Wrestling Forum banner

Poll/Comparison Section

510 views 1 reply 2 participants last post by  Oxidamus 
#1 ·
I know that comparison threads seem to be frowned upon around these parts but they tend to sneak there way in regardless and it seems like people are content to make GOAT or "Who do you think should be pushed?" threads.

My thought process is that this sort of section would allow fans to make these comparisons while the brand sections would be more dedicated to in depth discussion.
 
#2 ·
A wee bit before your time the administrators and such decided upon giving a sticky thread a shot. That thread was "The GOAT Discussion Thread", or something along those lines.

Guess what came with it? Amazingly pointless arguments with RATINGZ, huge wars between marks arguing semantics, and subjectivity as facts, and an immense amount of flaming each other.

The thread ended only a short while after it was made. Maybe a month or two at max.


This suggestion has been made a couple of times and it was probably a driving reason behind the GOAT thread attempt. Overall it just turns an already hard-to-manage forum with much too many immature children insulting each other into... Well, double that.

I think comparison threads are alright by themselves but unfortunately it's just the posters who make them bad. They're disallowed because, basically, the kids can't control themselves in the face of their personal forum-adversity.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top