Re: WON: Dominion Star Ratings
I would like to actually ask Dave one day what does 5 stars really mean to him anymore? And yes, I know it's all personal opinion. I disagree with it, but whatever. And honestly I get more annoyed by people who can't have an opinion of their own than Meltzer himself.
But when I look at 5 star matches from WWE in the past like Taker vs. HBK inside the Cell or Punk vs. Cena from MITB, those are worthy of 5 stars. Because they weren't just great matches, they were moments in time.
You look at a match like Ospreay vs. Dragon Lee, while very good, is it a moment time. Is it going to live on in people's memories like those other matches did or like Okada vs. Omega did?
No. And that's why most of the time I just can't take his opinions, at least as far as match quality, seriously.