Wrestling Forum banner

1 - 19 of 19 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
15 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
A Tier List on AEW Wrestlers for 2020 (so far) according to the wrestlers that appear on AEW | All Elite Wrestling Roster | Official Website

A ranking system based on a wrestler’s charisma, mic skills, in-ring ability and likeability combined into a single tier-ranking.
You can vote for a wrestler based on YOUR opinion of them in 2020 thus far, bias is valid and welcomed.
All the submissions will be compiled, and the wrestler will be ranked in accordance with their average rank.

S Tier = 7 points A Tier = 6 points B Tier = 5 points C Tier = 4 points D Tier = 3 points E Tier = 2 points F Tier = 1 points

Each round we rank 6 Male Wrestlers and 2 Females Wrestlers if you don't have an opinion of a wrestler feel free to skip.

Round 2:
Males:

Orange Cassidy
Nick Jackson
Trent
Lance Archer
Chris Jericho
Colt Cabana
Females:
Abadon
Hikaru Shida

CURRENT TIER LIST - After Round 1
Fun Fact:
John Silver received an S Tier Vote and an F Tier Vote last round.
1600314336797.png
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
727 Posts
Orange Cassidy - C (they're starting to force him in unnecessary situations, which will hurt him)
Nick Jackson - A
Trent - C (Chuck Taylor is dragging him down)
Lance Archer - A (the perfect big man)
Chris Jericho - A (King Midas)
Colt Cabana - D
Females:
Abadon - E (didn't see enough of her, plus i'm not impressed with the gimmick)
Hikaru Shida - B (she doesn't have enough quality opponents)
 

·
Banned
WF Legend
Joined
·
7,709 Posts
Orange Cassidy - E

Nick Jackson - C

Trent - C

Lance Archer - C (No fault of his own, bad booking)

Chris Jericho - B (Again, no fault of his own but AEW allowing him to do his stupid garbage hurts him)

Colt Cabana - D (Colt would usually be a C but I just can't get into him at all in AEW)

Females:

Abadon - E

Shida - D
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
Orange Cassidy: D (Comedy Act, should be used less and sparingly)
Nick Jackson: A (Consistently producing the most entertaining tag-matches alongside his brother)
Trent: C (Great look, acts too goofy - needs to get serious)
Lance Archer: A+ (Amazing! My favourite act right now along side Jake Roberts, terrific in the ring, amazing precense, would love for him to beat Moxley and fued with Brain Cage)
Chris Jericho: C (Involved in a terrible fued with Orange Cassidy which ruined his Aura, still has occasional good moments)
Cold Cabana: D (Solid, somewhat involved in a semi-intresting storyline with Dark Order, however, he still acts goofy and needs to become evil quicker)
 

·
Premium Member
Geekslayer
Joined
·
10,971 Posts
Males:
Orange Cassidy - E
Nick Jackson - E (Knowing how to work properly and refusing to most of the time makes you worse than just not knowing)
Trent - B (Held back by Chuck)
Lance Archer - A
Chris Jericho - B (A last year, C this year)
Colt Cabana - D
Females:
Abadon - C (green but has potential)
Hikaru Shida - A
 

·
Justice 4 Asuka
Joined
·
1,914 Posts
Orange Cassidy - D - I don't dislike him but I don't get the hype either. Shouldn't have went over Jericho.

Nick Jackson - B - Has put on some great tag team matches this year along with Matt.

Trent - C+ - I definitely think he's the better of the two.

Lance Archer - B - Again I'd give him a B. Hasn't put on enough great matches for an A

Jericho - A - He's simply one of the greatest ever. He manages to get anything over, he even managed to get a demo God shirt. His in ring work has obviously declined though.

Colt Cabana - D - Meh, he's just kinda there isn't he. Not terrible though to warrant an E or F though.

Abadon - C+ - Has a great character and should be a B+ player next year when she improves her in ring craft. She has lots of potential.

Shida - A+ - Basically the best they have by far. Has had several good-great matches and has carried the division through the Covid period.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,853 Posts
Males:
Orange Cassidy - D
Nick Jackson - C
Trent - C
Lance Archer - C
Chris Jericho - B
Colt Cabana - E
Females:
Abadon - D
Hikaru Shida - C
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,319 Posts
A Tier List on AEW Wrestlers for 2020 (so far) according to the wrestlers that appear on AEW | All Elite Wrestling Roster | Official Website

A ranking system based on a wrestler’s charisma, mic skills, in-ring ability and likeability combined into a single tier-ranking.
You can vote for a wrestler based on YOUR opinion of them in 2020 thus far, bias is valid and welcomed.
All the submissions will be compiled, and the wrestler will be ranked in accordance with their average rank.

S Tier = 7 points A Tier = 6 points B Tier = 5 points C Tier = 4 points D Tier = 3 points E Tier = 2 points F Tier = 1 points

Each round we rank 6 Male Wrestlers and 2 Females Wrestlers if you don't have an opinion of a wrestler feel free to skip.

Round 2:
Males:

Orange Cassidy
Nick Jackson
Trent
Lance Archer
Chris Jericho
Colt Cabana
Females:
Abadon
Hikaru Shida

CURRENT TIER LIST - After Round 1
Fun Fact:
John Silver received an S Tier Vote and an F Tier Vote last round.
View attachment 91062
Silver on ‘D‘ is blasphemy - we’ll see in a year’s time when he is the biggest babyface

screenshot this post
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,722 Posts
Males:
Orange Cassidy - D
Nick Jackson - B
Trent - B
Lance Archer - B
Chris Jericho - A
Colt Cabana - D

Females:
Abadon - E
Hikaru Shida - A
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
6,405 Posts
Orange Cassidy: D
Nick Jackson: D
Trent: B
Lance Archer: C
Chris Jericho: C, his shape is disgusting and his breath... god, he aged a lot in the last few years
Colt Cabana: B
Abadon: C
Hikaru Shida: C
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
70 Posts
Males:
Orange Cassidy - C
Nick Jackson - C
Trent - D
Lance Archer - C
Chris Jericho - A
Colt Cabana - D
Females:
Abadon - D
Hikaru Shida - B
 

·
Currently lying down wearing a blue suit
Joined
·
13,202 Posts
Males:

Orange Cassidy: B (he's an entertaining character, over as hell with fans, and he definitely deserves the push/spotlight he's received lately; SCREW the bitter critics)

Nick Jackson: B

Trent Beretta: B

Lance Archer: B

Chris Jericho: S

Colt Cabana: C

Females:

Abadon: D

Hikaru Shida: B
 
1 - 19 of 19 Posts
Top