[Dalexian]

Natalya and Beth show no personality, though =[

 

[Kiz]

lol michelle mccool.

 

[perro]

Good

She Deserves it

Shes been [Love her or hat her] the best Female wrestler all year

 

[Cynic]

Isn't PWI a kayfabe sheet anyway? I can never tell with them.

It makes sense in kayfabe terms. Even though she's terrible and the fact she's constantly made to outshine Layla is just insulting.

 

[SilverX]

Natalya and Beth show no personality, though =[

+1000

 

[WCWnWo4Life]

Natalya and Beth show no personality, though =[

In-ring ability has made up for that (to me anyways). They're both improving there. I mean I'm sorry but McCool has done nothing but annoy and bore me all year. Biggest reason she gets the push is for being Taker's slampiece. She uses a finisher that's made better by a man with 100x the accolades she will ever gain (thank God I haven't seen her use it for months). She needs more time in the ring to improve and a better angle, one that doesn't make her so damn annoying.

 

[TripleG]

I liken this to when Triple H won PWI Superstar of the Decade. The only reasons I can come up with for that decision are purely kayfabe. Storyline wise, he had just been in that top spot for most of the decade and that was the only justification I could come up with because his body of work (especially when compared to the likes of Shawn, Taker, Edge, Angle, Jericho, Styles, Mysterio, & even the often criticized Cena) didn't measure up at all.

Same thing here. Are there better workers in Women's Wrestling in this day and age. Oh let me count the ways! Gail, Natalya, Phoenix, Mickie, Tara/Victoria, Melina, etc. There are plenty of girls who are just better, but because Women's Wrestling is more of side show, they don't always get to show it. So the top girl is going to be the one that gets the gold, and Michelle is always thrust to the top of the diva's division, so she gets the most attention, therefore, she gets the most recognition.

 

[scrilla]

McCool is one of the top 5 female workers in the WWE and easily one of the most entertaining. Probably the best on the mic tbh. **** only hate her because she married Taker just like they hate Trips for marrying Steph. Get over it bros.

 

[perro]

Same thing here. Are there better workers in Women's Wrestling in this day and age. Oh let me count the ways! Gail, Natalya, Phoenix, Mickie, Tara/Victoria, Melina, etc. There are plenty of girls who are just better, but because Women's Wrestling is more of side show, they don't always get to show it. So the top girl is going to be the one that gets the gold, and Michelle is always thrust to the top of the diva's division, so she gets the most attention, therefore, she gets the most recognition.

This is just for the past year

Michell has been better then all of them this past year

 

[bme]

:lmao Still can't believe people take these awards seriously.

The award is kayfabe, she's the most dominate diva in wrestling right now.

 

[KiNgoFKiNgS23]

her and layla are one of the few things entertaining about mainstream women wrestling(besides beth and kong) so i dont see why this should upset anyone.

 

[Troll™]

PWI is kayfabe, so nothing wrong with it.

 

[MOBELS]

She deserved it from last year because she did the best work of last year from a kayfabe point of view

 

[Prospekt's March]

I love McCool, she's a complete package imo, her Laycool run has been one of few bright spots in divas division over these past two years, she might not be in same level with Natalya in terms of wrestling skill but she's still very solid and can work a good match with anyone. She deserves this award.

 

[CainTheUndertaker]

I say it's quite well deserved. She has the looks, the mic skills and more importantly better in-ring ability than most of the other divas, which makes her probably the most complete diva on the roster. I can understand why people think her push is only because she is Mrs. Taker, but I'm inclined to believe what John Piermarini said in that she has worked her way to the top.

 

[TKOK]

I have no problem with this award being given to her. Laycool's about the only entertaining thing in womens wrestling.

 

[perro]

Whats more upsetting is who won Rookie of the year....

 

[Renegade™]

Isn't PWI a kayfabe sheet anyway? I can never tell with them.

It makes sense in kayfabe terms. Even though she's terrible and the fact she's constantly made to outshine Layla is just insulting.

This.

Fuck McCool.

 

[TelkEvolon]

Del Ray!