Wrestling Forum banner

1 - 20 of 114 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,808 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
In Bret Hart's book, ''Hitman'', he talks about a rating system for wrestlers. He gives a mark to wrestlers out of 10 for three aspects of wrestling.

You then add the marks together and obviously the closer to the perfect 30, the better the wrestler and vice versa.

Anyway, I thought it would be interesting to see what people rate the WWE roster so here it goes.

1. Look/physical presence
2. The ability to talk/sell yourself
3. Wrestling talent/the ability to work
(For example, Hulk Hogan - 10/10/5)

RAW

Alex Riley -
CM Punk -
Daniel Bryan -
Darren Young -
David Hart Smith -
David Otunga -
Evan Bourne -
Ezekiel Jackson -
Goldust -
The Great Khali -
Heath Slater -
Husky Harris -
Jey Uso -
Jimmy Uso -
John Cena -
John Morrison -
Justin Gabriel -
Mark Heny -
Michael McGillicutty -
Michael Tarver -
The Miz -
Primo -
R-Truth -
Randy Orton -
Santino Marella -
Sheamus -
Skip Sheffield -
Ted DiBiase -
Triple H -
Tyson Kidd -
Vladmir Kozlov -
Wade Barrett -
William Regal -
Yoshi Tatsu -
Zach Ryder -


Divas

Alicia Fox -
Brie Bella -
Eve Torres -
Gail Kim -
Jilian Hall -
Maryse -
Melina -
Natalya -
Nikki Bella -
Tamina -
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
914 Posts
Alex Riley - 9/9/7
CM Punk - 7/10/8
Daniel Bryan - 5/7/10
Darren Young - 7/5/5
David Hart Smith - 7/2/4
David Otunga - 5/7/2
Evan Bourne - 9/3/8
Ezekiel Jackson - 10/4/5
Goldust - 9/4/6
The Great Khali - 8/1/3
Heath Slater - 5/6/5
Husky Harris - 8/6/6
Jey Uso - 6/6/5
Jimmy Uso - 6/6/5
John Cena - 9/9/9
John Morrison - 9/4/9
Justin Gabriel - 8/7/9
Mark Henry - 5/3/5
Michael McGillicutty - 7/1/7
Michael Tarver - 6/9/5
The Miz - 9/9/5
Primo - 7/6/6
R-Truth - 4/6/7
Randy Orton - 9/5/6
Santino Marella - 8/8/5
Sheamus - 4/8/8
Skip Sheffield - 9/7/7
Ted DiBiase - 8/2/5
Triple H - 9/9/10
Tyson Kidd - 8/3/7
Vladmir Kozlov - 7/4/6
Wade Barrett - 10/10/6
William Regal - 7/7/9
Yoshi Tatsu - 6/2/8
Zach Ryder - 9/6/6

Divas

Alicia Fox - 7/1/6
Brie Bella - 7/2/5
Eve Torres - 10/7/5
Gail Kim - 6/4/3
Jilian Hall - 7/0/3 (her singing does my skull in)
Maryse - 9/7/9
Melina - 7/5/9
Natalya - 10/8/9
Nikki Bella - 7/2/5
Tamina - 6/6/7

Didn't take long.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
115 Posts
Alex Riley - 9/9/7
CM Punk - 7/10/8
Daniel Bryan - 5/7/10
Darren Young - 7/5/5
David Hart Smith - 7/2/4
David Otunga - 5/7/2
Evan Bourne - 9/3/8
Ezekiel Jackson - 10/4/5
Goldust - 9/4/6
The Great Khali - 8/1/3
Heath Slater - 5/6/5
Husky Harris - 8/6/6
Jey Uso - 6/6/5
Jimmy Uso - 6/6/5
John Cena - 9/9/9
John Morrison - 9/4/9
Justin Gabriel - 8/7/9
Mark Henry - 5/3/5
Michael McGillicutty - 7/1/7
Michael Tarver - 6/9/5
The Miz - 9/9/5
Primo - 7/6/6
R-Truth - 4/6/7
Randy Orton - 9/5/6
Santino Marella - 8/8/5
Sheamus - 4/8/8
Skip Sheffield - 9/7/7
Ted DiBiase - 8/2/5
Triple H - 9/9/10
Tyson Kidd - 8/3/7
Vladmir Kozlov - 7/4/6
Wade Barrett - 10/10/6
William Regal - 7/7/9
Yoshi Tatsu - 6/2/8
Zach Ryder - 9/6/6

