Join Date: Oct 2013
Favourite(s): Mox, Zayn, Y2J, Bray, McIntyre, Bryan, Pac, Braun
Re: Rate the Classic Superstar: CM Punk edition
Look/Presence: 8. His look wasn't exactly very tough or badass, but he had superstar presence. He could carry himself like a star, and was a believable opponent for big guys (if booked to be). For example, his Lesnar match. I though he looked great there, Brock actually sold for him, and it wasn't ridiculous or stupid, it felt legitimate.
In-Ring Ability: 6. He was good, he knows in-ring stuff, I just feel like he lost it someway around the last 3 years of his career. He had many great matches, though.
Charisma: 10. Even when he hadn't received any character development (like 2006-7-ish), he still somehow appealed. I don't know what it was, except great charisma. All those years I was waiting for him to be given the chance, and when they did - he shined greatly.
Mic Skills: 10. He was the or one of the best mic workers ever existed. That is not for debate, it's a fact.