Wrestling Forum banner

Vote for the best card in EACH matchup

  • The Ratman

    Votes: 11 35.5%
  • HollywoodNightmare

    Votes: 23 74.2%
  • AwSmash

    Votes: 15 48.4%
  • AlienBountyHunter

    Votes: 19 61.3%
1 - 20 of 40 Posts

736 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Instructions: For each match, choose the best card. Simple as that. This'll be open for two days.

MATCH ONE: HollywoodNightmare vs. The Ratman

HollywoodNightmare's Card
Nightmare Mania III:

The Rock vs Shawn Michaels

Two of the biggest stars in wrestling HISTORY who have never faced each other will meet in the main event of Nightmare Mania III! In one corner you have a corner stone of the attitude era, The Rock. In the other corner, you have one the guys responsible for the attitude era being born Shawn Michaels. Combined the two have 15 world championships between them. Add in the X Factor here which is the 15 foot high, cold and unforgiving Steel Cage and you have the makings of an epic match. Who will win when these two icons face off for the first time ever?

WWF Championship Match:
Dean Ambrose vs Hulk Hogan (c)

Ambrose has always claimed he wanted to prove he was the best and now he has his chance. He'll be stepping into the ring with the biggest name in professional wrestling history, Hulk Hogan with the WWF Title on the line. Both have won matches at both Nightmare Mania I and Nightmare Mania II and now only one can walk out of this epic battle with the WWF Championship around his waist. Who will it be?

Old School Meets New School: Intercontinental Championship Ladder Match
Dusty Rhodes vs Edge

Edge is a multiple time IC Champion and Dusty Rhodes is one of the biggest legends to never win the title. Now these two clash over the vacant IC Title in a historic Ladder Match. The match type does favor Edge, who is the master of the Ladder Match but Dusty Rhodes is far from out of his element when weapons get involved. Can Edge and his devious ways earn him the IC Title or will Dusty Rhodes become an IC Champion for the first time in his legendary career?

World Tag Team Title Match:
SGT. Slaughter & Lex Luger vs Demolition (c)

Demolition have proved the last 2 shows why they are one of the greatest teams of all-time by knocking off The Nasty Boys and The Hooliganz. Now they face a whole new kind of challenge when they take on the america loving team of SGT. Slaughter and Lex Luger with Demolition's Tag Titles on the line. Will Demolition continue to dominate on their mission to prove they are the greatest team of all-time or will Slaughter and Luger be able to use their bond over their love for America to propel this team to victory?

X Division Championship:
Christopher Daniels vs Alex Shelley vs Low Ki (c)

Daniels and Low Ki have gone to war and fought together in war many times. They know each other very well which makes Alex Shelley somewhat of a wild card here. Now these three will do battle over Low Ki's newly won X Division Championship and only one will be able to walk out as champion. All three have been champion before but the question is, which one will prove to be the best X Division Champion ever when they lock horns in what should be an amazing triple threat match?

Loser Leaves The USA Forever:
Jack Swagger vs Jushin "Thunder" Liger

Jack Swagger's problems with Liger began when he suddenly decided that anybody hailing from a foreign land needed to be taken out and his target? One of the greatest high flyers of all-time, Jushin Liger. Liger accepted the challenge to a match at Nightmare Mania III but after that, the stakes were raised because Swagger said that the loser of the match would have to leave the United States of America...FOREVER! Will Jack Swagger prove himself to be a "Real American" or will Liger prove to be too much for Swagger to handle?

One Final Match Between The Two:
Paul London vs The Brian Kendrick

These two former friends turned enemies will clash in the opening contest of Nightmare Mania III as once again Brian Kendrick turned his back on Paul London but London has had enough of it. He issued the challenge to Kendrick for one final battle between the two to decide who the better man really is. Now we will find out who the weak link of this once great team really is when these two clash one last time.

The Ratman's Card
The Ratman presents

For the first time ever in pro wrestling history, two of greatest wrestlers of all time will have a one on one match. I should say, two of the greatest "Canadian" wrestlers of all time will fight. That's right, it will be Bret "The Hitman" Hart going against Y2J, Chris Jericho. This match couldn't be decided by one fall so it will be a 60 Minute Iron Man match. This match will show who is the best Canadian wrestler of all time.

One of the biggest and successful WWE Superstars in their young career on the roster right now is new comer, Bobby Roode. He has already defeated the greats of Randy Orton and Scott Hall. He has proved himself that he is WWE Championship material. Well we'll see if he is or not when he steps in the ring against WWE Champion, CM Punk. Can the longest reigning TNA World Champion of all time defeat the current and longest reigning WWE Champion in 25 years?

Also in the card will be the two of the greatest Intercontinental Champions of all time, Randy Savage and Razor Ramon will compete for the vacant championship in a ladder match. Also Curtis Axel and his grandfather Larry "The Ax" Hennig will go against Zack Ryder and Curt Hawkins hoping to become the first ever grandson and grandfather tag team champions.