Divas

Alicia Fox - 7/1/6
Brie Bella - 7/2/5
Eve Torres - 10/7/5
Gail Kim - 6/4/3
Jilian Hall - 7/0/3 (her singing does my skull in)
Maryse - 9/7/9
Melina - 7/5/9
Natalya - 10/8/9
Nikki Bella - 7/2/5
Tamina - 6/6/7

Didn't take long.
:lmao Zack Rider better than Sheamus and Orton.
What did you use, a random number generator?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,187 Posts
Alex Riley - 6/8/5
CM Punk - 8/10/9
Daniel Bryan - 5/7/10
David Otunga - 7/5/1
Evan Bourne - 6/3/8
The Great Khali - 9/1/1
Heath Slater - 4/3/7
John Cena - 10/9/9
John Morrison - 8/5/8
Justin Gabriel - 8/5/8
Michael McGillicutty - gtfo now.
Michael Tarver - 7/7/6
The Miz - 6/7/5
R-Truth - 5/3/7
Randy Orton - 9/7/5
Santino Marella - 5/8/5
Sheamus - 8/5/5
Skip Sheffield - 7/5/6
Ted DiBiase - 7/4/3
Triple H - 9/9/9
Tyson Kidd - 3/4/8
Vladmir Kozlov - 6/4/4
Wade Barrett - 8/9/6
William Regal - 5/7/9
Zach Ryder - 4/4/6

left a few out..
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
290 Posts
1. Look/physical presence
2. The ability to talk/sell yourself
3. Wrestling talent/the ability to work
(For example, Hulk Hogan - 10/10/5)

RAW

Alex Riley - 9/9/8
CM Punk - 8/10/9
Daniel Bryan - 8/10/10
Darren Young - 7/5/7
David Hart Smith - 8/1/6
David Otunga - 10/3/1
Evan Bourne - 7/(Does he talk?)/8
Ezekiel Jackson - 10/5/7
Goldust - 8/10/9
The Great Khali - 10/1/3
Heath Slater - 6/6/7
Husky Harris - 1/2/5
Jey Uso - 7/6/8
Jimmy Uso - 7/6/8
John Cena - 10/10/10
John Morrison - 8/5/5
Justin Gabriel - 9/5/9
Mark Henry - 4/4/4
Michael McGillicutty - 6/1/6
Michael Tarver - 10/10/4
The Miz - 8/10/7
Primo - 5/5/5
R-Truth - 8/4/2
Randy Orton - 8/4/4
Santino Marella - 3/10/9
Sheamus - 10/9/8
Skip Sheffield - 10/6/6
Ted DiBiase - 7/3/5
Triple H - 10/10/10
Tyson Kidd - 4/1/6
Vladmir Kozlov - 6/4/8
Wade Barrett - 10/10/9
William Regal - 4/7/10
Yoshi Tatsu - 5/5/5
Zach Ryder - 6/8/8


Divas

Alicia Fox -
Brie Bella -
Eve Torres -
Gail Kim -
Jilian Hall -
Maryse -
Melina -
Natalya -
Nikki Bella -
Tamina -
[/QUOTE]
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,200 Posts
Alex Riley - 7/8/6
CM Punk - 8/10/9
Daniel Bryan - 3/6/10
Darren Young - 2/2/3
David Hart Smith - 6/2/5
David Otunga - 1/1/1
Evan Bourne - 1/3/7
Ezekiel Jackson - 8/3/2
Goldust - 7/7/7
The Great Khali - 10/0/0
Heath Slater - 3/3/6
Husky Harris - 5/7/5
Jey Uso - 4/6/6
Jimmy Uso - 4/6/6
John Cena - 9/8/6
John Morrison - 6/2/7
Justin Gabriel - 7/5/7
Mark Heny - 7/2/2
Michael McGillicutty - 6/2/5
Michael Tarver - 7/7/2
The Miz - 4/9/5
Primo - 4/3/7
R-Truth - 5/2/4
Randy Orton - 10/5/5
Santino Marella - 4/7/6
Sheamus - 7/7/6
Skip Sheffield - 8/4/6
Ted DiBiase - 7/2/4
Triple H - 10/10/6
Tyson Kidd - 2/2/8
Vladmir Kozlov - 6/1/0
Wade Barrett - 10/10/6
William Regal - 8/10/8
Yoshi Tatsu - 2/0/4
Zach Ryder - 3/8/8

