Yep agreed. Most of MsChifs title matches were disappointing and i really enjoy Portia Perez as a heel.
She also had the misfortune of having the title bouts right after awesome matches in multiple volumes.
In other words, having matches after Del Rey, Melissa, Stock, Hamada, or the Joshi wrestlers.
When it comes to favorite wrestlers...
Past - Tiana Ringer. For some reason, I really liked watching "Smurfette" wrestle. She had a certain type of zaniness that, if she was in the industry longer, probably would have gotten her more mainstream jobs, IMO. Namely in TNA. Plus, I liked that she was able to incorporate her ballerina and martial art skills into her move set. I just wish I got to see it evolve.
It really sucks that she left the industry, but... Honestly, I just hope she's happy were she is now.
Present - This is a really difficult question. There's a slew of awesome talent in the promotion right now. Melissa has been my consistent favorite, but Hamada hasn't had a match less than three stars yet. So again, really difficult, but...
Future - I see plenty of potential. Athena, Matthews, McKay, the Rate Tank, etc... Right now though? Jesse McKay. I think in a few years she'll be the future of women's wrestling much like Del Rey currently personafies it (I don't count the Divas or KOs).
Favorite not in Shimmer? Look at the sig. Taeler Hendrix.