Bret Hart vs. Chris Jericho

CM Punk (c) vs. Bobby Roode w/ Vince McMahon

"Macho Man" Randy Savage vs. Razor Ramon

Randy Orton vs. Umaga

Maryse (c) vs. Kelly Kelly

Primo vs. Epico vs. Carlito

Rosey vs. The Hurricane

Zack Ryder and Curt Hawkins vs. Curtis Axel and Larry "The Ax" Hennig

Kofi Kingston and Elijah Burke vs. Nation of Domination


MATCH TWO: AwSmash vs. AlienBountyHunter

AwSmash's Card

WWF Championship - 3 Stages of Hell (Singles, Hardcore, Ladder)
Triple H vs. Kurt Angle

No DQ Match
Steve Austin vs. Ultimate Warrior

Intercontinental Championship
Mr. Perfect vs. Ricky Steamboat

Women's Championship
Trish Stratus vs. Mickie James

World Tag Team Championship - Ladder Match
The Hardy Boyz vs. The Dudley Boyz vs. Rob Van Dam & Jamie Noble

Cruiserweight Championship
Rey Mysterio vs. X-Pac

United States Championship
Damien Sandow vs. Chavo Guerrero

AlienBountyHunter's Card
World Heavyweight Championship
Ric Flair vs Kenta Kobashi

These two legends of wrestling have never faced each other before but now the time has come. The World Title is on the line in a super-mega-dream match.

Chris Benoit vs Goldberg
Two big clashes of styles. Benoit, the technical master. Goldberg, the vicious powerhouse. In what should be a fascinating match, who will cope with the other’s offense and come out on top?

Steel Cage Match
William Regal vs Nick Bockwinkel
Two men who simply love to cause pain will meet for the first time. Neither man cares about being loved or winning a title, they simply want to beat the hell out of the other. This won’t be pretty.

Intercontinental Championship
Dean Malenko vs Rick Rude

These two couldn't be less alike, but they both have one thing in common - they both thrive to be the intercontinental champion. Will Rude's showmanship and over exuberance allow Malenko to topple the 'Ravishing' one? Or will Malenko's frosty demeanor and very intense psyche allow Rude to walk out as the champ?

Cruiserweight Championship
Billy Kidman vs Cody Rhodes

Rhodes snuck below the weight limit to get a chance at the cruiserweight title. Kidman contents that Rhodes will never be a 'true cruiserweight' and vows to stop him from ever becoming champion.

9-man Elimination Tables Match
The Wyatt Family (Bray Wyatt, Erick Rowan, Luke Harper) vs Heyman's Henchmen (Sabu, Taz, Rhyno) vs The Mexicools (Super Crazy, Psicosis, Juventud Guerrera)

We kick off the night in what's sure to be an absolute carwreck - a nine man tables match. A minimum of six men will be going through a table in this one, so sit back and just enjoy the carnage.​

Stay Fearless
7,384 Posts
Its only 4 votes but it still worries me. Great cards guys.

Locker Room Leader
12,168 Posts
Voted for HN and ABH. Kobashi vs Flair- Chop battle of the millennium :D

Stay Fearless
7,384 Posts
Didn't expect a blow out tbh. Does my card really suck that bad?

Stay Fearless
7,384 Posts
I don't think it sucks at all tbh. Perhaps it's his undercard that's beating your's. I think if you we're against anyone, but HN, it'd be much closer.

We had 40 votes last round, so I wouldn't say he's won yet. Remember Chan's comeback?
Yeah that's true. Hype had quite the comeback on me too.

Exploring Planet Alpha
396 Posts
Didn't expect a blow out tbh. Does my card really suck that bad?
Nah your card is good man but I think me being able to set up a dream match of HBK vs Rock in round 3 is pretty huge.

I expect you'll make a comeback on me sometime today. Anybody from the 4 can win this thing tbh.

Stay Fearless
7,384 Posts
I think we should done separate threads for this tbh. There has been more than one person that aren't voting correctly and they voted for both people.

30,350 Posts
Im surprised Ratman is quite behind here...although Hollywood i think from the History Drafts brought more of his "A" game in this one with a very tough roster/matchup to beat in fairness.

As for Awsmash vs. ABH..wow..can't get much closer than this!!!

Still the GOAT
4,787 Posts
Saving my vote for later today, although at this point I have a pretty good idea as to who I'm going with.

Honestly, I'm actually disappointed by the cards in this round, but there's one of them that I really, REALLY fucking like and it's probably not the one that everybody expects it to be. I think that alot of opportunities for creative matchups were thrown out the window with conventional thinking and not thinking outside of the box enough. There's one of you though that I think used his ENTIRE roster better than anybody else.
1 - 20 of 40 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.