Divas

Alicia Fox - 2/4/4
Brie Bella - 0/0/0
Eve Torres - 3/3/3
Gail Kim - 1/1/3
Jilian Hall - 1/1/1
Maryse - 6/5/3
Melina - 6/8/6
Natalya - 9/5/10
Nikki Bella - 0/0/0
Tamina - 7/2/6
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
510 Posts
Alex Riley - 6/7/4
CM Punk - 6/10/8
Daniel Bryan - 5/6/10
Darren Young - 5/6/5
David Hart Smith - 7/2/6
David Otunga - 6/6/4
Evan Bourne - 5/2/7
Ezekiel Jackson - 8/4/6
Goldust - 6/6/8
The Great Khali - 8/1/2
Heath Slater - 5/6/6
Husky Harris - 4/4/5
Jey Uso - 5/3/5
Jimmy Uso - 5/3/5
John Cena - 9/7/7
John Morrison - 7/5/8
Justin Gabriel - 6/6/7
Mark Heny - 7/4/6
Michael McGillicutty - 6/2/7
Michael Tarver - 7/3/5
The Miz - 6/8/6
Primo - 6/3/6
R-Truth - 7/4/6
Randy Orton - 8/3/7
Santino Marella - 6/8/6
Sheamus - 9/6/8
Skip Sheffield - 9/4/6
Ted DiBiase - 7/5/6
Triple H - 9/7/7
Tyson Kidd - 2/3/7
Vladmir Kozlov - 6/1/5
Wade Barrett - 7/8/7
William Regal - 6/8/8
Yoshi Tatsu - 3/2/6
Zach Ryder - 6/7/6

Divas

Alicia Fox - 5/4/5
Brie Bella - 6/4/4
Eve Torres - 6/5/6
Gail Kim - 7/2/6
Jilian Hall - 4/3/4
Maryse - 7/6/5
Melina - 5/4/6
Natalya - 6/2/6
Nikki Bella - 6/4/4
Tamina - 5/2/6
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
621 Posts
RAW

Alex Riley - ...
CM Punk - 7/10/8
Daniel Bryan - 5/5/10
Darren Young - 7/4/5
David Hart Smith -5/4/7
David Otunga - 7/7/1
Evan Bourne - 5/2/8
Ezekiel Jackson - 8/5/5
Goldust - 7/7/5
The Great Khali - 10/4/1
Heath Slater - 5/4/5
Husky Harris - ...
Jey Uso - ...
Jimmy Uso - ...
John Cena - 9/9/6
John Morrison - 8/5/7
Justin Gabriel - 7/5/6
Mark Heny - 8/3/3
Michael Tarver - 6/6/3
The Miz - 7/7/4
R-Truth - 7/5/5
Randy Orton - 9/6/7
Santino Marella - 4/8/?
Sheamus - 9/7/5
Skip Sheffield - 7/5/4
Ted DiBiase - 6/5/5
Triple H - 9/9/7
Tyson Kidd - 4/5/6
Vladmir Kozlov - 7/3/4
Wade Barrett - 7/7/4
William Regal - 4/8/8
Zach Ryder - 6/6/?

