Yet TNA does its best ratings when AJ isnt champ.
Peole you need to remember ALL that matters to TNA is ratings and how their inept creative team interprets them.
This is where the problem lies because we all know that Eric Bischoff is all about ratings as he showed in WCW when even whilst beating WWE in the ratings he would still try and make WWE look stupid and would talk constantly about the ratings. Throw in Vince Russo who believes that shock value and stables equal ratings on top of Hulk "i believe i am HUGE ratings" Hogan and you see that as long as TNA can get better ratings that they did before then everything is ok.
The reality is though that regardless of the ratings TNA is quite possibly the worst it has ever been since i started watching regularly in mid 2005 and it doesn't look like it is going to get better anytime soon with the top heels being Ric Flair, Hulk Hogan, Eric Bischoff, Rob Terry and Matt Hardy and the booking being all over the place. Add to the fact that their top star and most over face in AJ Styles is about to be thrown into a feud with Bubba Ray fucking Dudley and you know that it is a long road ahead before it gets better in TNA.
As for AJ Styles being punished though i would say no because it seems quite clear that Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff are simply trying to keep AJ Styles busy and out of the World title scene until either No Surrender or most likely Bound For Glory. One thing i will give Eric Bischoff credit for is he understands the fact that for the biggest PPV of the year you should have the top face against the top heel for the World title which is what he did with Sting/Hogan in WCW, Michaels/Benoit/Triple H and Batista/Triple H in WWE so i expect to see Styles/A.N other at Bound For Glory for the World title.
If as i expect him to Ken Anderson turns heel soon and assumes the role of top heel in TNA and World champion then i would imagine that at No Surrender we would see a four way match between Ken Anderson, AJ Styles and another two people with Ken Anderson getting the win thus meaning the top heel will go into Bound For Glory as World champion. AJ Styles would then challenge for the World title on the biggest stage in TNA as top face and would get the win and World title thus giving TNA a real Bound For Glory moment with their biggest homegrown star in the same way as John Cena does at WrestleMania in WWE.