The WWE should do Rock vs Austin IV(Really their like 10th or 11th 1 vs 1 match but strictly Wrestlemania here), at Wrestlemania 39.
Not The Rock vs Roman Reigns
Not Stone Cold vs John Cena
Let’s not waste any time, feel free to add to the argument or if you disagree explain why… let’s go…
1.
This the biggest match they can possibly do.
Since Rock has returned to WWE in the last decade in 2011 and since Hulk Hogan is retired(thus a Rock/Hogan II or a Rock/Austin/Hogan triple threat is therefore not gonna happen…)
Rock/Austin at Wrestlemania is the biggest possible drawing match at Wrestlemania.
Neither a Rock vs Roman Reigns nor Stone Cold vs John Cena will draw as much as Rock vs Austin at Wrestlemania part IV.
You don’t wanna risk it and do those matches first as it risks injury and thus risks a Rock/Austin match. Look at what happened with Sting, they should’ve did Sting/Taker first and not risk it as they horribly did with his Triple H and Seth Rollins feuds
This is a business and you wanna do the biggest match possible… this is the biggest possible match.
Besides a Rock/Reigns or Austin/Cena storyline and match will not be as good in quality as a Rock/Austin storyline and match.
This isn’t even up for debate.
2.
This is the era of Nostalgia.
Nostalgia is in and booming.
From Cobra Kai to Top Gun Maverick to Commercials(Ferris Bueller, Sopranos), to Skits(Back to the Future, Kenan & Kel reuniting), to Coming 2 America, to companies even rebranding in Nostalgia(See Burger King logo) etc etc
Nostalgia is making money. So not only would you have 2 biggest stars who can still wrestle but you have nostalgia as a draw.
Now....
How to do and commemorate a 4th Rock vs Austin Wrestlemania rivalry and match:
1. Limp Bizkit
One of the best pre match video package of all time is the Wrestlemania 17 Rock vs Austin Limp Bizkit “My Way” pre match promo.
Have the pre match promo be in the same exact cut with Limp Bizkit’s “My Way” theme, just like how Top Gun: Maverick started just like the original Top Gun with Kenny Loggin’s “Dangerzone”
If you want to be original have Limp Bizkit/Fred Durst perform the song live on stage with highlights of the Rock/Austin rivalry playing in the background on the titantron.
2. Face vs Face
Have them both as babyfaces, you wanna make this a babyface vs babyface match.
You can’t have either be a heel when both are fan favorites, heel or face the fans will root for them(See Wrestlemania 15 with Rock being a fan favorite and getting cheered despite being the antagonist in story)
3. Vince Russo
Vince Russo, the very creator of Rock and Austin’s Attitude era characters as well as the Rock/Austin storyline rivalry who wrote their peak feud(Wrestlemania 15/Backlash 1999) and peak characters should be the one to write and end his very storyline.
He should get the honor of ending his storyline and he would write the best feud they would have since their Backlash 1999(While their Wrestlemania 17 feud wasn’t bad, it wasn’t as good, did best PPV domestic numbers due to WCW purchase & stacked mega card, unlike Wrestlemania 15 where they were the only headline with only 170k less domestic ppv buys than 17, also Rock/Austin was more popular in 1999 with higher ratings), no one else has ever written the Rock/Austin as great nor as big as Vince Russo, he's the creator and best writer of the story, he should therefore be the one to end it.
4. Bill it as the finale/Erase the bad taste of their Wrestlemania 19 feud
Bill it as the Rock/Austin finale, unlike Wrestlemania 19 where Austin retired but it was never ever promoted as such, you can build this as Rock vs Austin last match ever.
Make this story better than the Wrestlemania 17 and 19 stories.
Wrestlemania 19 was a flat out horrible build and Wrestlemania 17 while not bad, was a downgrade in quality from their Wrestlemania 15 and Backlash 1999 build ups.
Build it in vein of their most popular rivalry, the 1999 one, and this time actually promote it as the finale(Unless for some reason there is still enough demand for yet another match)
5. Include Easter eggs
Have Easter eggs and continue storylines from the past rivalries.
Rock threw Austin off a bridge, Austin sprayed Rock with beer, Rock scared the shit outta Austin, Austin destroyed Rock's car, Rock turned corporate, Austin and Mcmahon teamed up against Rock etc etc bring it all up.
6. Cameo appearances
Have those involved in the past Rock/Austin rivalry involved in the build.
Characters such as Vince McMahon, Mankind/Mick Foley, Kurt Angle, Triple H, Stephanie Mcmahon, Shane Mcmahon, Gerald Brisco, Earl Hebner, Debra, D Lo Brown, Mark Henry, Farooq, Godfather, Hurricane etc were huge contributors to past Rock/Austin rivalries
You could even do scene with Austin and Debra making peace and moving on in vein of Johnny Lawrence and Ali Mills in Cobra Kai season 3 if they’re up for it(I doubt it but just throwing the idea out):
7. Bring back Jim Ross and Jerry The King Lawler to do commentary
No other commentary team commentated The Rock/Austin matches/rivalry better than Jim Ross and Jerry The King Lawler, not Michael Cole, Kevin Kelly, Paul Heyman, Tazz, etc
THE commentary team should be Jim Ross and Jerry Lawler, open the "forbidden door" if ya gotta get Ross back for one night.
8. Involve current guys
Complain that this takes away from new wrestlers?
While I personally don’t care for any of the current wrestlers, for neutrality/argument sake you can involve new guys into the story, I wouldn't, but in case there's an argument for current gen there ya go.
To conclude:
This can be the best storyline in the last decade(or even last 2 decades…)
The possibilities are endless but here’s the key…
it’s possible.
Rock and Austin are both able to wrestle, this opportunity should
not be wasted.
Who should win the 4th Wrestlemania match? Doesn't matter, the only L would be not having this match happen again when you could have done it again...
To not do this match when it can be done would be one of WWE's biggest sins.
Thanks for reading.