Divas

Alicia Fox - 5/3/4
Eve Torres - 9/5/5
Gail Kim - 6/?/9
Maryse - 9/?/?
Melina - 9/5/7
Natalya - 7/5/9
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,897 Posts
CM Punk - 9/10/9
Daniel Bryan - 5/8/10
Darren Young - 7/5/5
David Hart Smith - 6/2/6
David Otunga - 8/8/2
Evan Bourne - 4/3/8
Ezekiel Jackson - 9/6/7
Goldust - 8/10/8
The Great Khali - 8/5/2
Heath Slater - 5/6/7
Husky Harris - 8/6/6
Jey Uso - 6/7/6
Jimmy Uso - 6/6/6
John Cena - 9/10/9
John Morrison - 9/5/9
Justin Gabriel - 8/6/9
Mark Henry - 7/6/5
Michael McGillicutty - 8/2/7
Michael Tarver - 8/9/6
The Miz - 7/9/5
Primo - 7/6/8
R-Truth - 7/5/7
Randy Orton - 10/6/7
Santino Marella - 7/10/8
Sheamus - 8/9/9
Skip Sheffield - 9/6/6
Ted DiBiase - 7/6/8
Triple H - 10/10/9
Tyson Kidd - 6/4/9
Vladmir Kozlov - 5/1/8
Wade Barrett - 10/10/5
William Regal - 7/10/10
Yoshi Tatsu - 6/2/8
Zach Ryder - 9/8/7

Divas

Alicia Fox - 7/7/5
Brie Bella - 8/3/6
Eve Torres - 10/7/7
Gail Kim - 7/4/7
Jilian Hall - 7/6/5
Maryse - 10/10/5
Melina - 8/7/9
Natalya - 7/6/10
Nikki Bella - 8/5/7
Tamina - 6/6/6
 

·
Bowing down to the BEAST INCARNATE
Joined
·
4,564 Posts
RAW

Alex Riley - 8/8/7
CM Punk - 9/10/9
Daniel Bryan - 7.5/8/10
Darren Young - 7.5/6/7
David Hart Smith - 7/5/7.5
David Otunga - 8/7/5
Evan Bourne - 8/7/10
Ezekiel Jackson - 8/5/6
Goldust - 10/9/10
The Great Khali - 1/0/0
Heath Slater - 5/5/7
Husky Harris - 7.5/7.5/7.5
Jey Uso - 7.5/5/7.5
Jimmy Uso - 7.5/5/7.5
John Cena - 8/7/5
John Morrison - 9/7.5/8
Justin Gabriel - 8.5/7/8
Mark Henry - 8/7/7
Michael McGillicutty - 0/0/0
Michael Tarver - 6/6/5
The Miz - 8/8.5/8
Primo - 7.5/5/8
R-Truth - 8/6/7
Randy Orton - 9/8.5/9
Santino Marella - 8/9/6
Sheamus - 8/7/8.5
Skip Sheffield - 8/6/7
Ted DiBiase - 7.5/7/8
Triple H - 9/9/9
Tyson Kidd - 7.5/6/8
Vladmir Kozlov - 7/5/5
Wade Barrett - 8/7.5/7
William Regal - 8/8/8
Yoshi Tatsu - 7.5/4/8
Zach Ryder - 8/7.5/8

Divas

Alicia Fox - 7/5/6
Brie Bella - 8/7/7
Eve Torres - 7/5/6
Gail Kim - 8/7/9
Jilian Hall - 7/7/5
Maryse - 10/9/7
Melina - 8/8/7
Natalya - 8/7/9
Nikki Bella - 8/7/7
Tamina - 7/5/6
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
10,171 Posts
CM Punk - 8/10/10
Daniel Bryan - 3/8/10
Darren Young - 4/4/6
David Hart Smith - 6/2/6
David Otunga - 8/2/1
Evan Bourne - 5/3/8
Ezekiel Jackson - 9/4/6
Goldust - 7/9/8
The Great Khali - 10/2/1
Heath Slater - 3/4/7
Husky Harris - 4/6/6
Jey Uso - 6/6/6
Jimmy Uso - 6/6/6
John Cena - 9/10/8
John Morrison - 9/4/8
Justin Gabriel - 8/6/8
Mark Henry - 6/6/5
Michael McGillicutty - 9/2/8
Michael Tarver - 8/9/5
The Miz - 7/10/4
Primo - 6/6/7
R-Truth - 6/5/5
Randy Orton - 9/6/8
Santino Marella - 7/10/7
Sheamus - 8/8/8
Skip Sheffield - 8/3/6
Ted DiBiase - 9/4/9
Triple H - 10/10/9
Tyson Kidd - 6/3/8
Vladmir Kozlov - 5/2/6
Wade Barrett - 9/10/5
William Regal - 7/10/10
Yoshi Tatsu - 4/2/8
Zach Ryder - 3/8/7

