Interesting post. Can't say I disagree, and I'll have to put Taker in there too. Really sells a limb well, I think.Ziggler is NOT the answer. He can take trememndous "bumps".
The answer is Triple H or CM Punk (imo), these two can "sell" an arm or leg throughout a match, they will get worked on and it it'll show at the end of the match due to great selling.
Ziggler just spins 3 or 4 times when he's clotheslined to sell the individual move.
Don't get me wrong I really like Ziggler, he's entertaining as hell!