Rate the Classic Superstar: Melina edition - Wrestling Forum: WWE, AEW, New Japan, Indy Wrestling, Women of Wrestling Forums

View Poll Results: Who should we rate next?
Ric Flair 1 33.33%
WALTER 1 33.33%
Kurt Angle 2 66.67%
Velveteen Dream 1 33.33%
Owen Hart 1 33.33%
Roddy Piper 1 33.33%
Big Show 2 66.67%
Johnny Gargano 1 33.33%
Apollo Crews 2 66.67%
Chris Benoit 1 33.33%
Kyle O'Reilly 1 33.33%
Tommaso Ciampa 1 33.33%
Triple H 2 66.67%
Pete Dunne 1 33.33%
Roderick Strong 1 33.33%
Matt Riddle 2 66.67%
Batista 2 66.67%
Matt Hardy 2 66.67%
Randy Savage 1 33.33%
Erick Rowan 2 66.67%
Mick Foley 1 33.33%
Kane 2 66.67%
Eddie Guerrero 1 33.33%
Mojo Rawley 2 66.67%
Adam Cole 1 33.33%
Luke Harper 2 66.67%
Xavier Woods 2 66.67%
Kofi Kingston 2 66.67%
Big E 2 66.67%
Usos 2 66.67%
Edge 1 33.33%
Revival 2 66.67%
CM Punk 1 33.33%
The Rock 1 33.33%
Hulk Hogan 1 33.33%
Undertaker 1 33.33%
Sting 1 33.33%
Oney Lorcan 1 33.33%
Humberto Carrillo 1 33.33%
Ariya Daivari 1 33.33%
Tony Nese 1 33.33%
Mike Kanellis 2 66.67%
Akira Tozawa 1 33.33%
Lio Rush 1 33.33%
TJP 1 33.33%
Lince Dorado 1 33.33%
Kelly Kelly 1 33.33%
Eve Torres 1 33.33%
Victoria 1 33.33%
Gail Kim 2 66.67%
AJ Lee 1 33.33%
Layla 1 33.33%
Bianca Belair 1 33.33%
Shayna Baszler 1 33.33%
Michelle McCool 1 33.33%
Chyna 1 33.33%
Kaitlyn 1 33.33%
Torrie Wilson 1 33.33%
Dakota Kai 1 33.33%
Candice LeRae 1 33.33%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 3. You may not vote on this poll

 9Likes
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
post #1 of 16 (permalink) Old 10-05-2019, 02:15 AM Thread Starter
Currently lying down wearing a blue suit
 
DammitC's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2016
Location: Hollywood, FL
Favourite(s): Bryan, AJ, Seth, Ziggler, Zayn, KO, Joe, Cesaro
Posts: 10,067
Points: 34,217
                     
Rate the Classic Superstar: Melina edition

Yep, you know the drill. This is a women's week, which means that it is now time to rate another classic female superstar. I'd like to thank those of you who participated in my previous threads. Remember that all of your votes DO matter, but please just try to be objective. Let's also try to get as many responses here as possible now

As you already know, AOP ended up being ranked at 36th place in the current section so far. Unfortunately for AOP, the ratings for their mic skills hurt them drastically. However, the Authors of Pain did receive a pretty good score for their look/presence.

As you already know, Kalisto ended up being ranked at 5th place in the cruiserweight section so far. Unfortunately for Kalisto, the ratings for his mic skills hurt him drastically. However, the King of Flight did receive a good score for his in-ring ability.

Here are the updated standings:

Classic:

Steve Austin: 9.6 (Look/Presence 9.7, In-Ring Ability 9.0, Charisma 9.9, Mic Skills 9.7)
Chris Jericho: 9.1 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 8.8, Charisma 9.7, Mic Skills 9.8)
Bret Hart: 8.8 (Look/Presence 9.3, In-Ring Ability 9.9, Charisma 8.6, Mic Skills 7.5)
Shawn Michaels: 8.7 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 9.4, Charisma 9.0, Mic Skills 8.0)
Goldberg: 7.3 (Look/Presence 9.7, In-Ring Ability 5.0, Charisma 9.0, Mic Skills 5.6)

Current:

Samoa Joe: 8.9 (Look/Presence 8.9, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 9.5)
Daniel Bryan: 8.9 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 9.7, Charisma 9.2, Mic Skills 8.6)
John Cena: 8.7 (Look/Presence 9.2, In-Ring Ability 7.2, Charisma 9.4, Mic Skills 9.1)
Randy Orton: 8.2 (Look/Presence 9.3, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 7.2)
EC3: 8.1 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 8.0, Mic Skills 8.5)
Bray Wyatt: 8.1 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 8.8)
The Miz: 8.0 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 6.9, Charisma 8.3, Mic Skills 9.3)
AJ Styles: 7.9 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 9.3, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 6.6)
BW: 7.8 (7.9, 6.4, 8.4, 8.6)
Jeff Hardy: 7.8 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 9.4, Mic Skills 5.7)
Dean Ambrose: 7.8 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 6.8. Charisma 8.2, Mic Skills 8.4)
Seth Rollins: 7.7 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 8.3, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 6.9)
R-Truth: 7.7 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 7.9)
Aleister Black: 7.5 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 8.3, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 6.6)
Kevin Owens: 7.5 (Look/Presence 6.0, In-Ring Ability 7.7, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 8.4)
Sheamus: 7.5 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 6.9, Mic Skills 7.0)
SR: 7.4 (7.7, 8.1, 7.3, 6.6)
Dolph Ziggler: 7.4 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 7.0, Mic Skills 6.9)
Braun Strowman: 7.4 (Look/Presence 9.4, In-Ring Ability 5.9. Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 6.1)
Bobby Roode: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 7.1, Charisma 7.2, Mic Skills 7.0)
Cesaro: 7.3 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 9.3, Charisma 6.4, Mic Skills 5.0)
Brock Lesnar: 7.2 (Look/Presence 9.5, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 4.1)
Rusev: 7.2 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 6.6)
Elias: 7.2 (Look/Presence 7.8, In-Ring Ability 5.4, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 7.9)
Rey Mysterio: 7.1 (Look/Presence 7.0, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 7.5, Mic Skills 5.6)
Sami Zayn: 7.0 (Look/Presence 4.9, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 7.1, Mic Skills 7.6)
Andrade Cien Almas: 7.0 (Look/Presence 7.9, In-Ring Ability 8.8, Charisma 7.2, Mic Skills 3.9)
BL: 6.9 (9.2, 7.0, 7.5, 3.8)
Jason Jordan: 6.9 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 6.1, Mic Skills 5.4)
SZ: 6.8 (4.8, 8.2, 6.9, 7.4)
Drew McIntyre: 6.8 (Look/Presence 9.1, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 4.8, Mic Skills 5.7)
Finn Balor: 6.7 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 7.9, Charisma 6.4, Mic Skills 5.2)
Mustafa Ali: 6.7 (Look/Presence 6.0, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 6.1, Mic Skills 6.4)
Roman Reigns: 6.7 (Look/Presence 8.7, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 5.4)
Chad Gable: 6.5 (Look/Presence 6.0, In-Ring Ability 8.3, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 5.7)
Shinsuke Nakamura: 6.4 (Look/Presence 7.1, In-Ring Ability 7.3, Charisma 7.6, Mic Skills 3.7)
Baron Corbin: 6.3 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 6.4, Charisma 6.1, Mic Skills 6.4)
CG: (5.7, 8.2, 5.7, 5.4)
SN: 6.2 (6.9, 7.0, 7.4, 3.6)
Bobby Lashley: 6.1 (Look/Presence 9.5, In-Ring Ability 6.7, Charisma 4.3, Mic Skills 3.9)
Jinder Mahal: 5.7 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 4.7, Charisma 5.1, Mic Skills 5.1)
AOP: 5.5 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 6.4, Charisma 4.1, Mic Skills 3.3)
JM: 5.4 (7.3, 4.5, 4.8, 4.9)
Ricochet: 4.7 (Look/Presence 4.9, In-Ring Ability 6.4, Charisma 4.4, Mic Skills 2.9)
R: 4.6 (4.8, 6.3, 4.3, 2.8)

Women:

Becky Lynch: 8.3 (Look/Presence 8.3, In-Ring Ability 7.8, Charisma 8.8, Mic Skills 8.2)
Trish Stratus: 8.3 (Look/Presence 9.5, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 8.7, Mic Skills 7.5)
BL: 8.2 (8.2, 7.7, 8.7, 8.0)
Mickie James: 8.1 (Look/Presence 8.4, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 7.9)
TS: 7.9 (9.2, 7.1, 8.3, 7.1)
Asuka: 7.9 (Look/Presence 8.5, In-Ring Ability 8.9, Charisma 8.8, Mic Skills 5.3)
Alexa Bliss: 7.9 (Look/Presence 8.4, In-Ring Ability 6.0, Charisma 8.5, Mic Skills 8.6)
Toni Storm: 7.8 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 7.9, Mic Skills 6.3)
Rhea Ripley: 7.7 (Look/Presence 8.8, In-Ring Ability 7.8, Charisma 7.7, Mic Skills 6.5)
Ruby Riott: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.0, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 7.7)
Charlotte Flair: 7.3 (Look/Presence 8.1, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 6.0)
Beth Phoenix: 7.3 (Look/Presence 9.1, In-Ring Ability 7.7, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 5.7)
Sasha Banks: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 8.1, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 6.2)
Molly Holly: 7.3 (Look/Presence 7.1, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 6.9)
Kairi Sane: 7.2 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 7.8, Mic Skills 4.4)
RR: 7.1 (6.7, 7.8, 6.5, 7.5)
Lacey Evans: 7.1 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 5.9, Charisma 7.1, Mic Skills 7.0)
Lita: 7.0 (Look/Presence 8.5, In-Ring Ability 6.3, Charisma 8.1, Mic Skills 5.2)
Io Shirai: 7.0 (Look/Presence 8.0, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 7.3, Mic Skills 4.0)
KS: 7.0 (7.7, 8.5, 7.5, 4.2)
Ronda Rousey: 6.7 (Look/Presence 8.2, In-Ring Ability 7.2, Charisma 6.9, Mic Skills 4.3)
Ember Moon: 6.5 (Look/Presence 7.6, In-Ring Ability 8.7, Charisma 5.4, Mic Skills 4.3)
Carmella: 6.5 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 4.7, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 7.3)
Nikki Cross: 6.5 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 6.6, Charisma 7.0, Mic Skills 6.1)
EM: 6.4 (7.3, 8.6, 5.3, 4.2)
Sonya Deville: 6.3 (Look/Presence 7.4, In-Ring Ability 7.0, Charisma 5.5, Mic Skills 5.3)
Mandy Rose: 6.2 (Look/Presence 8.6, In-Ring Ability 5.3, Charisma 5.7, Mic Skills 5.2)
SD: 6.2 (7.3, 6.9, 5.4, 5.2)
MR: 6.1 (8.4, 5.2, 5.6, 5.1)
Peyton Royce: 6.1 (Look/Presence 7.7, In-Ring Ability 5.1, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 5.6)
Bayley: 6.1 (Look/Presence 6.3, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 6.6, Mic Skills 3.8)
B: 5.9 (6.1, 7.5, 6.5, 3.6)
Nikki Bella: 5.9 (Look/Presence 7.3, In-Ring Ability 5.5, Charisma 6.0, Mic Skills 4.6)
NB: 5.7 (7.0, 5.4, 5.7, 4.5)
Billie Kay: 5.6 (Look/Presence 6.4, In-Ring Ability 4.0, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 6.0)
Maryse: 5.6 (Look/Presence 7.5, In-Ring Ability 3.9, Charisma 6.0, Mic Skills 4.9)
BK: 5.4 (6.2, 3.9, 5.7, 5.8)
Natalya: 5.4 (Look/Presence 5.8, In-Ring Ability 7.4, Charisma 3.7, Mic Skills 4.6)
N: 5.2 (5.5, 7.2, 3.5, 4.4)
Naomi: 4.9 (Look/Presence 6.3, In-Ring Ability 5.4, Charisma 4.6, Mic Skills 3.2)
N: 4.6 (6.0, 5.0, 4.3, 3.0)
Alicia Fox: 4.5 (Look/Presence 5.6, In-Ring Ability 4.3, Charisma 4.4, Mic Skills 3.7)
Brie Bella: 4.1 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 2.9, Charisma 4.4, Mic Skills 3.0)
DB: 4.1 (5.2, 4.2, 3.5, 3.4)
BB: 3.9 (5.9, 2.8, 4.1, 2.8)
Dana Brooke: 3.9 (Look/Presence 5.1, In-Ring Ability 4.0, Charisma 3.3, Mic Skills 3.1)
Nia Jax: 3.5 (Look/Presence 5.3, In-Ring Ability 2.9, Charisma 3.2, Mic Skills 2.6)
NJ: 3.3 (5.0, 2.7, 2.9, 2.4)
Tamina: 2.8 (Look/Presence 5.3, In-Ring Ability 3.1, Charisma 1.3, Mic Skills 1.3)
T: 2.4 (4.6, 2.7, 1.1, 1.1)