Divas

Alicia Fox - 5/2/4
Brie Bella - 6/4/5
Eve Torres - 8/6/5
Gail Kim - 7/4/7
Jilian Hall - 5/4/7
Maryse - 10/8/5
Melina - 8/7/7
Natalya - 9/5/10
Nikki Bella - 6/5/5
Tamina - 7/3/7

I don't know my Jimmy from my Jey.
 

·
Few adventures require staying home
Joined
·
7,725 Posts
RAW

Alex Riley - 9/10/8
CM Punk - 9/10/9
Daniel Bryan - 7/7/10
Darren Young - 8/4/7
David Hart Smith - 6/3/7
David Otunga - 5/7/2
Evan Bourne - 6/3/9
Ezekiel Jackson - 8/5/7
Goldust - 9/10/9
The Great Khali - 7/1/2
Heath Slater - 3/3/7
Husky Harris - 1/3/4
Jey Uso - 3/3/6
Jimmy Uso - 3/3/6
John Cena - 9/10/9
John Morrison - 8/5/9
Justin Gabriel - 7/5/9
Mark Heny - 6/5/5
Michael McGillicutty - 1/1/3
Michael Tarver - 4/9/4
The Miz - 9/10/8
Primo - 5/5/7
R-Truth - 6/9/7
Randy Orton - 8/8/8
Santino Marella - 8/9/3
Sheamus - 9/9/9
Skip Sheffield - 6/4/5
Ted DiBiase - 5/2/5
Triple H - 9/10/9
Tyson Kidd - 6/3/9
Vladmir Kozlov - 7/3/7
Wade Barrett - 8/10/8
William Regal - 6/9/9
Yoshi Tatsu - 5/1/7
Zach Ryder - 8/10/7

Divas

Alicia Fox - 7/8/9
Brie Bella - 9/8/8
Eve Torres - 8/6/8
Gail Kim - 8/5/9
Jilian Hall - 7/7/10
Maryse - 10/5/4
Melina - 8/4/8
Natalya - 9/9/9
Nikki Bella - 9/9/8
Tamina - 5/4/6
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
151 Posts
RAW

Alex Riley - 8/8/7
CM Punk - 8/10/10
Daniel Bryan - 6/6/10
Darren Young - 6/6/4
David Hart Smith - 8/6/8
David Otunga - 8/6/4
Evan Bourne - 6/6/8
Ezekiel Jackson - 9/2/6
Goldust - 7/8/7
The Great Khali - 7/1/3
Heath Slater - 7/6/7
Husky Harris - 6/6/6
Jey Uso - 6/6/7
Jimmy Uso - 6/6/7
John Cena - 8/10/8
John Morrison - 8/8/8
Justin Gabriel - 8/6/8
Mark Henry - 7/5/5
Michael McGillicutty - 8/5/7
Michael Tarver - 9/8/7
The Miz - 8/10/9
Primo - 6/6/7
R-Truth - 7/7/7
Randy Orton - 10/10/10
Santino Marella - 6/8/7
Sheamus - 10/10/9
Skip Sheffield - 10/4/7
Ted DiBiase - 8/7/7
Triple H - 10/9/8
Tyson Kidd - 7/6/8
Vladmir Kozlov - 8/4/7
Wade Barrett - 9/9/7
William Regal - 7/8/7
Yoshi Tatsu - 6/5/7
Zach Ryder - 7/6/6
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,506 Posts
I'm just going to do overall ratings, with a small review. I haven't done this before, but I figured it would be better to explain my reasonings for some of the ratings.

