Wrestling Forum banner
1 - 20 of 38 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,818 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
In Bret Hart's book, ''Hitman'', he talks about a rating system for wrestlers. He gives a mark to wrestlers out of 10 for three aspects of wrestling.

You then add the marks together and obviously the closer to the perfect 30, the better the wrestler and vice versa.

Anyway, I thought it would be interesting to see what people rate the WWE rosters so here it goes.

1. Look/physical presence
2. The ability to talk/sell yourself
3. Wrestling talent/the ability to work
(For example, Hulk Hogan - 10/10/5)

Alberto Del Rio -
Big Show -
Caylen Croft -
Chavo Guerrero -
Chris Masters -
Christian-
Cody Rhodes -
Curt Hawkins -
Dolph Ziggler -
Drew McIntyre -
Edge -
Jack Swagger -
Joey Mercury -
JTG -
Kane -
Kaval -
Kofi Kingston -
Luke Gallows -
MVP -
Rey Mysterio -
Trent Barretta -
Tyler Reks -
The Undertaker -
Vance Archer -


Divas

Beth Phoenix -
Kelly Kelly -
Layla -
Michelle McCool -
Rosa Mendes -
Tiffany -
-
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
621 Posts
Alberto Del Rio - 7/7/7
Big Show - 9/6/3
Caylen Croft - who?
Chavo Guerrero - 4/5/8
Chris Masters - 6/2/6
Christian- 8/8/8
Cody Rhodes - 7/7/6
Curt Hawkins - who?
Dolph Ziggler - 7/6/7
Drew McIntyre - 8/7/5
Edge - 9/9/8
Jack Swagger - 6/4/8
Joey Mercury - 5/5/5
JTG - ...
Kane - 9/8/6
Kaval - 6/4/8
Kofi Kingston - 6/5/7
Luke Gallows - 6/5/4
MVP - 7/6/6
Rey Mysterio - 9/5/7
Trent Barretta - who?
Tyler Reks - 6/3/2
The Undertaker - 10/8/6
Vance Archer - ...

Divas

Beth Phoenix - 6/5/9
Kelly Kelly - 8/5/1
Layla - 7/7/2
Michelle McCool - 6/4/8
Rosa Mendes - who?
Tiffany - ...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,187 Posts
Alberto Del Rio - 6/4/6
Big Show - 9/4/4
Chavo Guerrero - 4/5/7
Christian - 5/9/9
Cody Rhodes - 6/6/4
Dolph Ziggler - 8/7/8
Drew McIntyre - 6/3/3
Edge - 8/8/8
Jack Swagger - 7/4/7
Kane - 7/8/5
Kaval - 6/4/9
Kofi Kingston - 5/6/7
MVP - 5/7/7
Rey Mysterio - 8/5/9
The Undertaker - 10/6/9

Left a few out. :/
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
7,852 Posts
I have no interest in a list of all wrestlers from Smackdown, with a system next to it, made by an old man. People will like who they wanna like, regardless of if they have a bad score next to them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,200 Posts
Alberto Del Rio - 8/7/8
Big Show - 9/4/2
Caylen Croft - 2/5/6
Chavo Guerrero - 4/4/8
Chris Masters - 7/2/4
Christian- 5/8/9
Cody Rhodes - 3/6/6
Curt Hawkins - 7/6/6
Dolph Ziggler - 7/7/9
Drew McIntyre - 9/5/7
Edge - 9/7/6
Jack Swagger - 7/2/10
Joey Mercury - 2/1/5
JTG - 5/6/5
Kane - 5/9/2
Kaval - 3/2/9
Kofi Kingston - 6/5/6
Luke Gallows - 5/4/6
MVP - 5/7/5
Rey Mysterio - 5/5/8
Trent Barretta - 8/6/8
Tyler Reks - 7/1/3
The Undertaker - 10/5/8
Vance Archer - 2/2/3

Divas

Beth Phoenix - 8/5/10
Kelly Kelly - 2/1/1
Layla - 5/7/5
Michelle McCool - 6/2/8
Rosa Mendes - 1/1/1
Tiffany - 4/4/6
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
510 Posts
Alberto Del Rio - 8/8/9
Big Show - 9/7/5
Caylen Croft - who?
Chavo Guerrero - 4/5/8
Chris Masters - 8/2/6
Christian- 6/8/9
Cody Rhodes - 6/7/7
Curt Hawkins - who?
Dolph Ziggler - 7/7/7
Drew McIntyre - 7/6/5
Edge - 8/10/8
Jack Swagger - 7/3/9
Joey Mercury - 5/4/6
JTG - 4/3/5
Kane - 8/7/5
Kaval - 4/4/8
Kofi Kingston - 6/4/7
Luke Gallows - 7/4/5
MVP - 7/7/7
Rey Mysterio - 8/3/7
Trent Barretta - who?
Tyler Reks - 7/2/6
The Undertaker - 9/8/8
Vance Archer - ...