Cruiserweight:

Brian Kendrick: 7.5 (Look/Presence 6.9, In-Ring Ability 8.0, Charisma 7.7, Mic Skills 7.5)
Drew Gulak: 7.2 (Look/Presence 6.2, In-Ring Ability 8.2, Charisma 7.0, Mic Skills 7.4)
Buddy Murphy: 6.9 (Look/Presence 7.6, In-Ring Ability 8.4, Charisma 5.9, Mic Skills 5.8)
Jack Gallagher: 6.7 (Look/Presence 6.1, In-Ring Ability 7.7, Charisma 6.4, Mic Skills 6.5)
Kalisto: 5.3 (Look/Presence 5.6, In-Ring Ability 7.1 Charisma 4.8, Mic Skills 3.8)
Cedric Alexander: 5.3 (Look/Presence 5.3, In-Ring Ability 7.6, Charisma 4.8, Mic Skills 3.6)
CA: 5.1 (5.0, 7.3, 4.6, 3.4)

Today we will rate Melina since she also won the previous poll. This is your turn to vote. Make sure to keep up!

Please set each quality in this order (Look/Presence, In-Ring Ability, Charisma, Mic Skills), so it'll be easier to count your votes

NOTE: If you feel like you missed out on a previous rating thread of a superstar, then it is NOT too late!! I am still willing to count any of your votes for any old rating threads from this year. You folks have until the END OF THIS DECEMBER to do this; so just be sure to let me know which old rating thread you want me to include your vote in, and just be sure that it's from a thread in 2019. If you even feel like bumping up any of my older rating threads, then go right on ahead! My rankings are based off the MOST UPDATED standings. The MORE votes that are included to ALL of this, the MORE accurate the results will be

Edit: Don't forget that the poll is MULTIPLE CHOICE.

Previous Threads:

https://www.wrestlingforum.com/raw/2...p-edition.html

https://www.wrestlingforum.com/raw/2...o-edition.html

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/D55vUv4WAAE9lQJ.jpg

Are you having trouble having access to my older rating threads? Did you forget to vote for one of the currently rated talents? Click on the link below, search through my RTC threads, and bump up any of my old rating threads so you can still get your votes counted in

https://www.wrestlingforum.com/565609-dammitc.html
DammitC is online now  
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
post #2 of 16 (permalink) Old 10-05-2019, 02:38 AM Thread Starter
Currently lying down wearing a blue suit
 
DammitC's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2016
Location: Hollywood, FL
Favourite(s): Bryan, AJ, Seth, Ziggler, Zayn, KO, Joe, Cesaro
Posts: 10,067
Points: 34,217
                     
Re: Rate the Classic Superstar: Melina edition

Melina:

Look/Presence: 9.5/10

In-Ring Ability: 8/10

Charisma: 8/10

Mic Skills: 9/10

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/D55vUv4WAAE9lQJ.jpg

Are you having trouble having access to my older rating threads? Did you forget to vote for one of the currently rated talents? Click on the link below, search through my RTC threads, and bump up any of my old rating threads so you can still get your votes counted in

https://www.wrestlingforum.com/565609-dammitc.html
DammitC is online now  
post #3 of 16 (permalink) Old 10-05-2019, 02:53 AM
Seek the wolf in thyself...
 
