Sure, I can rate it.
I'll use an easy +/- rating.
- simple background swirl.
- bad choice of color(I'm not a fan of yellows)
- text is too simple. needs a different font type, and some effects like glow or stroke or motion blur, etc.
+ you spelled your name correctly
^sorry man who cares what you think about my swirly, it is my first one, your mean, yellow actually kinda cool. What is you favorite color and I will try to change it. Then maby you will like it. Except my challange. You will likely win, but what ever.
I'm mean? Dude, I was just stating the flaws in the graphic and being honest. Sorry, was I supposed to sugarcoat it for you?
And just changing the color isn't gonna change my decision of not liking it much. But anyway, I like blues, purples, greens, stuff like that.
You think he is mean? What about all the shit you have been posting over the last hour, bagging everyone's work. Not one of your posts have been constructive in any way shape or form. For starters, how about posting in English, or using a spell checker. Like Kaneanite said, at least you spelled your name correctly.
I'm hopeless with Photoshop, I'll admit that, but what you've done, I reckon I could do in about 10 minutes. And to think, you've been bagging everyone else's work and you create stuff like that.