[Contrarian]

Is he? Where would you place both these guys in your all time list? Top 30-40?

 

[CokaCoola]

Jericho would be in the top 40 probably but Edge would struggle to make it into my top 50 list, frankly. I'd say why but I'm sure another poster will come up with something.

 

[Hazaq]

No, Jericho will always be the Bigger star/Legend in wrestling history.

 

[Kr0wbar]

No, I personally don't have them that far apart though.

 

[Warren Zevon]

I don't keep a list or anything, but I don't think either would be in the top 50. Jericho maybe, but Edge was always more notable to me as a tag team competitor.

 

[John_Sheena22]

No. Jericho is above Edge

 

[Scrotey Loads]

I don't hate Edge, and I realize this will come off as more dickish than I want it to sound, but the idea of Edge being higher on the list of greats than Jericho is absurd to me. Jericho was a top guy when WWE's star power was still off the charts. Edge only got his break when the roster was thin. Edge would never have been WHC/WWE championship material when Rock, Austin, Triple H, etc. were still at the peak of their careers.

 

[Bushmaster]

Jericho is above Edge. Edge could have a bazillion world title reigns but he wouldnt be above Jericho.

 

[777]

Fuck no. Strictly personal preference but Jericho is in my top five all-time, while Edge doesn't even rank.

 

[John_Sheena22]

Also I think another important factor is that Jericho was Undisputed Champion during the Attitude Era.
Edge wasn't a main eventer during Attitude Era.
And what Scrotey Loads says is true, Edge wouldn't have been World champion if Rock, Stone Codl and Triple H were still around.

 

[HMecabo]

Hell no. I don't actually place them that far apart, but if you consider them individually, Jericho is A LOT greater. Edge got initial heat from being a Tag Team Wrestler. Jericho didn't need it. He grew his own persona and made it big when there was a lot of competition in the wrestling industry.

 

[3030]

I'd say no, but they're both definitely all-time greats, so it's not like it really matters who's a notch above who.

 

[Mojo Stark]

Edge and Jericho are in my personal Top 3. Love Edge to death but Jericho will always be better.

 

[Rockstar]

I'd personally put Edge above Jericho but Edge is my favourite of all time, so yeah. I just enjoyed Edge's character more over the years than I did Jericho's. Although Jericho is one of my favourites as well.

 

[TheVladMan]

No, I've always preferred Jericho over him. He's in my top-5 of all time, whereas Edge would be ranked somewhere in my top-20.

 

[2K JAY]

Yes. Edge makes my top 10 of all time. Jericho would be in my top 15.

 

[jonoaries]

Jericho > Edge

 

[Headliner]

Created my own option for voting.

 

[Hazaq]

^ And thats a bad move. The "hell no" & "No" option is going to end up splitting the votes and inturn "Yes" option is going to seem as the winning opinion.

 

[Here To There]

My objective list of the greatest:

1. Hulk Hogan
2. 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin
3. 'Nature Boy' Ric Flair
4. Bret 'the Hitman' Hart
5. 'Macho Man' Randy Savage
6. The Undertaker
7. Shawn Michaels
8. Chris Benoit
9. The Rock
10. Kurt Angle
11. Chris Jericho
12. Triple H
13. Bruno Sammartino
14. Harley Race
15. Sting
16. Eddie Guerrero
17. 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper
18. Ricky 'the Dragon' Steamboat
19. **** Foley
20. Bob Backlund
21. Andre the Giant
22. John Cena
23. Ted DiBiase
24. Jake 'the Snake'Roberts
25. Edge