[DogSiDranyam]

A couple of banners I created for a some efed PPVs. Check 'em... Rate 'em... Give constructive criticism...

(We had this name before those ripoffs in TNA )

EDIT: Added this banner, too... It's for a storyline created fed (meaning it only exists for another fed's storyline purposes, not that any of you care )

 

[LK]

Reduce the size of your sig, it's too big....read the rules.

The banners are all ok-ish, nothing wrong with them but they wont WOW me

 

[DogSiDranyam]

Thanks for the tip on the sig. I completely forgot this place had limits.

Anyways, I was kinda looking for a bit of constructive criticism. Especially considering everyone else I've showed these to has loved/raved over 'em (outside of here... I have proof ). Nice to see you disagree... Just wanna know why? "They're OK-ish" and "They don't WOW me" isn't very specific Doesn't tell me anything about WHY. Plus, I know I've showed worse banners around here and people have loved those... Curious lol. We all got our tastes though.

Anyone else?

PS: I have my own little problems with each, but nothing I'd go back to fix.

 

[Jsyn]

they suck

 

[LK]

Pff okay...

First one's BG is cool. Maybe it's troo bright at the center...but you used Bevel and Emboss...that's a big no-no...you placed the text all nice.

Second one is just good.

Third is also good, but it doesn't really appeal to me since it's kinda bland, give it some more contrast, give it some more colors.