I totally agree with what you said here. He was a great talent but I was never a fan. Just never liked him very much or cared about his character, matches, feuds, etc. I never really thought of him as a main event talent. I always felt his ceiling should have been upper mid-card i.e. Jobber to the Stars.A very good worker but I never liked him that much and honestly think that he sometimes gets overrated.
But he was much better all around than Malenko and Benoit. Neither of them could dream of being as charismatic and entertaining as Eddie.i always saw him as the third best in ring worker of The Radicals after Chris Benoit and Dean Malenko although that isn't knocking Eddie Guerrero is it.