Divas

Beth Phoenix - 8/5/9
Kelly Kelly - 8/5/5
Layla - 7/7/4
Michelle McCool - 7/4/6
Rosa Mendes - who?
Tiffany - ...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
102 Posts
Alberto Del Rio -8.5/8.5/8.5
Big Show -7/8/6
Caylen Croft -6/5/6
Chavo Guerrero -6/7/8
Chris Masters -8/6/5
Christian-7.5/8/8
Cody Rhodes -8/8/7.5
Curt Hawkins -7/6.5/7
Dolph Ziggler -8/7.5/8
Drew McIntyre -7/7/7
Edge -8/9/8
Jack Swagger -8/8.5/8.5
Joey Mercury -6/6/7
JTG -6/6/6
Kane -8/9/7
Kaval -7/7.5/8
Kofi Kingston -8/8/8
Luke Gallows -7.5/6/6.5
MVP -7.5/8/7.5
Rey Mysterio -8/8/8
Trent Barretta -6/6.5/6
Tyler Reks -6/6/6
The Undertaker -9/8/10
Vance Archer -7.5/6/6.5

Divas

Beth Phoenix -9/7/8
Kelly Kelly -6/6/5
Layla -7.5/7/6.5
Michelle McCool -7.5/7/7
Rosa Mendes -7/6/5
Tiffany -6.5/6/5
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
151 Posts
1. Look/physical presence
2. The ability to talk/sell yourself
3. Wrestling talent/the ability to work
(For example, Hulk Hogan - 10/10/5)

Alberto Del Rio - 9/10/9
Big Show - 7/7/6
Chavo Guerrero - 7/6/8
Chris Masters - 9/5/5
Christian- 7/7/9
Cody Rhodes - 7/8/7
Dolph Ziggler - 8/8/8
Drew McIntyre - 8/8/7
Edge - 8/10/8
Jack Swagger - 8/9/9
Joey Mercury - 7/6/7
JTG - 6/5/6
Kane - 9/10/7
Kaval - 8/7/10
Kofi Kingston - 7/7/9
Luke Gallows - 6/3/2
MVP - 7/7/7
Rey Mysterio - 7/5/8
Tyler Reks - 6/6/7
The Undertaker - 10/8/8
Vance Archer - 8/6/6

Divas

Beth Phoenix - 9/6/9
Kelly Kelly - 6/4/5
Layla - 7/9/7
Michelle McCool - 7/9/7
Rosa Mendes - 8/6/6
Tiffany - 6/5/5
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,506 Posts
Gonna do this like I did in the Raw thread.

Alberto Del Rio (9) - LOVED his second match with Rey Mysterio, and his finisher is great. I can see him becoming World Champion, fairly quick.
Big Show (7) - I just don't think there's a place for him in todays WWE.
The Dudebusters (8) - They both get an 8 from me, but I think they would be better off as faces. They could be the new Edge and Christian!
Chavo Guerrero (7) - While I think he's great in the ring, I feel that he is past his prime and there isn't much of a place for him.
Chris Masters (8) - Shame to think he was in the main event 4 years ago. I would love to see him as IC Champion, he could be huge.
Christian (10) - I'm not the biggest fan but he always puts on a good match. He also doesn't seem to have a problem putting people over.
Cody Rhodes (9) - He's been the absolute highlight of Smackdown for me! I would give him a 10 but I still think he needs a little more improvement in the ring.
Curt Hawkins (7) - He is best as a tag team wrestler. Should never have split from Archer.
Dolph Ziggler (10) - One of WWE's best younger stars. He can wrestle really well and talk on the mic.
Drew McIntyre (9) - Also one of WWE's best younger stars. He can wrestle, talk, and has the look of a main eventer.
Edge (10) - Like Triple H, too many classic matches for me to give anything less. He is one of the all-time best.
Jack Swagger (10) - I really wish he was World Champion again. I really enjoy watching him in the ring, he is the future.
Joey Mercury (6) - He hasn't done much since returning. So I can't really rate him any higher.
JTG (6) - He gets a 6, because I think he is better off with Shad.
Kane (6) - I don't enjoy any of Kane's matches and haven't since about 2004. He seems really slow in the ring and I don't enjoy his promos at all.
Kaval (10) - 10 for me, easily. He is extremely exciting to watch. One of WWE's best.
Kofi Kingston (8) - He has put on some good matches in the past, and is pretty popular with the crowd.
Luke Gallows (7) - I don't think he'll be lasting much longer, sadly. I would rate him above guys like Zeke, Reks and Kozlov.
MVP (10) - Easy 10 for me. He can wrestle, talk and play his character extremely well. He is the full package, sucks WWE doesn't see it that way.
Rey Mysterio (10) - Like Edge and Triple H, too many classic matches for anything less.
Tyler Reks (5) - Haven't seen much, but I'm not liking him.
The Undertaker (10) - Too many classic matches for anything less.
Vance Archer (6) - See Hawkins.
Beth Phoenix (10) - Her and Natalya are in a completely different league in the divas division. Easy 10 for me.
Kelly Kelly (5) - Pretty much only pushed because of her looks. I give her a 5 because of her ring improvement and popularity.
Layla (5) - Not a HUGE fan, but she has improved alot in the ring.
Michelle McCool (9) - Best model-turned-wrestler imo. I enjoy watching her matches.
Rosa Mendes (2) - IMO the worst diva on the roster. She looks extremely out of place in the ring.
Tiffany (6) - She looked comfortable in the ring and looked like she knew what she was doing.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,971 Posts
Alberto Del Rio - 8/7/8
Big Show - 7/6/6
Caylen Croft - 6/6/6
Chavo Guerrero -6/6/7
Chris Masters -7/5/7
Christian-9/9/8
Cody Rhodes -8/8/7
Curt Hawkins -7/7/7
Dolph Ziggler -9/9/10
Drew McIntyre -8/8/7
Edge -9/9/10
Jack Swagger -9/8/9
Joey Mercury -7/6/6
JTG -6/6/5
Kane -7/9/7
Kaval -7/7/7
Kofi Kingston - 8/5/8
Luke Gallows -6/6/5
MVP -8/8/8
Rey Mysterio -9/9/9
Trent Barretta - 6/6/6
Tyler Reks -7/4/6
The Undertaker -9/8/7
Vance Archer -7/7/6

