This is so simplistic if you think town always tell the truth.
There's a difference between telling one lie to try and catch someone else in a lie or holding back information to slide by without drawing the mafia kill.
It's entirely different to constantly lie throughout the game and imply you have information on someone just because you know you can't build a genuine case against the other than "he unvoted and defended".
When have I tried to do dumb shit like this as scum before?
I’m not gonna be that ballsy to try an out the BG like this. Hell, I presented a pretty comprehensive case just so that I could out the bg, something which is just an unnecesary risk for me to take.
Its not WIFOM. Scum simply don’t do what I just did. And dumb scum is just weak reasoning. Since there’s no way to differentiate between what dumb scum or dumb town would do.
You've been sussed all game, and with this result you're out of shots. It's not at all unreasonable to think you'll be killed off soon, why not out the BG before you go? What comprehensive case?
Why would you do something dumb as town if you knew it was dumb? The same thing applies to scum. You can't just say "oh guess that was dumb" about something and have that as a reason to avoid analyzing it.