[JustTheMC]

Now I've always gone back and forth with Rollins and sometimes I like him other times I don't but Edge I've never cared about. Back in the day I always found myself a bigger fan of Christian but to me I put Seth over Edge overall shoot me💪🏾💪🏾💪🏾. Seth is a better wrestler and a better promo.

Also I'm just going to throw it out there......the Lita triangle helped his character👊🏾👊🏾👊🏾

 

[NatureDog]

I’d probably prefer Edge in general unless he’s trying to be Hunter 2.0

Seth’s best work came prior to shredding his knee in 2015

 

[KR⦻SS]

Edge has a library of cool shit that I would actually go back and watch.

I can't remember a single thing about Seth Rollins besides being a poor crossdresser and a voice that would make someone shove his head through a car window.

 

[La Parka]

I feel like both did their best work as a tag team (or stable in Rollins case) but overall gotta go with Edge.

 

[KR⦻SS]

I forgot who it was. Edge dry-humped pinned this girl at ECW One Night Stand. Its escaping me, but the fact that I remember that little tibbit says it all.

That's probably at the bottom of the barrel of Edge's moments and it's better than everything Seth Rollins ever did.

 

[thorwold]

I think Rollins went into a tailspin with the Bray Wyatt stuff in 2019 and has never recovered (though he’s still a good promo), but from about 2008 up till 2019 I thought he was basically very good, or could be on his day.

I really can’t stand Edge. From the day he debuted and broke that poor dudes neck to all those motherfucking ladder match wins, so on, so forth. Hate him. He was a very good heel for a few years there at the peak of his singles run, and was maybe Cena’s best opponent (give or take Punk), but nah, hate him. Always have and always will. He is a great promo though.

 

[Bobholly39]

Seth Rollins

Not sure why he gets so much shit around here lately.

Both are really good though

 

[BestInTheWorld312]

Seth

 

[sickofcena]

Edge rated r superstar just a more interesting character and promo imo

 

[Black Metal]

Edge no contest.

 

[SuicideSlushPuppie]

Edge. Not close.

 

[Kratosx23]

I don't know why they're being compared but Edge is lightyears better in every aspect. Look, charisma, mic skills, in ring, everything.

 

[RWPunk]

Both have had their moments.

Majority of Edge's stuff after Lita is forgetable besides a few moments. Edge's spear is the worst spear of all time.

Seth was ruined after the Fiend and took years to recover.

I don't know why they're being compared but Edge is lightyears better in every aspect. Look, charisma, mic skills, in ring, everything.

Holy dick riding Batman!!!

Charisma. Edge has it over Seth
Mic skills. Both are pretty much the same and are meh.
Look? For real? More than half of Edges career he had skinny fat muscle worse than CM Punk. Seth has always been in shape and had a better look.
In Ring. That can be very debatable. Edges better matches are definitely gimmick and multi-man matches. Other than that his matches are pretty boring.

 

[robbiecakes]

Both great wrestlers. Edge is the better promo. Edge has had more impactful moments on the industry. Edge wins this one.

 

[Flex2007]

Edge much better promo and he's done more memorable shit. Seth does cool moves.

 

[doctordoom212]

Edge by far

 

[hari123]

As much of a Seth fan that I am, Ultimate Opportunist Edge in 2007-08 is the best.

 

[Prosper]

Edge easily. All the Rated R Superstar stuff with Lita was gold and his feuds with HBK and Cena were memorable. I don’t remember much from Rollins career outside of the heist of the century.

 

[bmack086]

This board is and has always been against Seth…so we know where this is going. Seth has been the best match on the card, basically every event he’s been on since 2014. He went from an okay promo to carrying promos. It’s Seth, and I don’t think it’s close.

 

[Mr619]

Edge is a better wrestler than Seth Rollins.