Wrestling Forum banner

Which card is better?

Kappa Auction RO16 Match 7 - Shala vs Fringe

2K views 22 replies 20 participants last post by  ITRK93 
#1 ·
Welcome to the Kappa Auction Draft's Round of 16 Match 1 between Shala aka "Ultimate Gohan" and Fringe. The rules for voting are simple - if you issue a vote, you must leave a sentence or two justifying your decision. If you do not do that, the vote doesn't count. This prevents some spam voting or begging for votes from friends around the forum, as it lends some reasoning behind the voting. Thanks in advance for cooperating!

SHALA'S SUPER FIGHTING DOJO Z

1. Normal match. Pinfall/submission: Carlito vs Jeff Jarret

2. Falls count anywhere match: Chris Sabin vs Trent Baretta

3. Normal match. Pinfall/submission: Mickie James vs Beth Phoenix

4. Normal match. Pinfall/submission: Luke Harper vs Kane

5. Tag Team match. Pinfall/submission: Taz & Del Rio vs Jack Swagger & Rosey

6. Normal match. Pinfall/submission: Homicide vs Bad News Barret.

7. Normal match. Pinfall/submission: Sonjay Dutt vs Eugene

8. Triple threat cage match. Prince Puma vs Johnny Mundo vs Justin Gabriel

9. First Blood match: Kazuchika Okada vs Roman Reigns

vs.

Team Fringe and Shane McMahon present:

UWF WINTRY WAR 2015

For the Television Championship:
Drago vs Zack Ryder (w Curt Hawkins)

Cryme Tyme Vs. Otunga and Rotunda (I.R.S).

For the Intercontinental Title: Fatal Four Way*
Lex Luger, Brutus Beefcake, Greg “The Hammer” Valentine, Ron Simmons

Tag Team Championship Tournament Round 1
Meng and Barbarian Vs. Sgt. Slaughter and The Iron Shiek

Tag Team Championship Tournament Round 2
Ivan Koloff and Nikita Koloff Vs. Arn Anderson and Barry Windham

Brusier Brody Vs. Big Boss Man

For the Women’s Championship
Ivelisse Velez Vs. Lita

Tag Team Championship Tournament Round 3
Ivan Koloff and Nikita Koloff Vs. Sgt. Slaughter and The Iron Shiek

For the World Heavyweight Championship RAGE IN A CAGE MATCH*
Cesaro Vs. Muhammed Hassan
 
#6 ·
I'm going with Shala.

I think Fringe's tag with Meng & Barbarian vs. Slaughter and Sheik would've been worth watching but everything else on the card is pish. Don't stress though, this happens to a lot of FIRST TIME DRAFTERS. Including myself and even Shala.

Shala had buys on Harper vs. Kane assuming they're both in their prime, the main event Okada vs. Reigns, and a few solid other mid-card matches as well.
 
#15 ·
Shala gets my vote for Puma vs Mundo vs Justin Gabriel and Okada vs Reigns
 
#16 ·
CASE AGAINST SHALA:
- Dutt vs. Eugene is an absolutely all-time WOAT match
- Could have emphasised the respective histories of the Colons and Jarretts
- Not into LU guys
- Don't feel like the stips fit the guys

CASE FOR SHALA:
- Sabin and Baretta would probably have a good undercard match for NJPW
- Carlito vs. Jarrett would draw in Puerto Rico

CASE AGAINST FRINGE:
- 'The Narcissist' Lex Luger plz. Get it right.
- Hassan vs. a Swiss guy?!?
- Would've liked to have seen Windham and Rotunda together
- Too many foreign heels and not enough US babyfaces to face them

CASE FOR FRINGE:
- Koloffs :mark:. Total mark for Nikita. The original Goldberg.
- Ivelisse vs. Lita is an interesting one.
- Meng and Barb vs. Sympathiser Slaughter and Shiek, in some kind of Bootcamp Match, would be immense

THE DECISION:
I'm sorry to say, Shala's card is the worst I've seen so far. Particularly in light of the fact that he traded me Baretta for Mainstream celebs Big Show AND Mr. T.

Fringe's is also a weak card, in light of the fact that he traded me Sting for a $5m loss.

Fringe wins but there's a lot of work to be done to survive the next round. Maybe pick-up Reigns, Kane and/or Taz.
 
#17 ·
Not a fan of Reigns, but I feel that an Okada and Reigns bout would be fucking stellar.

Voting Shala.
 
#20 ·
Sorry to say this but both cards really do look pretty hit and miss. I was originally gonna go with Shala, but the more I look at Fringe's card the more I like it, so I'm gonna go with him.

Shala only had two matches that interest me in Harper vs. Kane and Okada vs. Reigns, while Fringe has four to five matches I'd happily watch in the tag tourney matches, Brody vs Bossman :)like) and Ivelisse vs. Lita.
 
#23 ·
Shala's card is a bit experimental until it gets to the solid main event of Okada vs. Reigns. :vince$

Fringe's...I....I don't know what draws matches are even there. (although the fatal four way with old timers sounds fun)

Vote goes to Shala for the main event alone and more tolerable undercard to sit through to get to the dream match.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top