Alex Riley (6) - He can talk and plays his character well, but he doesn't seem that solid in the ring.
CM Punk (10) - He's excellent on the mic and in the ring. He's also a good role model for children.
Daniel Bryan (10) - Again, excellent in the ring. The emotion he brings to the table is unmatched. Easily one of the best.
Darren Young (5) - He had a unique look before he cut his hair. He is pretty average in the ring and on the mic.
David Hart Smith (9) - Distant throwback to tag team wrestling, he can wrestle VERY good, and has "the look"
David Otunga (5) - 5 is probably a bit generous but he can carry himself on the mic and as a character. He also has a good physique.
Evan Bourne (10) - 10 for me, easily. He is extremely exciting to watch, and has a cool look. His mic skills can be passed, just look at Rey Mysterio.
Ezekiel Jackson (6) - I gave him a 6 because I think he's one of the best "power wrestlers" in a while. He also has an impressive look and I could see him doing well.
Goldust (8) - He is a legend and one of the best characters of all-time. Can also have a good match with almost anybody.
The Great Khali (4) - I give him a 4 because he has the presence. He doesn't have to move around much in the ring for people to notice him.
Heath Slater (7) - I give him a 7 because of his experience in the ring. He looks like he knows what he's doing.
Husky Harris (7) - I enjoy watching him wrestle, I think he has a unique look nowadays and it reminds me of Terry Gordy and Dusty Rhodes.
The Usos (6) - I haven't seen much of them, so they both get a 6 out of me. I liked how most of their moveset was a tribute to Umaga.
John Cena (8) - I don't enjoy watching him at all, but he gets an 8 based on his presence, his workrate and his ability to sell a match.
John Morrison (9) - He has a unique look and offense. But he seems nervous on the mic in front of a live crowd, and for that I can't give him a 10.
Justin Gabriel (9) - Like John Morrison, he has a unique look and is really fun to watch.
Mark Henry (4) - I'm just shocked that he's been employed this long. He can't wrestle in the ring or talk on the mic. And there's just nothing appealing about him.
Michael McGillicutty (7) - He's REALLY awkward on the mic but he seems like a natural in the ring. He also has the look and I can see him becoming pretty big in the future.
Michael Tarver (8) - He has the presence, the look and the mic skills. His ring skills can easily be passed.
The Miz (9) - He fits the WWE's main event mould perfectly. Classic heel.
Primo (7) - He's never really been given a chance, so I can't rate him any higher. From what I've seen, he's pretty fun to watch.
R-Truth (8) - I like watching him, he has a unique offense and is pretty popular with the crowd.
Randy Orton (7) - I don't know if it's his current character, but he is really slow in the ring and just isn't exciting to watch. I give him a 7 because of his look, popularity and presence.
Santino Marella (6) - Santino was at his best in late 2007. Now his jokes are incredibly childish and usually follow the same pattern every week. He's getting really stale.
Sheamus (10) - WWE's best main eventer. He has a unique look, can wrestle really well and is fun on the mic. He also seems like a really hard worker.
Skip Sheffield (8) - 8 because of his presence, and look. Both him and Tarver were the highlights of the Nexus attacks.
Ted DiBiase (7) - I do like him but I don't think he's GREAT in the ring. I think he's passable at best.
Triple H (10) - Too many classic matches for me to give anything less. One of the all-time best.
Tyson Kidd (9) - He can mat wrestle, and also do highflying spots, so he gets a 9. I think him and Smith are better off as a tag team right now though.
Vladmir Kozlov (6) - Like Jackson, he is pretty fun to watch in the ring at times. But I think he peaked in 2008.
Wade Barrett (9) - While he can work the mic really well, I don't think he's overly impressive in the ring. He is a great character though.
William Regal (8) - He is best as a comedy character, which is why I think he should be a face. I think he peaked as a heel during the KOTR/GM storyline.
Yoshi Tatsu (8) - I wish he was given a better opportunity. He was extremely fun to watch in ECW and was connecting with the crowd. Hopefully they move him to Smackdown shortly.
Zack Ryder (7) - Because of his gimmick, WWE aren't ever taking him seriously. He can definitely wrestle in the ring and that was showed during ECW.
Alicia Fox (6) - She has put on some good matches in the pass, so she gets a 6 from me. I still don't think she should have become Divas Champion though.
The Bellas (4) - If it wasn't for the guest hosts, I really don't think they would be hired this long. They can't wrestle very good and they just can't connect with the crowd.
Eve Torres (5) - I don't think she can wrestle, talk OR dance. She can't connect with the crowd and was pretty much only pushed because of her looks. 5 because of her ring improvement.
Gail Kim (10) - Look at her TNA stuff and you'll see why she's one of the best female wrestlers in the world. WWE haven't given her the opportunity.
Jilian Hall (6) - I thought her gimmick was getting REALLY stale, but she seems like a good trainer for the divas.
Maryse (3) - Like Eve, she got pushed because of her looks. She can't wrestle or talk on the mic, besides a few whistles from the crowd, she isn't over.
Melina (9) - She has the ring skills, the mic skills, and the crowd love her, so she gets a 9 from me.
Natalya (10) - Best female wrestler in the world. She can wrestle, talk and has the look. She has been really getting over with the crowd lately too.
Tamina (6) - Like the Usos, I haven't seen much of her, so I can't really rate. From what I've seen, she looks comfortable in the ring, so she gets a 6.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
115 Posts
Alex Riley - 6/8/5
CM Punk - 6/10/9
Daniel Bryan - 4/6/10
David Otunga - 7/5/4
Evan Bourne - 5/4/8
The Great Khali - 10/2/2
John Cena - 9/9/5
John Morrison - 8/3/9
Justin Gabriel - 6/4/7
The Miz - 6/9/6
R-Truth - 7/4/7
Randy Orton - 9/5/6
Sheamus - 9/8/8
Skip Sheffield - 8/5/5
Ted DiBiase - 7/4/6
Triple H - 9/8/6(would have been higher a few years ago)
Tyson Kidd - 3/4/8
Vladmir Kozlov - 8/4/4
Wade Barrett - 9/8/6
William Regal - 5/6/8

