I'm not a huge fan of the show so far. All of the stuff with BJ/Bubba and various people not getting along is obviously a work. The matches are definitely clipped, not in front of real crowds and not really shot like normal matches, so it's hard to get too invested. It also makes it somewhat pointless to try and gage where these people are at because we aren't seeing the whole thing. The coach competition thing isn't really working either. I'm sure it'll be fine if the shows ever get to just airing matches like 205 Live/Level Up did and it becomes a normal wrestling show, but I don't know if that'll happen.
Someone in WWE really likes Anthony Luke. He's really being pushed hard on the show. It's hard for me to tell where he's at though because we haven't seen live unedited matches. I think Penina has a lot of potential but her look is going to limit her to being a monster heel type. Zena will be a likeable face but we haven't seen much of her in the ring and what we did see didn't look good. Dani seems like she will be fine as she's good looking and athletic. Chris Island can move pretty well due to being an amateur wrestler and should be okay. Troy Yearwood really reminds me of Byron Saxton. We've already seen Jasper Troy, who is already fine as is Shiloh Hill and Cutler James, I'm not really high on as he's very generic.