The GIF kinda gives me the "trying to hard" feel. Though I guess the text fits WWE's NYR text, I don't like it. The blending on HBK makes him look like he has some rare skin disease. The blending on everyone else is inconsistent. Jericho is blurry. I like the background (Premade?).
Overall, I guess it isn't terrible. But, try to improve the things I said.