Sheamus is clearly better in every area, but that's not an endorsement. He's average and Batista is gutwrenching. The company is better off with him than Dave, at least the product quality is.
Finding somebody to replace anybody isn't hard, unless it's John Cena and they even have ample time to do that.
You got to stop bashing Sheamus, Morrison, and Swagger every chance you get. It's really annoying we get it! As for Batista? Batista had more starpower, the history, a character development, stage presence, and was mroe charismatic than Sheamus. That's not a a knock to Sheamus as he has certainly grown on me. Sheamus > Pyro's bashing