[SoupBro]

Punk by far. Wish Rock didnt have to cut his usual jokes, he was good though for the most part but Punk was just on another level. While Rock was going and Punk just stood there no smiles or smirks was great.

[Nostalgia]

Both were awesome. Really enjoyed their segment. I'd give the edge to Punk just for his great promo before The Rock came out, the dude's just exceptional on the mic, must of been talking for like 30 minutes straight. This thread is likely just going to lead to mark wars though, and I wouldn't be surprised if this was closed soon.

[Cookie Monster]

I thought CM Punk.

The last 35 minutes of the show were nothing short of very very good. It was a great promo when CM Punk was out there with Heyman. Slightly disappointed they cut him off to a break though. Then when The Rock was out there, I feel he upped his game even more. I thought Punk killed him but Rock was coming on strong at the end.

I loved the intensity of The Rock though throughout it all. It's going to be one hell of a feud and I think something we can ALL agree on is that after having just a 20 minute promo together, this feud has already topped Rock/Cena.

[UltimateOppitunist]

How can anyone say anything different. "It doesn't matter if you matter"? "cookie puss"? Come on now.

[BKsaaki]

Shorter Punk Marks : WHY IS TEH OCK SAYING SILLEH LINEZ!!!??? Punk is teh god. Take my anus!!
Rock Marks : :FAP: :FAP: :SPLOOSH:
Ricky Ponting Mark : :Blink: :blink:

[Brodus Clay]

both, I'm happy this isnt like Cena/Punk in were they rarely had this kind of back and forth.

[EnemyOfMankind]

Punk and its not even close. I still love Rocky tho

[Punter]

May the odds be ever in each sides favor

[starscreamlive]

I agree.

[Creme De La Creme]

Equal for me. Both were amazing tonight. Punk got way more one on one time, which was fine. That was pretty special, IMO. This is WAY better than Cena/Rock. Punk is actually playing his role, The Rock is actually putting Punk over.... Both were great tonight