It'd be what we have now but with more curses and sluttier outfits. The rating being PG is a little iffy for not being allowed to swear at your opponent or make him bleed, etc. but scrilla said it best when he said it's the lack of talent that's making the product dull and repetitive and not which audience the shows are targeting. Watch the shows carefully, every wrestler does the same thing, they come out, stop where the walk-way gets thinner, do a hand signal or pose, walk down the aisle, do another pose on the aporn or on the top rope, try to get as much offense as possible in their match, and either win with a finisher, lose to a finisher, or get beat up by a guy they're feuding with resulting in a DQ. Audience want to see people that are different and "abnormal" in a way; people you wouldn;t see everyday who don't do everyday things. Hogan wasn't an everyday guy, Andre wasn't an everyday guy, Austin wasn't an everyday guy, etc.
We have some great guys atm too but it's like they're all missing something big and no one on the roster has practically everything. The bookers and stuff have to blamed too, though. We have a feud like HHH vs. Taker which came from a stare in the face and bunch of discussion that isn't face to face. Then they take a guy like The Miz or Michael Cole and try to turn them into monsters when they can be convincing chicken shits instead. The fuck are they doing? Commentators don't help at all. They're all really bad.