left a few out..

Although I don't think its as simple as adding all 3 together because looks and mic skills are far more important than actual wrestling talent when it comes being sucessful.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
8,283 Posts
Alex Riley - 9/7/5 He has the looks, he's good on the mic but not great like some people were saying.
CM Punk - 9/10/9 Punk is as close to perfection as your gonna get.
Daniel Bryan - 6/8/10 His look is not good but it fits him.
Darren Young - 2/4/7 His wrestling ability is alright, he's a joke in every other way.
David Hart Smith - 4/3/7 He's big and solid in the ring. The next Chris Masters minus steroids.
David Otunga - 7/2/2 All he has is looks.
Evan Bourne - 8/2/8 He is what he is.
Ezekiel Jackson - 9/5/7 Big bad looking dude, can work well with just about anybody, not bad on the mic.
Goldust - 9/8/7 Goldust was great but now he's limited for what he could do so he's hard to rate.
The Great Khali - 8/1/1 He's tall, he wins, the casuals think he's some monster. That's all there is.
Heath Slater - 1/2/5 He's releasable material. Where is ROH and disruntled TNA workers when we need them?
Husky Harris - 1/6/2 Again like Heath Slater. Wrestling needs some fat men but he has a long ways to go.
Jey Uso - 3/3/7 I think their pretty talented in the ring.
Jimmy Uso - 3/3/7 ^^^
John Cena - 10/10/6
John Morrison - 7/4/9 I think he's a little too small and a pretty boy. Plus he can't get over on the mic.
Justin Gabriel - 6/2/7 He's far from perfect but keep him around.
Mark Henry - 6/6/2 Go away already.
Michael McGillicutty - 3/1/2 Annoying horrid on the mic. Nothing to talk about in the ring. Generic.
Michael Tarver - 6/9/2 He needs tremendous improvement in the ring. I wished WWE would let him go to Japan.
The Miz - 9/9/5
Primo - 6/4/6
R-Truth - 8/8/6
Randy Orton - 9/7/5
Santino Marella - 4/8/3 Seriously go away.
Sheamus - 7/7/6
Skip Sheffield - 8/7/5 I actually like this guy.
Ted DiBiase - 8/4/5 He tries on the mic more and more but he still sucks. Ring work is below average for WWE.
Triple H - 10/10/6
Tyson Kidd - 6/2/9 I don't mind his look and he's a phenomenal worker.
Vladmir Kozlov - 7/3/3 He's alright but he needs time to improve and he's been in for what 3 years now.
Wade Barrett - 8/9/4 A lot of improvement in the ring to go. This main event push is doing wonders for him.
William Regal - 2/9/9
Yoshi Tatsu - 2/1/6
Zack Ryder - 8/8/5
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
730 Posts
I think this list is the best list you can find anywhere and I cannot find ANY faults with it


