)
Lacey Evans: 7.1 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 5.9, Charisma 7.1, Mic Skills 7.0)
Lita: 7.0 (Look/Presence 8.5, In-Ring Ability 6.3, Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 5.2)
KS: 7.0 (7.7, 8.5, 7.5, 4.2)
GK: 6.9 (7.5, 7.7, 6.3, 6.2)
Chyna: 6.9 (Look/Presence 9.5, In-Ring Ability 5.2, Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 4.7)
Ronda Rousey: 6.7 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 7.2, Charisma 6.9, Mic Skills 4.3)
Ember Moon: 6.5 (Look/Presence 7.6, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 5.4, Mic Skills 4.3)
Carmella: 6.5 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 4.7, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 7.3)
Nikki Cross: 6.5 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 7.0, Mic Skills 6.1)
EM: 6.4 (7.3, 8.6, 5.3, 4.2)
Sonya Deville: 6.3 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 5.5, Mic Skills 5.3)
Mandy Rose: 6.2 (Look/Presence 8.6, In-Ring Ability 5.3, Charisma 5.7, Mic Skills 5.2)
SD: 6.2 (7.3, 6.9, 5.4, 5.2)
MR: 6.1 (8.4, 5.2, 5.6, 5.1)
Peyton Royce: 6.1 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 5.1, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 5.6)
Bayley: 6.1 (Look/Presence 6.3, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 3.8)
B: 5.9 (6.1, 7.5, 6.5, 3.6)
Nikki Bella: 5.9 (Look/Presence 7.3, In-Ring Ability 5.5, Charisma 6.0, Mic Skills 4.6)
NB: 5.7 (7.0, 5.4, 5.7, 4.5)
Billie Kay: 5.6 (Look/Presence 6.4, In-Ring Ability 4.0, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 6.0)
Maryse: 5.6 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 3.9, Charisma 6.0, Mic Skills 4.9)
BK: 5.4 (6.2, 3.9, 5.7, 5.8)
Natalya: 5.4 (Look/Presence 5.8, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 3.7, Mic Skills 4.6)
N: 5.2 (5.5, 7.2, 3.5, 4.4)
Naomi: 4.9 (Look/Presence 6.3, In-Ring Ability 5.4, Charisma 4.6, Mic Skills 3.2)
Kelly Kelly: 4.7 (Look/Presence 8.1, In-Ring Ability 2.7, Charisma 5.3, Mic Skills 2.8)
N: 4.6 (6.0, 5.0, 4.3, 3.0)
Alicia Fox: 4.5 (Look/Presence 5.6, In-Ring Ability 4.3, Charisma 4.4, Mic Skills 3.7)
Brie Bella: 4.1 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 2.9, Charisma 4.4, Mic Skills 3.0)
DB: 4.1 (5.2, 4.2, 3.5, 3.4)
BB: 3.9 (5.9, 2.8, 4.1, 2.8)
Dana Brooke: 3.9 (Look/Presence 5.1, In-Ring Ability 4.0, Charisma 3.3, Mic Skills 3.1)
Nia Jax: 3.5 (Look/Presence 5.3, In-Ring Ability 2.9, Charisma 3.2, Mic Skills 2.6)
NJ: 3.3 (5.0, 2.7, 2.9, 2.4)
Tamina: 2.8 (Look/Presence 5.3, In-Ring Ability 3.1, Charisma 1.3, Mic Skills 1.3)
T: 2.4 (4.6, 2.7, 1.1, 1.1)

Cruiserweight:

Brian Kendrick: 7.5 (Look/Presence 6.9, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 7.7, Mic Skills 7.5)
Drew Gulak: 7.2 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 7.0, Mic Skills 7.4)
Buddy Murphy: 6.9 (Look/Presence 7.6, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 5.8)
Jack Gallagher: 6.7 (Look/Presence 6.1, In-Ring Ability 7.7, Charisma 6.4, Mic Skills 6.5)
Akira Tozawa: 5.6 (Look/Presence 5.7, In-Ring Ability 7.8, Charisma 6.3, Mic Skills 2.7)
Mike Kanellis: 5.6 (Look/Presence 6.0, In-Ring Ability 6.0, Charisma 4.5, Mic Skills 5.7)
Humberto Carrillo: 5.4 (Look/Presence 5.6, In-Ring Ability 7.8, Charisma 4.5, Mic Skills 3.5)
Kalisto: 5.3 (Look/Presence 5.6, In-Ring Ability 7.1 Charisma 4.8, Mic Skills 3.8)
Cedric Alexander: 5.3 (Look/Presence 5.3, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 4.8, Mic Skills 3.6)
CA: 5.1 (5.0, 7.3, 4.6, 3.4)
HC: 5.0 (5.1, 7.4, 4.1, 3.3)
Oney Lorcan: 4.4 (Look/Presence 3.4, In-Ring Ability 7.1, Charisma 3.8, Mic Skills 3.2)

Today we will rate Michelle McCool since she also won the previous poll. This is your turn to vote. Make sure to keep up!

Please set each quality in this order (Look/Presence, In-Ring Ability, Charisma, Mic Skills), so it'll be easier to count your votes :)

NOTE: If you feel like you missed out on a previous rating thread of a superstar, then it is NOT too late!! I am still willing to count any of your votes for any old rating threads from this year. You folks have until the END OF THIS DECEMBER to do this; so just be sure to let me know which old rating thread you want me to include your vote in, and just be sure that it's from a thread in 2019. If you even feel like bumping up any of my older rating threads, then go right on ahead! My rankings are based off the MOST UPDATED standings. The MORE votes that are included to ALL of this, the MORE accurate the results will be :D

Edit: Don't forget that the poll is MULTIPLE CHOICE.

Previous Threads:

https://www.wrestlingforum.com/general-wwe/2407630-rate-classic-superstar-undertaker-edition.html

https://www.wrestlingforum.com/raw/2407634-rate-current-superstar-humberto-carrillo-edition.html
 

·
Currently lying down wearing a blue suit
Joined
·
10,597 Posts
Discussion Starter #2
Michelle McCool:

Look/Presence: 9.5/10

In-Ring Ability: 7.5/10

Charisma: 6.5/10

Mic Skills: 6.5/10
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
597 Posts
Look/Presence - She was hot but looked too bland for a wrestler imo 6/10
Charisma - 4/10
Inring - For her era one of the best women so 7/10, Today more like 3 or 4.
Mic - 6/10
 

·
Currently lying down wearing a blue suit
Joined
·
10,597 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
I'll just bump up this thread due to the low number of votes. It's not too late to rate Michelle McCool as an overall talent :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,395 Posts
I'll just bump up this thread due to the low number of votes. It's not too late to rate Michelle McCool as an overall talent :)
This is one of those cases where I'd feel like a fraud if a rated her.

I mean I could give her an 8 for looks/presence for being reasonably hot, to sound a chauvinistic as possible, but even that seems fraudulent.

I just haven't seen enough of her to give her a rating objective or subjective.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,272 Posts
I'll just bump up this thread due to the low number of votes. It's not too late to rate Michelle McCool as an overall talent :)
Goes to show the kind of work she did and the impact she had on the business.

Look/Presence: 4
In-Ring Ability: 3
Charisma: 0
Mic Skills: 1
 

·
alexa = greatest of all time!
Joined
·
2,865 Posts
Look/Presence: 8/10

In-Ring Ability: 5.5/10

Charisma: 4/10

Mic Skills: 4/10
 
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
Top