Originally Posted by Felpent
Either Triple H/Batista or Taker/Shawn.
Taker/Mankind is one of the worst hell in a cell in history. Completely overrated.
Yeah still don't care what anyone says, stupid match. One of the matches where you contemplate heavily on what Ric Flair said about Foley "He's a professional stuntman"
To me the greatest HIAC is still the very first. The greatest HIAC of this era is Edge/Taker Summerslam '08. Sorry Trips/Taker. To me HHH/Taker didn't feel like a HIAC match. That match could have played out the exact same way if it were just a regular no-DQ match. The cell served no purpose. Well it kind of did, it kept them locked inside but still I'm just not a fan of the match like most people. Told an amazing story but nowhere near a 5 star match.
I rate HHH/Taker like I did Flair/HBK. Tremendous match, lots of emotion and for that reason it should be 5 stars but I just can't. It's a match where you watch it once and that's it. Maybe twice. But no more than three times really.