Divas

Beth Phoenix -8/8/8
Kelly Kelly -9/6/6
Layla -9/9/7
Michelle McCool - 9/9/8
Rosa Mendes -6/5/6
Tiffany -6/6/6
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,156 Posts
Alberto Del Rio - 8/9/9.5
Big Show - 8/8/6
Caylen Croft - 8/7.5/8
Chavo Guerrero - 7/8/9
Chris Masters - 9/7/8
Christian- 7/9.5/9
Cody Rhodes - 8/8/9
Curt Hawkins - 9/7.5/8
Dolph Ziggler - 8.5/8/9.5
Drew McIntyre - 8/7/8
Edge - 8/9.5/8.5
Jack Swagger - 7/7/9.5
Joey Mercury - 6.5/DUD/8
JTG - 7/7/7
Kane - 8/6/6
Kaval - 6/7/9.5
Kofi Kingston - 8/8/9
Luke Gallows - 7/8/7
MVP - 8/9.5/9
Rey Mysterio - 8/3/9.5
Trent Barretta - 8/8/9
Tyler Reks - 9/7/7
The Undertaker - 10/8/9
Vance Archer - 7/7/6
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
253 Posts
Alberto Del Rio - 8/8/9
Big Show - 9/8/5
Chavo Guerrero - 7/6/10
Chris Masters - 7/7/7
Christian- 8/8/8
Cody Rhodes - 6/6/8
Curt Hawkins - 9/7.5/8
Edge - 9/9/8
Jack Swagger - 7/8/9
Kane - 10/10/5
Kaval - 5/5/10
The Undertaker - 10/10/9
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
640 Posts
Alberto Del Rio - 6/9/6
Big Show - 8/8/5
Caylen Croft - 8/7/8
Chavo Guerrero - 5/8/9
Chris Masters - 10/7/9
Christian- 7/9/9
Cody Rhodes - 8/8/4
Curt Hawkins - 9/4/4
Dolph Ziggler - 8/8/8
Drew McIntyre - 8/7/5
Edge - 9/9/8.5
Jack Swagger - 7/7/9
Joey Mercury - 6.5/2/5
JTG - 4/4/6
Kane - 8/6/7
Kaval - 6/7/9
Kofi Kingston - 8/4/5
Luke Gallows - 6/4/4
MVP - 8/9.5/9
Rey Mysterio - 8/3/9.5
Trent Barretta - 8/8/7
Tyler Reks - 9/4/5
The Undertaker - 10/9/10
Vance Archer - 7/7/6
 

·
Unlucky! Better luck next time!
Joined
·
416 Posts
1. Look/physical presence
2. The ability to talk/sell yourself
3. Wrestling talent/the ability to work
(For example, Hulk Hogan - 10/10/5)

