JR was like a fan. He would show emotion, get excited, cheer for the faces... It was awesome.
Comparing him to Cole now is just terrible. Cole every move is like "that will put him away!" and it just gets old. Every move to Cole is like a robot with what he says.
JBL is good too - but he's there for just heel purposes.
Cole comes across as just a suit to me. Someone who is following a script and it's too obvious. JR at least seemed to talk and be normal during a telecast.
I don't know why WWE split them up in the first place. IMO hey did it way too early. Those two together are still to this day my favorite announcing duo in wrestling.