The HBK one is ok. The two main cuts, you should maybe use some effects or something. The blended images, I think, are a little too blended. You can hardly see them. The font isn't the best but it's not bad. The background isn't bad but I think the red and blue are to dark.
The Benoit is better then the other one but still has some problems. The main cut, once again, should use some effects. To bring the cut out more. I don't really like how you blended the other cut either. I don't like the font. I see it a lot and it never really looks good to me. The background isn't bad. I kind of like it actually.