Alberto Del Rio - 8/9/9
Big Show - 9/7/6
Chavo Guerrero - 5/6/8
Chris Masters - 9/5/8
Christian- 8/6/9
Cody Rhodes - 9/8/7
Dolph Ziggler - 9/8/8
Drew McIntyre - 6/6/6
Edge - 8/9/9
Jack Swagger - 7/9/10
Joey Mercury - 5/6/7
JTG - 6/5/6
Kane - 9/10/7
Kaval - 7/5/10
Kofi Kingston - 8/6/9
Luke Gallows - 6/3/4
MVP - 9/8/8
Rey Mysterio - 10/3/8
Tyler Reks - 8/6/7
The Undertaker - 10/9/10
Vance Archer - 8/6/6

Divas

Beth Phoenix - 7/6/9
Kelly Kelly - 9/4/5
Layla - 7/9/9
Michelle McCool - 7/9/8
Rosa Mendes - who the fuck is that?
Tiffany - 6/5/5
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,013 Posts
Alberto Del Rio -7/7/7=21/30
Big Show -10/6/5=21/30
Caylen Croft -6/5/6=17/30
Chavo Guerrero -5/7/8=20/30
Chris Masters -9/5/5=19/30
Christian-7/8/9=24/30
Cody Rhodes -7/6/6=19/30
Curt Hawkins -6/6/6=18/30
Dolph Ziggler -6/6/7=19/30
Drew McIntyre -7/5/6=18/30
Edge -9/8/8=25/30
Jack Swagger -8/6/7=22/30
Joey Mercury -5/4/6=15/30
JTG -6/4/5=15/30
Kane -10/5/5=20/30
Kaval -5/5/8=18/30
Kofi Kingston -6/7/8=21/30
Luke Gallows -6/5/5=16/30
MVP -7/6/6=19/30
Rey Mysterio -6/5/10=21/30
Trent Barretta -6/5/6=17/30
Tyler Reks -7/5/5=17/30
The Undertaker -10/8/9=27/30
Vance Archer -7/3/5=15/30

Top 5 SmackDown Superstars:
1.The Undertaker-27/30
2.Edge-25/30
3.Christian-24/30
4.Jack Swagger-22/30
5.Kofi Kingston-21/30-Rey has the same score, but he annoys the everliving fuck out of me.


Beth Phoenix -8/6/8=22/30
Kelly Kelly -10/4/4=18/30
Layla -8/5/3=16/30
Michelle McCool -9/4/7=20/30
Rosa Mendes -5/5/3=13/30
Tiffany -8/6/6=20/30

SmackDown Diva Rankings:
1.Beth Phoenix-22/30
2.Tiffany-20/30(Same score as Michelle, but I prefer Tiffany)
3.Michelle McCool-20/30
4.Kelly Kelly-18/30
5.Layla-16/30
6.Rosa Mendes-13/30
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
8,283 Posts
Alberto Del Rio - 6/7/8
Big Show - 8/6/2 Tremendous size but not scarry anymore. Boring in the ring.
Caylen Croft - 6/5/7
Chavo Guerrero - 7/7/7
Chris Masters - 8/3/7 He's improved a lot but lost his physique.
Christian- 6/9/9 He'll be missed.
Cody Rhodes - 2/8/5
Curt Hawkins - ?/?/?
Dolph Ziggler - 8/7/8 Ziggler is amazing, the future.
Drew McIntyre - 6/2/3 This guy is fucking boring.
Edge - 8/8/7 Edge is not THAT great.
Jack Swagger - 7/8/5 He's overated in the ring.
Joey Mercury - 1/4/6
JTG - 2/3/5 I guess he makes a once a month appearance on Superstars.
Kane - 4/5/3 Go away already.
Kaval - 6/6/9 Waiting for Ziggler/Kaval match on a ppv soon.
Kofi Kingston - 7/7/7 He's decent but he never goes anywhere.
Luke Gallows - 5/6/3 What the hell happned to him since SES disbanded?
MVP - 8/7/4 MVP still has a job?
Rey Mysterio- 10/5/8
Trent Barretta- 6/5/7 Push the damn Dudebusters. Nah that won't happen.
Tyler Reks- 6/5/4 I just don't like this guy but he has improved a little.
The Undertaker- 8/8/5 He used to be a 10 in almost every department but he got old.
Vance Archer- 4/1/4 Haven't seen enough of him. He's not bad looking though I guess.

Divas

Beth Phoenix - Only/Talented/Diva
Kelly Kelly - Looks like a/Little girl but I'd still/ Hit it
Layla - Please just/Do/Porn
Michelle McCool - Bring/Back/Chuck Palumbo
Rosa Mendes - She can't Speak Spanish/But she's/Fucking hot
Tiffany - Kick/Drew McIntyre's/Ass
 
1 - 20 of 38 Posts
Top