Lord Trigon's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2018
Location: Pre-apocalyptic Australia
Favourite(s): Ruby Riott, Mustafa Ali, Buddy Murphy
Posts: 1,806
Points: 9,552
                     
Re: Rate the Classic Superstar: Melina edition

Look/Presence: 8
In-Ring Ability: 7
Charisma: 7.5
Mic Skills: 8
DammitC likes this.






11-21-17
Lord Trigon is offline  
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
post #4 of 16 (permalink) Old 10-05-2019, 03:02 AM
TAFKA KroKro
 
Krokro's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2015
Posts: 2,556
Points: 7,737
                     
Re: Rate the Classic Superstar: Melina edition

Hate that I don't rep anybody but you C, because it means I can't rep you again. No worries about AoP, a poll is a poll after all!

I always have trouble rating women. Are we rating them fairly against men? Because... it makes it more difficult. Against other women? I don't know. Either way. It's hardly relevant.

Looks/Presence: 9/10 - Melina was hot. That split she did, was just unnfff.. so, yeah .She was dope.
In-Ring Ability: 7/10 - Melina, compared to her peers, was actually pretty solid during the era she wrestled in. Hence why I was confused how to rate her. Her, Mickie James, Beth Phoenix, and Gail Kim are the four that I think would hold up extremely well with today's roster. However... of those 4, Melina has to be the weakest.
Charisma: 6/10 - I admit, I don't remember her being very charismatic, but I don't remember her being awful. She has more physical charisma more than anything.
Mic Skills: 5/10 - Same as above. I remember her being very average.
Krokro is offline  
post #5 of 16 (permalink) Old 10-05-2019, 07:07 AM
Fearless University Graduate
 
Eva MaRIHyse's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2014
Location: Rihanna Drive
Favourite(s): Tessa Blanchard
Posts: 14,410
Points: 60,968
                     
Re: Rate the Classic Superstar: Melina edition

Look/Presence: 9/10

In-Ring Ability: 8/10

Charisma: 7/10

Mic Skills: 9/10
DammitC likes this.

You can catch me, Rih, in the new La Ferrar'

Womens Champion * World Champion * Hardcore Champion
The Breast Of The Breast
Eva MaRIHyse is offline  
post #6 of 16 (permalink) Old 10-05-2019, 10:20 AM
Pro WWE
 
Blissed Phenomenon's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2018
Location: CHCH, New Zealand
Favourite(s): Refer above
Posts: 9,045
Points: 5,501
                     
Presence-7.5
In Ring-8
Mic Skills-7
Charisma-8
DammitC likes this.

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn%3AANd9GcSiyoDfCp9alJ9Ia3AG2cL3e6Nvp2rDLe4p6Xf9HwjPURYFHY99
Blissed Phenomenon is offline  
post #7 of 16 (permalink) Old 10-05-2019, 10:34 AM
 
Join Date: Jun 2018
Posts: 418
Points: 1,310
                     
Re: Rate the Classic Superstar: Melina edition

Look/Presence. 8

Ring skills. 6

Charisma. 8

Mic skills. 7
DammitC likes this.
hypnobitch is offline  
post #8 of 16 (permalink) Old 10-05-2019, 11:02 AM
Scarring the Night Sky
 
emerald-fire's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2017
Posts: 4,983
Points: 71,943
                     
Re: Rate the Classic Superstar: Melina edition

Look/Presence - 10/10
In-ring ability - 8.5/10
Charisma - 8/10
Mic skills - 8.5/10
DammitC likes this.

emerald-fire is offline  
post #9 of 16 (permalink) Old 10-05-2019, 12:29 PM
 
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 4,625
Points: 4,275
                     
Re: Rate the Classic Superstar: Melina edition

Look/Presence: 6
Ring skills: 5
Charisma: 6
Mic skills: 7
deadcool is offline  
post #10 of 16 (permalink) Old 10-05-2019, 01:14 PM
Queen of all Galaxies
 
Emmanuelle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2018
Posts: 2,906
Points: 11,858
                     
Re: Rate the Classic Superstar: Melina edition

Look/Presence: 9.5
In-Ring Ability: 8.5
Charisma: 8
Mic Skills: 8
DammitC likes this.

Emmanuelle is offline  
Reply

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page



Posting Rules  
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are On

 
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome