[N-destroy]

Which one did you enjoy more?

 

[mrchordproductions]

Bobby Rhoodes Segments were A LOT better but CM Punks PPV matches were probably better(though the austin aries match was great).

Id say I enjoyed bobbys run more

 

[jaw2929]

Punk's, cuz it hasn't ended yet!

 

[Boneduster]

Punk's, cuz it hasn't ended yet!

It's ending Monday

 

[HeliWolf]

Punk's. Cause I watched it.


But I wouldn't trade some of the matches he had for anything (vs Jericho x2, versus Bryan every match he's had with him.

 

[CamillePunk]

Pretty sure threads like these aren't allowed but I'll say Punk's because the matches were far far superior to Roode's.

 

[2ndComingY2J]

bobby who?

 

[GetStokedOnIt]

I'd say Roode's, but that's not to say I didn't enjoy Punk's reign. Roode was just such a good heel though.

 

[Crona]

Bobby's was booked MUCH better than Punk's, but I enjoyed Punk's more.

 

[Rick_James]

I thought Roode's reign was a lot better, he put on a bunch of great matches, awesome on the mic, and is making a lot of people interested in TNA again. Punk's title reign consisted of him still being in the mid card and feuding generally with other people that were in the mid card - I'm a Punk fan too, but this is the truth. TNA did a lot right with Bobby Roode.

 

[Bryan ls A God]

I like both Title reign's but my favourite was CM Punk's just beacause It hasn't ended and he's 1 of my favourites. And he doesn't end every match of his the same like bashing a beer bottle over his opponents head like Roode did. He did that way to often to James Storm and Sting.

 

[joeisgonnakillyou]

bobby who?

this :lmao

in the TNA side "roode" wins
in the WWE side "punk" wins

meh

Overall the it factor wins because he's actually in the fucking main event.

 

[Guerrilla Press Slam]

Roode.

 

[-Extra-]

Who's this Bobby Roode and what title did he held in WWE to compare with Punk?

 

[youssef123]

TNA did great with Bobby Roode, and Roode elevated the TNA world heavyweight title to a whole new level !! Roode was far more better this year than CM Punk, CM Punk was boring, wasn't booked right, and deteriorated a bit more the WWE title reputation (the title was shit, but now, it's worse...).
Bobby Roode looks like a legit champion, and was great from the begginning til' the end of his reign.
And this is coming from a CM Punk fan.

 

[DOPA]

Roode because he is actually booked as a main eventer. Plus he has been an awesome heel. I love Punk but honestly Roode's title reign has been more memorable for me.

 

[Guerrilla Press Slam]

I like both Title reign's but my favourite was CM Punk's just beacause It hasn't ended and he's 1 of my favourites. And he doesn't end every match of his the same like bashing a beer bottle over his opponents head like Roode did.

Like Austin did with the stunner? Or Bret Hart with the Sharpshooter? How about Sweet Chin Music or Hogan's infamous legdrop?

The beer bottle is/was Bobby's gimmick.

 

[BULLY]

Cm Punk's title reign hasn't been horrible, but Bobby Roode's for me. I didn't want it to end.

 

[Carcass]

Punk's. While his character hasn't been that the matches have been phenomenal. Roode's reign sucked in every aspect. The only positive thing about it was it lead to Aries becoming world champ.

 

[TripleG]

I think Roode definitely benefitted from better writing and just the fact that he is the ONLY World Champion in the company helps as well.

I would choose Punk as the better performer and his feuds with Jericho & Bryan were definitely main event worthy, but I just liked having a great long heel reign with a timeless character in Roode.