The fact that the only one you put in that actually runs all the time is Afterlife, then that, but half those shows have barely begun.
You should have added RoG, New WWE, NGW and a few others.
Half those I've never heard of. So, I'm sorry, but the most popular is obviously Rise of Glory in terms of both number of replies and views.
No offence but this is a pointless thread. Maybe if you had of looked around first and wrote a few down to add then it would have actually meant something, but it doesnt. Oh well, one vote for Afterlife (the only long running thread mentioned)