I actually concur quite a bit with Masenko regarding Gambit. His Day one was all over the place and mostly revolved around wanting to kill Masenko and fluffing. Wasn't Gambit one of the top town players in this section a while back? I feel like it's a deliberate change in meta. What has swayed me however was his grenade throw at Masenko. Mafia throwing a grenade Day 1 is a ridiculous move and absolutely not worth it so I'm guessing no Mafia have thrown a grenade yet but that makes the game really easy for town. Mafia have to have some sort of way to control their grenades or roles that make grenades a DUD or some other bullshit. If this is the case which I'm going to assume, it would be a perfect play for Gambit to appear as reckless town. No Mafia member would act like this. It could even have been a bus with Masenko being a scum teammate but I don't see that as the case as I'm reading Masenko as town. He always posts like a fool and is extremely stubborn in his incorrect analysis which is no change this game. It's a really risky meta since he ALWAYS seems to be a target for a lynch. It would be idiotic to play like that as Mafia, although WIFOM and all that. I just don't see him being able to play to his town meta since it requires loads of idiotic remarks that are hard to fake.
We should definitely look at the Fitz wagon for scum. It was a ridiculous wagon in my opinion, Fitz was clearly town-Fitz during that Day 1 and him claiming Miller just makes the case on him being town that much stronger. I've liked most of the active posters so far, strong lean on Junk being town, Superior as well iirc, LC town but should never be trusted. I believe Chr1st0 has a pretty poor scum game, he'll be outed quickly later in the game if he's scum so keeping him around is a good thing for now. He hasn't offered much so far though. I haven't liked CP so far. CP isn't known for his day 1 plays though (?) but his plays were absolutely useless in my opinion, contributing very little to the discussion. Look at these posts for example:
flip flop on fitz who I think is town
I don't mind this post, although I feel like Masenko is obvious bad town. However, minutes later he posts this:
LC was right on him last time so
Flip flops himself after lynching Masenko for the same thing. He even puts the burden of guilt on LC if this goes through and Superior flips town. IIRC he's done this in the past as well, left it up to LC to lead. Don't recall what alignment he was but I think it's all pretty sus and very un-CP-like. I've always thought of CP as more of a leader as town. I don't know, I don't trust him right now at least.