Which one is/was hotter? The parallels are incredible. Austin was the first man to ever lay out the boss in the AE, Big Show was the first man ever to lay out the boss in the PG era. Austin drives a beer truck to the ring, Big Show drives a semi-truck. Also, the Big Show returning to help the Rhodes brothers win the tag titles is eerily similar to Austin helping Mankind win his first title. Who do you think is a bigger star? I will have to go with the Big Show. The beer truck and Mankind title win didn't really draw much of a crowd reaction. However, the crowd popped huge for Show tonight, and the Rhodes brothers winning the tag team titles was an epic moment. That win will be talked about for generations. The Big Show is an A+ player.