Wrestling Forum banner

61 - 80 of 108 Posts

·
In the bleak midwinter ....
Joined
·
1,927 Posts
I might post an actual tier list, under the following criteria

S-Tier - Consistently good as all alignments
A-Tier - Usually good as all alignments
B-Tier - Consistently good as one alignment, less good as others
C-Tier - Sometimes good as any alignment
D-Tier - Coasters
E-Tier - Erratic Madmen
F-Tier - Dross
Z-Tier - 2018 Lawls

If anyone else wants a go in the meantime ....
 

·
How you doin?
Joined
·
2,879 Posts
I might post an actual tier list, under the following criteria

S-Tier - Consistently good as all alignments
A-Tier - Usually good as all alignments
B-Tier - Consistently good as one alignment, less good as others
C-Tier - Sometimes good as any alignment
D-Tier - Coasters
E-Tier - Erratic Madmen
F-Tier - Dross
Z-Tier - 2018 Lawls

If anyone else wants a go in the meantime ....
I'm so good I get a tier in my name
 

·
In the bleak midwinter ....
Joined
·
1,927 Posts
So here we go (No h8)

S Tier - Magic, Poyser, CP, Imp, Peter
A Tier - Rop3, Xenus, Doddsy, Big Man, LC
B Tier - Jam, Titania, Rugrat, Chimp*, Curry
C Tier - Banez, Skybox, Reap
D Tier - TKOK, T'Challa, Phen0m
E Tier - Chimp
F Tier - Psychosocial, Sol Katti
Z Tier - Lawls

If you're not on the list, I haven't played enough games with you. Like I know Doc is an S-Tier town player based on the one game I've played with him. I think I've covered all the regulars on my list

Couple of notes - Both Phen0m and Chimp are very good when they play/don't fuck around respectively. Lawls is actually an A tier player when hes playing and not fucking around. Titania is obviously a high skill town player but stinks as scum, so my system is unkind to her. SK's rank is mostly for the lols :westbrook2
 

·
Aggressively White
Joined
·
6,236 Posts
Should have made a "Pigeon Tier" for T'Challa. :brodgers

I'd say that list is accurate. I'd say Xenus deserves top billing tbh

I wonder what Titania would say about her positioning given her six year one sided feud with Elsie.
 

·
pretending to be nice
Joined
·
1,492 Posts
So here we go (No h8)

S Tier - Magic, Poyser, CP, Imp, Peter
A Tier - Rop3, Xenus, Doddsy, Big Man, LC
B Tier - Jam, Titania, Rugrat, Chimp*, Curry
C Tier - Banez, Skybox, Reap
D Tier - TKOK, T'Challa, Phen0m
E Tier - Chimp
F Tier - Psychosocial, Sol Katti
Z Tier - Lawls

If you're not on the list, I haven't played enough games with you. Like I know Doc is an S-Tier town player based on the one game I've played with him. I think I've covered all the regulars on my list

Couple of notes - Both Phen0m and Chimp are very good when they play/don't fuck around respectively. Lawls is actually an A tier player when hes playing and not fucking around. Titania is obviously a high skill town player but stinks as scum, so my system is unkind to her. SK's rank is mostly for the lols :westbrook2
Seems right. I'd rate all your garbo tier players higher tho. Flay can have the worst tier to himself, described as "actively makes his team worse". Though he can also have good games if he behaves.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
5,302 Posts
So here we go (No h8)

S Tier - Magic, Poyser, CP, Imp, Peter
A Tier - Rop3, Xenus, Doddsy, Big Man, LC
B Tier - Jam, Titania, Rugrat, Chimp*, Curry
C Tier - Banez, Skybox, Reap
D Tier - TKOK, T'Challa, Phen0m
E Tier - Chimp
F Tier - Psychosocial, Sol Katti
Z Tier - Lawls

If you're not on the list, I haven't played enough games with you. Like I know Doc is an S-Tier town player based on the one game I've played with him. I think I've covered all the regulars on my list

Couple of notes - Both Phen0m and Chimp are very good when they play/don't fuck around respectively. Lawls is actually an A tier player when hes playing and not fucking around. Titania is obviously a high skill town player but stinks as scum, so my system is unkind to her. SK's rank is mostly for the lols :westbrook2

@Sol Katti;

Dis gon be good
 

·
In the bleak midwinter ....
Joined
·
1,927 Posts
Omissions:

Bananas is B
Fitz is A
Pez is probably B
I wouldn’t really know where to put Junk
 

·
In the bleak midwinter ....
Joined
·
1,927 Posts
I’m awaiting your redemption story Ruggers, you should be in the A tier really, it all went wrong when you changed your avatar to Wayne Rooney
 

·
Aggressively White
Joined
·
6,236 Posts
Thanks, I was never an A Tier player - I just had a handful of good games when you started.

That said ; my Internet is now fixed so I can give this mafia lark a proper go
 

·
CHAMPION
Joined
·
1,170 Posts
When you play you are good rugger. You have that naturally scummy demeanour tho which kinda harms you as town but helps when you’re scum. But your reads are solid. I’d say A tier is about right.

I’d have xenus at the top too.

Can’t wait to see @Sol Katti;’s reaction :banderas
 
61 - 80 of 108 Posts
Top