Basically, do you think 2010 was an improvement from 2009.
I'll break it down piece by piece.
Storylines: 2009's biggest storylines included Orton vs. Cena, Orton vs. Triple H, & Punk vs. Jeff Hardy which were all 3 great feuds with great buildup to them with classic moments like Randy Orton trying to blow up John Cena with the pyro, Randy Orton taking out the whole McMahon family and CM Punk's epic promos toward Jeff Hardy. In 2010 the main storylines were Cena vs. Wade Barrett, Cena vs. Batista, and Kane vs. Undertaker. Kane vs. Undertaker had great buildup with the whole Kane trying to figure out who did it stuff but it ended up being an epic fail. Cena vs. Wade Barrett was a great feud as well as Cena vs. Batista but I'm gonna give the edge to 2009.
Shows: On the RAW side 2010 wins this by a landslide. Especially, due to the increased talent being drafted over, the whole Nexus storyline and the decrease of guest host segments which really killed 2009's shows. On the SmackDown side it all went downhill due to pretty much all of their main talent from 2009 being drafted to RAW. The lack of starpower and the lack of interest really hurt Smackdown. 2010 SmackDown still produced great matches, however, so I'm gonna give the edge to 2010 mainly because of their great improvement from RAW this year.
PPV's: Comparing the 2009 PPV's to the 2010 PPV's, 2009's were vastly superior. The Royal Rumble, No Way Out, Backlash, Judgment Day, Extreme Rules, Survivor Series, & Bragging Rights were all better than their successors and seeing as the majority were better than their successors I'll give the edge to 2009.
Pushes: The 2010 Youth Movement definitely helped 2010 as far as creating new talent. In 2010 the WWE has created main events stars out of The Miz, Wade Barrett, Alberto Del Rio, Sheamus (Yeah he won the WWE title in 2009 but he wasn't a true main event star until this year), and Daniel Bryan have been giving great pushes. As well as guys like Dolph Ziggler and the member of the Nexus getting their time to shine.
All in all, when I break it down to these four categories, I think I'd put the years as equal.