RAW

Alex Riley - 7/7/7
CM Punk - 7/10/9
Daniel Bryan - 6/8/9
Darren Young - 6/4/6
David Hart Smith - 6/3/6
David Otunga - 7/6/2
Evan Bourne - 4/5/7
Ezekiel Jackson - 8/6/6
Goldust - 8/8/8
The Great Khali - 9/2/1
Heath Slater - 5/6/6
Husky Harris - 3/6/7
Jey Uso - 5/5/6
Jimmy Uso - 5/5/6
John Cena - 10/9/7
John Morrison - 8/3/7
Justin Gabriel - 8/6/6
Mark Heny - 8/3/4
Michael McGillicutty - 6/4/6
Michael Tarver - 7/7/5
The Miz - 7/9/4
Primo - 5/3/6
R-Truth - 5/6/6
Randy Orton - 10/6/8
Santino Marella - 6/7/7
Sheamus - 10/7/7
Skip Sheffield - 9/5/6
Ted DiBiase - 6/3/6
Triple H - 10/7/8
Tyson Kidd - 5/4/8
Vladmir Kozlov - 6/3/6
Wade Barrett - 9.5/9/6
William Regal - 6/7/8
Yoshi Tatsu - 6/3/7
Zach Ryder - 7/7/7 (Underrated)

Divas

Alicia Fox - No/One/Cares
Brie Bella - Fuck/These/Two
Eve Torres - Horrible/Horrible/Dancer
Gail Kim - Go/Back/ToTNA
Jilian Hall - Never/Sing/Again
Maryse - Appear/Don't/Wrestle
Melina - What/Happened/Here?
Natalya - Only/Decent/Diva
Nikki Bella - Fuck/These/Two
Tamina - Where'd/She/Go
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,833 Posts
Alex Riley -7/6/?
CM Punk -8/10/10
Daniel Bryan -8/7/10
Darren Young -6/?/?
David Hart Smith -6/?/6
David Otunga -7/4/5
Evan Bourne -8/6/8
Ezekiel Jackson -8/?/5
Goldust -8/8/8
The Great Khali -6/1/1
Heath Slater -5/?/5
Husky Harris -4/?/4
Jey Uso -8/7/7
Jimmy Uso -8/7/7
John Cena -9/8/7
John Morrison -9/6/8
Justin Gabriel -7/?/7
Mark Heny -7/6/3
Michael McGillicutty -4/4/?
Michael Tarver -7/6/6
The Miz -7/8/5
Primo -7/?/7
R-Truth -7/6/6
Randy Orton -8/7/7
Santino Marella -7/10/6
Sheamus -7/8/7
Skip Sheffield -8/?/5
Ted DiBiase -7/6/6
Triple H -9/9/8
Tyson Kidd -8/?/8
Vladmir Kozlov -8/2/5
Wade Barrett -9/9/7
William Regal -8/9/10
Yoshi Tatsu -7/?/7
Zach Ryder -8/7/7

Divas

Alicia Fox -7/5/6
Brie Bella -5/?/5
Eve Torres -7/6/6
Gail Kim -8/?/8
Jilian Hall -6/7/6
Maryse -7/7/5
Melina -8/7/8
Natalya -8/7/8
Nikki Bella -5/?/5
Tamina -8/6/7
 
1 - 20 of 114 Posts
Top